We found the Motel that Cindy had booked in Rotorua and after unpacking, we walked across the road to McDonald's.
Trays loaded up with hamburgers, fries, and drinks, we found a table. I was impressed that Cindy only allowed Ryan water, but with the promise of a small sip of Natalie’s coke, ‘if he behaved himself’.
I sat next to Cindy, our thighs touching. Several times she reached down and rubbed my thigh, trying to be discrete but not fooling Natalie who, sat opposite with Ryan, watched us with a mixture of contempt and what might have been envy.
When Cindy went to the lady's room, Natalie looked over at me and said, "You're leaving in the morning, right?"
I sighed and looked back saying, "If that's what you want."
"Yes," she answered her voice was less convincing than before.
"Don't you think that's going to hurt your sister, is this what she wants?”
"No more than when you leave her when we get to Wellington."
"Maybe I won't leave. I don’t have a girlfriend there or any other ties," I said half-serious.
"You'll leave, I know what guys are like."
“So you're grouping me in with all guys, yet you don’t really know me at all?” I asked, a bit annoyed. For someone so young to profess to know about all guys, she was just showing herself to be very narrow-minded, I thought.
Natalie nodded her head, but before she could answer, Cindy came back and sat down next to me. "You guys getting to know one another?" she asked when she saw our faces.
"Yeah, Natalie thinks she knows me really well now," I said sarcastically, looking at her with more sadness than anger.
I saw Natalie's face turn red with either anger or embarrassment.
Cindy took in the atmosphere, then asked me if I would take Ryan back to the Motel. She wanted a quiet word with Natalie.
When Ryan and I got back to the motel, I helped him do his teeth, et cetera, then put him in the single bed opposite mine. I figured I would leave first thing in the morning and not encourage Cindy to come to my room that night. I figured it would just stir things between the sisters, and Natalie was right, in that there really was no long term future for Cindy and me, as I actually did have a girl I was a bit keen on in Wellington. But didn’t know where that was going to go, as I’d only taken her out once.
About half an hour later, the girls returned, Natalie looking very downcast, and a bit sorry for herself. Cindy checked that Ryan was fast asleep, then directed Natalie to sit by me. She rummaged around in the box of kitchen supplies that I had brought in from the car and brought out a bottle of wine. She carried it, and a bottle opener over for me to open. Then went back to the kitchen and returned with three glasses.
“Am I allowed?” Asked Natalie. As Cindy handed her a glass and I started to pour.
“Of course, you are. You’re well past the age of consent. And I want you to loosen up and admit to Dave that you have a crush on him.”
Natalie gasped out a denial, then did not know where to look, finally dropping her gaze to the floor, blushing bright pink.
“Natalie informs me that you are leaving us in the morning, and she’s admitted to me that she put pressure on you. We have been sitting over at Mcdonald's, arguing the reasons why, which I might add; Natalie really didn’t understand herself. And also, why she keeps acting the way she does with you. But I understand why - she has a massive crush on you.”
Again, Natalie tried to object to this. But Cindy just shut her down, but leaning forward, she took Natalie’s hands in her own and carried on.
“You are embarrassed with my disclosing this to Dave, but he needs to know why, and that I am going to insist he stays with us until we get to Wellington. Neither you nor I want him to leave, do you?”
Natalie hung her head, but nodded, admitting she did not want me to leave.
Still holding her hands, Cindy spoke quietly, “I won’t go and see Dave tonight. When we have finished our wine, let’s you and I go to bed. We can have a good long talk about all this.”
True to her word, Cindy did not creep in to see me that night. I had a restless sleep, wondering how I was to approach either of them now. I was glad I didn’t have to leave but was worried the next couple of days were going to be really awkward between us all.
I needn’t have worried, I was woken by Cindy breezing into my room the next morning.
"It's about time you woke up, sleepyhead," she said with a smile. "We tried to stay out as long as we could but Justin is getting cranky and we have to check out."
“Bloody hell! I never sleep in,” was my reply, as I rubbed my eyes and looked at my watch. It was after 9:00 am.
When we had checked out, we took Ryan down to the Whakarewarewa thermal park and spend about three hours there, looking at boiling mud pools and Geysers, etc. It was a different Natalie that I saw that day, her normal sullen attitude was gone; she even smiled at me, almost flirting.
About 3:00 pm, we headed back to the car to drive to Taupo. Natalie came and sat beside me, whilst Cindy took Ryan to the bathroom.
"Dave, I wanted to say that I'm sorry about the way I've treated you and the bad things that I said."
"You don't need to apologise to me, Natalie. I don’t always see people as they are, and realise after that I have made a mistake. At least, we get to change things. I’ve often found out much later when it’s way too late to apologise.”
She pushed her thigh against mine and nervously took my hand, squeezing it.
When I saw Cindy coming back toward us, I felt Natalie move slightly away from me and pull her hand from mine.
"Everybody ready to go," Cindy said with a smile. If she saw me holding Natalie’s hand she didn't show it. So we all climbed in the car and headed off for Taupo.
Halfway there, I spoke to Cindy, ”Let's get a better room for the night. I don’t mind paying a bit more if you are OK?”
"Sounds great, it would be nice for us all to stay in a posh place for a night."
When we arrived, we picked out one of the nice motels around the lake and got a room that had two bedrooms and a living room with a sofa bed. It also had a bathroom and a small kitchenette between the main bedroom and living room. The real bonus was that it had a spa pool out on our private deck, with views out over the lake.
While Cindy sorted out Ryan, Natalie and I went and found a supermarket and bought some food, etc. She was now much nicer to be around. But I was still keeping my distance, worrying about crossing any invisible lines. But it seemed to me that she was trying hard to please.
I was also unsure how to act around Cindy, as I was concerned that any wrong move could stir up an incident between the sisters and me.
Cindy cooked us dinner, she tried to stop me from helping her, but having been flatting now since I was seventeen, I was quite used to working around the kitchen and didn’t want to laze around while she had to do everything. After dinner, we watched some TV then got ready for bed.
I was made to take the double bed and the girls crashed in the other bedroom as it had the two single beds. Ryan, again, was to get the single bed/settee out in the lounge. I took a shower, it was one of those over the bath showers. I’d just hopped out and was drying myself when Cindy poked her head through the door and asked if Ryan could have a bath.
“Yes, send him in, I’ll bath him. While you guys get yourselves sorted.”
I was playing with Ryan, splashing water all over the bathroom when Cindy came in to see what all the giggling was about.
“Are you guys are making a mess," she said, trying to act stern but with a smile on her face.
“Sorry," I said, water dripping off me, as I turned to smile at a giggling Ryan. "I guess we got caught mate," I said and splashed water on him again.
"Can someone else get a bath," Natalie said lightly as she joined us.
"Alright, we're done," I said. "We'll go watch TV."
But we had hardly sat down and Ryan was fast asleep in the armchair. I carried him over to his bed and Cindy came over and tucked him in.
A little while later, I went into the kitchen to get a glass of water. I saw that the bathroom door was slightly cracked open. I looked in discretely, thinking it was Cindy in the bathroom. I almost gasped when I saw the reflection of Natalie in the mirror standing with only a pair of panties on, brushing her hair.
I wanted to turn away but I was frozen like a deer in the headlights as I looked at her half-naked form.
I had not realised Natalie's breasts were so large. The brown nipples were as big around as two-shilling pieces and stuck out like pencil erasers. The orbs were full and firm without a hint of sag.
I don't know when it happened but at some point, Natalie noticed that I was looking in on her.
I saw with a shock that her eyes were staring directly at me. Then I felt a thrill run through me when she didn't turn away or close the door. She simply stared at me as I looked at her and then went back to brushing her hair. I watched her breasts jiggle behind her arms as she moved the brush through her long hair. Finally, after a while, her arms dropped to her side, almost like an adult giving in to a child, letting me have the full view of her now heaving breasts. Then I saw a little indulgent smile come to her lips and maybe just a hint of pride as she straightened her back slightly, thrusting her breasts upward.
"Are you done yet," Cindy said, coming into the bathroom from the other side. Natalie jumped in surprise and turned quickly away. I moved back, hoping that Cindy hadn't seen me.
I was watching television again when I heard the shower running. When the water was turned off, I went to the bathroom door and quietly opened it, hoping that it was Cindy in there this time. Fortunately, it was. She was standing at the mirror in her panties, just like Natalie had been ten minutes before.
When I pushed the door open, I saw her turn and smile at me, then open her arms. Quickly, I stepped into the still steamy room and wrapped my arms around her. Her still-wet breasts pressed to my shirt as our lips met. I reached down and grasped her panty-covered ass cheeks, feeling the silky soft material in my hands. I reached my hands under the material and held her bare skin.
"Oh God," Cindy whispered as I bent to kiss her breast.
"You have a gorgeous ass," I said as I continued to squeeze her ass cheeks. I pulled away from her and slid to my knees. I turned her around and pushed her until she was bent toward the mirror. She looked at me over her shoulder in surprise as I knelt behind her, looking at her sexy panty covered ass. Slowly I reached up and pulled the panties up tightly between the cheeks, loving the way her smooth cheeks separated. Then I began to pull her panties down, slowly revealing the crack between her firm white ass cheeks and the sexy tan lines on both sides of her ass.
Cindy gasped when I gently kissed the inside of first one smooth cheek, then the other. I smiled up at her and used my hands to spread her cheeks open to reveal her little rose.
"Oh God, Dave," Cindy moaned as she felt my tongue come out and touch the top of her crack.
I felt her begin to shiver as my tongue slowly moved down between the damp cheeks, leaving a trail of saliva. Ever so slowly my tongue moved lower and lower. I knew that she was enjoying what I was doing when her ass lifted up slightly and pressed back at me.
I pulled back and looked at her exposed little rear hole. It was pink and wrinkled, almost winking at me, pulsing. We both moaned as I moved my head back and brought my tongue to the tiny hole, licking it with the flat of my tongue. Then I put my lips around it and began to suck the crinkled skin into my mouth.
"Oh, oh, oh, oh. Suck my ass, suck my ass, oh God, Dave, you're driving me crazy," Cindy grunted as she pushed her ass back at my mouth.
Then as I pressed my tongue into her back passage, her tight little hole opened and letting my tongue delve inside. I pressed deeper, pulling her cheeks wide apart. Suddenly, I was totally shocked when I felt Cindy shudder and shake as a climax ripped through her. I hadn't even touched her swollen sex lips yet.
I didn't let her recover before I pushed her around until her ass was against the counter. I lifted her until she was sitting on the vanity. Her eyes were wild with lust as she looked down at me. Then I pushed her thighs up and spread them wide apart, forcing her back against the mirror, until she was totally open before me. My mouth moved immediately between her legs.
"Ahhh!!!" Cindy moaned as my mouth covered her dripping lips.
My tongue pushed deep into her open hole, spreading her swollen lips. I could taste her sweet juice on my lips as I worked to bring her pleasure. I felt her hands on the back of my head and looked up at her face. She was leaning back against the mirror and her eyes were closed, her face a mask of undisguised pleasure.
In my peripheral vision, I sensed movement. Diverting my eyes to the mirror, I saw that Natalie was standing just outside the bathroom door watching me eat her sister. She still had only her panties on and had one hand inside rubbing herself, the other squeezing her swollen nipple. When our eyes met, she didn't look away. I could see her breasts heaving with excitement.
Natalie stood there and watched me eat her sister for a long time, her hand slowly moving inside her panties.
I made quite a show of it, spreading Cindy’s legs, lapping her with broad tongue strokes, and making sloppy sucking sounds. I would take the swollen inner lips in my mouth and pull my head back, stretching them from her body. When I let them go they would spring back to her like a rubber band. Then I would stiffen my tongue and move my head back and forth, penetrating her juicy hole repeatedly.
All the while, Natalie stood watching, rubbing herself with her fingers and pinching her nipple.
Cindy was totally oblivious to the show that she and I were providing. She was too far gone to even care.
"Oh God, Dave, eat me, eat meee!!!" Cindy moaned. "Yes, yes, make me cum, make me cum. Ohhh!!!" she practically screamed, her legs wrapping around my head as her body convulsed in pleasure.
"Ohhh my Goddd!!!" Cindy hissed, gasping for breath as her body shook with her climax.
I had a difficult time keeping my mouth in place as her hips bucked up and down.
When her thighs finally relaxed from around my head I stood up, pulled her to her feet, and kissed her, sharing the sweet juice on my lips. Then I pressed firmly on her shoulders. She knew what I wanted and went to her knees, quickly stripping my pants and shorts down my legs.
After I had pulled my shirt over my head, I looked at the opened door again and saw that Natalie was still there, her panties had now slipped down her thighs, and her fingers buried in her crotch.
I smiled as I saw her eyes go to my throbbing erection, now held in her sister's fist.
My hips moved forward as I reached down and grabbed Cindy's head. I watched Natalie's lust-filled eyes as I moved my shaft in and out of her sister's willing mouth. I saw Natalie lick her lips absentmindedly as she focused on her sister sucking on me.
"Oh suck me, suck my cock," I said, for Natalie's benefit. I even pulled out of her mouth and ran the dripping head around Cindy's face, smearing my juice across her cheeks. My eyes watched Natalie's lust-filled face as I teased Cindy with my pulsing rod. Then I moaned as I pushed back into her open mouth and grabbed her head in my hands. My hips began to work back and forth. I intended to cum in her mouth.
However, before I reached my peak, Cindy pulled away and stood up. I was only briefly disappointed because she whispered in my ear, "Fuck me, Dave."
"Oh yes," I responded as I kissed her lips passionately.
"Dave," Cindy said.
"Yes."
"I want you to... I want uh... I want you to fuck me in the ass," Cindy said in a rush, her face colouring.
"Oh my God," I moaned, my penis throbbing so hard that I was afraid that I was going to cum right there. I had hardly ever attempted anal sex, and when I had, I had always been rebuffed, but I was more than willing to try it.
Cindy turned in my arms and bent over the counter, pressing her ass back at me, leaning forward, her eyes closed. She had turned away from the door, and so still was not aware that Natalie was stood just outside it.
My hands were shaking as I spread her cheeks apart and looked at her tight little hole again. It looked so small that I was worried that I was going to hurt her. However, she had obviously done this before.
Then remembering Natalie, I looked apologetically over at her, taking in the expression on her face. Her eyes were as wide as saucers, shock evident on her face. But when I tried to indicate to her should I stop, she hastily shook her head.
I reached over and picked up a bottle of baby oil from the counter, and poured a stream of oil on the top of Cindy's ass crack, and watched as the slippery liquid slowly traveled down toward her little hole. Using my fingers, I rubbed it around, coating her pulsing hole, then pressed one finger on the hole until it slipped inside.
Cindy groaned as I pressed deeper, feeling the warmth of her anal canal as it gripped my finger tightly. I added a second finger, stretching her open as I forced them inside. When I felt that she was lubricated enough inside, I pulled my fingers out and placed the head of my penis on the pink hole. Again I reached for the baby oil and squirted more oil onto the head and shaft.
"Oh yes, oh yes, fuck me, Dave, fuck my ass," Cindy said breathlessly.
I placed the impossibly large head of my penis on the tight hole of her anus and pressed. Cindy moaned and pressed back at me as the little hole stretched. I moaned as her back passage opened and the head slipped inside. As her incredibly tight anal ring snapped around the crown of my penis head, I felt the urge to cum right then. I fought to hold back my climax wondering how I could get the rest of my shaft into her body before I shot my load. Then Cindy pressed her ass back toward me.
I watched in amazement as the shaft slipped inside her stretched anus. Slowly it disappeared into her body, her sheath caressing every inch of me like a warm velvet glove. She voiced little whimpers of pleasure and pain as her ass pulsed around my shaft. I pushed forward, and we continued to press into each other until the entire length of my penis had disappeared.
"Be still... be still... just a minute," Cindy moaned, wanting me to let her get used to my shaft inside her body.
I fought desperately to hold still, wanting to pound into her. Still, I waited, letting her adjust. It was probably only seconds but seemed so much longer before I felt Cindy begin to move. As she moved forward, I pulled back, letting half my shaft come out of her body. It looked like I was turning her anal tube inside out as it fought to hold me inside. I pushed back in, bringing a muffled scream from Cindy.
"Yes, yes, fuck me now, please fuck meee!!!"
I didn't wait to be told twice. Within seconds, my penis was moving in and out of her body, aided by the slick baby oil. I watched as my shaft pulled out then disappeared back inside, my balls slapping her dripping sex lips. Soon I was moving in and out like a jackhammer, my thighs slapping loudly on her ass cheeks.
“Dave, Dave, Dave, oh my God," Cindy moaned. "Fuck my ass hard, fuck me, fuck me!!!"
"Ohhh," I moaned as our bodies worked together. I had never felt anything so pleasurable in my young life. Cindy's tight asshole milked me, squeezing me like nothing I had felt before.
"I'm going to cum," Cindy moaned through clenched teeth. I slipped one hand around onto her tummy and then down to her clit and worked it hard.
"Yes, cum baby, cum for me. I'm close, God I'm going to cum too," I moaned as I felt my balls tighten. I looked up and saw Natalie looking at our sweating bodies, her own hands moving rapidly in her groin. This tipped me over the edge. I could not have held back now if a policeman walked into the room. I watched mesmerised as Natalie shuddered and her hips jerked in a rapid fucking motion. Her legs shook, as pleasure ripped through her. All this as my cum began to rush up the shaft. I could feel the head of my penis swell inside Cindy's ass and begin to squirt my sperm deep into her bowels.
"I can feel it," Cindy screamed. "I can feel your cum, oh yes, oh yes I'm cummmiiinnnggg!!!"
I bent over Cindy's back and grabbed her breasts in my hands, my hips moving in a blur as I filled her anal cavity with my juice. Cindy's convulsions made her ass squeeze even tighter on me, bringing me incredible pleasure.
I felt Cindy's shuddering slow, as the last of my juice squirted into her. When I started to pull out, I felt her hands reach back and grab my hips. "No, not yet," she whispered.
I held still, my shaft buried deep inside her. There were still ripples of pleasure rolling down Cindy's anal walls. Before my penis got soft she began to squeeze her ass on me like a vice. Suddenly, incredibly, I felt my penis begin to harden again. I had never gotten hard again so quickly after a climax.
"Fuck me again," Cindy said when she felt my penis at full erection inside her ass again.
My hips began to move back and forth again, aided this time by the baby oil and my own cum. I could see the sticky mixture begin to seep out as my speed increased until we were again rutting into each other.