Becky was my seventeen-year-old neighbor whom I'd inadvertently met through a chat room, realizing we knew each other only when we arranged to meet for the first time in a local motel. Back home, Becky had brought her best friend Jen, whom she was temporarily staying with, to visit and explore. That night, the girls, promising to be subtle, had gone home to try to get information from Jen's mom, Andrea, about a possible relationship with Becky's mom, Sara (also my ex).
Proving that teens really don't do subtlety, Andrea arrived at my house shortly after the girls had left for their summer soccer camp. She had put things together and straight out asked me about what had happened - deciding honesty was the best policy, and seeing it was clearly a turn-on for Andrea, I'd told her almost everything that had happened. She was hugely aroused by her daughter and best friend being with an older man, who'd also dated her girlfriend. It also became quickly evident that she loved ass play as much as her daughter.
After an afternoon of fucking, oral play, and me cumming deep in Andrea's ass, we sat naked in my living room as our breathing returned to normal.
Sitting, naked and spread, I looked at her as she came to sit on my knee. "Well, that was unexpected," she said as she played with my now sticky and soft cock.
"Will you tell Sara? Will you tell Jen?" I asked as I watched her play with my cock.
Smiling, she kissed my lips. "This was amazing, and you've made me realize I want a permanent future with Sara. But I also want to see you fuck her." As my fickle cock twitched under her fingers, she smiled, adding. "I'll have to see what Sara says. Do you think we should tell them about this afternoon?"
Smiling, I looked to the backdoor, where I'd heard a noise earlier. Not letting Andrea on to my suspicions I made a simple suggestion.
"How about complete transparency and this plan? When they come here this afternoon from soccer, I'll tell them there's been a change of plan. I'll explain that they're both gonna stay here for the next three days, while you do spend some time with Sara. I'll tell them we 'chatted' and you're going to talk to Sara about what's happened, how she feels, and the future?"
She looked at me, shocked. "You mean, give it a shot and let them have what they want for now?"
I nodded, looking at her. Cum leaking from her ass, her nipples hard, and her pussy glistening. I could tell I had surprised her, and it aroused her.
Getting up, she pulled on my hand. "Let's go shower before we ruin this furniture, I'll let you know my reply when you drop me home."
Following her closely up the stairs, holding her hand lightly, I was sure I heard some hushed whispering and the closing of a door.
---------------------------------------------
Excited by our afternoon together, her realization, and the plan, Andrea was keen to get moving. We showered together quickly, her nipples and skin super sensitive from such a strong orgasm earlier. I tried to play and realizing quickly it was too soon, reverted to washing her and she me. I felt close to her like I hadn't for a while. It was as we talked that I realized we were in this plan together, with a potential mixed-up future, somehow. God only knew how the girls would take the proposal, let alone knowledge that, not only had I been intimate with Becky's mom, but now with Jen's mom. I figured time would tell.
We dressed and I dropped Andrea home, exchanging numbers so we could keep in touch and update each other on progress. There was an awkward farewell when we didn't know whether to shake hands, make out or hug - she ended up stroking my semi-hard cock through my pants as I hugged her close. Very odd!
Getting home, I tidied up and prepared myself - work was out of the window. I knew the girls would come straight to my house, and they'd be here soon. I still wondered about the noises I'd heard earlier in the day. Stripping, I decided to get some sun and wait for the girls. Paying special attention to my recently overused cock, I put on moisturizing sun cream.
With a beer in hand, I lay by the secluded pool, as I read my emails and thought about what I would say, and how the conversations might go. Before the end of my second beer, I heard exciting chatter and giggles as the girls walked down the side passage and into the pool area.
Wearing only sunglasses, and 'man-spread', I greeted them as they stopped sharp, open-mouthed. They dropped their bags as they giggled and came over. Becky came straight up, kissing me deeply, passionately, and with a need. Jen stood and watched, hand on her hip. "I hope you've got sun-cream on," she quipped.
As Becky kissed me, practically sucking my tongue into her mouth, I felt her hand wrap around my semi-hard cock and stroke it. Coming up for air, she looked at Jen and nodded. "Yes, well covered, but he'll definitely need some more later."
Standing up, I looked at them both. "You both look hot, you must be hot." Smiling, I started to get up. Hands on their hips, the girls started a half-twerk
With a smile, I suggested. "Jen, why not help Becky." Becky needed no encouragement, lifting her arms above her head for Jen to pull her soccer shirt over her head, leaving her fabulous breasts on display. Playfully, Jen pinged her bra, which led to Becky turning around and pushing Jen into the pool with an almighty splash and hysterical laughter from all of us.
As I turned to pull a soggy Jen from the pool, Becky removed her bra and shorts, hands on hips in only her thong as we turned around. All I could say was "Wow." Her curves were on display, her slightly uneven teen breasts proudly out with hard nipples, I could see her dark trimmed bush through her thong.
Licking my lips, I recovered enough to ask, "Why so overdressed?" She giggled as she looked at Jen, who was pulling her t-shirt over her head.
With a smile, Jen looked at her. "I'll get you back for that."
Throwing her wet clothes to the side, I soon had two nubile teens naked except for their thongs. My cock was hard and at right angles to me, as I looked them both. Picking up the sun cream, I looked at them and pointed at the loungers.
"Both of you, face down. You need sun-cream, and we need to talk"
With a smile and quizzical look on their faces, they lay down side by side. I silently snapped a photo of them, lithe bodies and pert bottoms, with just a string on display as they lay there. I sent it to Andrea, with a message of, "Here we go."
Straddling them, I squirted sun cream on both of their butts. Once again being grateful for ambidexterity, I started to work the cream into their butt cheeks simultaneously, stopping only to pull both of their strings down. I felt them relax into the massage, legs spreading.
First Becky, then Jen spread their legs wider. My fingers eased down their ass cleft, and I pressed against their wet labia, teasing with a back-and-forth motion of my fingers. Their breathing quickened, and I felt Becky press back against me. Now was the time. "How did it go with your mom, Jen? Did you find anything out?"
She turned her head, looking at me. "Yes, but not much. We were really subtle and tried to question, but she didn't say much."
"How subtle do you think you were, did she click?" I asked as I felt a pearl of arousal seep from between Jen's smooth lips.
Eyes closed, lips moving she answered, "We were real subtle, she wouldn't have known. Would she Becky?"
Becky, pushing back on my finger nodded and murmured, "No, not a thing. She doesn't know."
As I moved, sliding a finger into both of them, starting to slowly finger fuck them together, I simply stated, "Really, cos I had a visitor right after soccer practice started."