Only at the bar did it occur to me that I couldn't carry so many drinks at once. As I turned to bring the wine and two of the beers, I saw my wife push a card, a key card I guessed, into Ben's shirt pocket. His hand was between her legs. I acted like I hadn't seen. I had to make three trips to bring all the drinks to the table.
We were from out of town, but we had been scoping this place for months. It was a swinger club that got mixed reviews on yelp. Some liked it for its lack of pressure and its inclusiveness. Certainly, that appealed to us as newbies who felt a little sensitive about our middle-aged bodies. Some disliked it for the very same reason. To hell with them, we had said, they're turned off by curves, we're turned off by shallow people. The feeling was mutual.
The reviews mentioned couples-only areas, private rooms, a dance floor, and a BYO bar. They even mentioned that the club allowed in thirteen single men the first Friday of the month…though some said the guys tended toward sleazy. "Let's give it a try," I said. "if it looks sketchy, we'll go back to the hotel and have our own wild night fueled by the thrill of having at least sought the opportunity."
When we got there—Faith dressed in a black dress that accentuated her cleavage and her ample ass and me in a pair of jeans and a sports jacket—we realized the sleazy single guys were out of luck. All thirteen of the night's single guys were piling out of one of those monstrous Hummer-stretched-into-a-limo things (some already well into the bottle), and the last one, wearing a blindfold and a dopey grin, was helped from the door by his friends just as we walked up. Most of them were in their 30s (some a little younger, some a little older) and they came in all shapes, sizes, and colors. One of them pulled the blindfold off the last guy and they all laughed. He smiled, confused. "Oh cool...we're clubbing?" He didn't sound thrilled.
The guy at his right elbow put his hand on his shoulder and laughed. "You said you were worried about getting bored with married sex, so we brought you to see what wild couples do, brother! This is a swing club full of MILFs and cougars and, Ben, we're the only single guys in the joint!"
Ben seemed unconvinced…but we didn't stick around to hear the rest of the conversation, we were already going in. Two of the party guys held the door for us. They made no effort to take their eyes off my wife's cleavage. She smiled brightly and thanked them as if they had just thrown their coats into a puddle so she could keep her feet dry. I couldn't wait to make a comment to Faith about the guys coming in, but my heart raced in near-panic when we checked in with the host and hostess, got the house rules, and entered another set of doors. The place was big - a square bar in the middle of the room, a small dance floor, lots of large and plush booths, and a roped-off staircase in the back labeled “couples only.” One booth was packed with four couples who were laughing loudly. Scattered throughout were other couples greeting each other like old, bold friends... They were all so confident. No matter their age or shape, they radiated sexiness with their confidence.
When we came in, Faith clutched my arm and I squeezed her shoulder. We fantasized constantly about including others in our sex life, but we lacked one essential ingredient to make it happen: though we had tried online ads and even porn theaters, at the point of speaking to another couple, we both tended to freeze and cling to each other in a way that drove others off.
We already knew that while the club had a bar, they had no liquor license. So we poured drinks from the wine and liquor we had brought and left our cooler at the bar. We found a booth at the edge of the empty dance floor that had empty booths on either side to act as a buffer. Thirty seconds inside our first swing club and we were already as far away from other people as we could get. I made up my mind to stay for an hour before we beat a retreat. Faith seemed just as uncomfortable.
Then the bachelor party came in. All eyes turned toward them. They stood in a herd, then moved in our direction to the only group of open tables in the place. Soon, we were surrounded as the party crowded into the booths on either side of us. Many of them were eager and they found ways to be noticed (at the bar, at the jukebox, crossing the dance floor). In ever smaller groups they drifted away from the herd and joined other couples and groups. They were having a blast.
But the groom and a few of his friends were less confident. They crowded into the booth to our right and exuded unease. We could hear them talking above the music about their bolder friends, laughing nervously. Ben, the groom, said very little, but after thirty minutes or so, he said "I've been with her a long time. I don't know any come-ons. I don't know how to speak first."
If there's one thing that can put a shy person at ease, it's the knowledge that the other person is even more nervous than they. So maybe it was that urge to be helpful, mingled with wine and growing lust, that caused Faith to turn in her seat and say over the back of the booth, as cool and casual as if they were old friends, "You just say, 'Hi, I'm Ben. What's your name?'" I was as stunned as they were. I don't think I closed my mouth for several minutes. But it didn't matter. They began to chat across the back of the booth and no one paid the least attention to me. They each introduced themselves to Faith using exactly the formula she had proposed.
"Hi, I'm Ben. What's your name?" He got up and offered his hand over the back of the booth. He had sandy brown hair and was tall and average in build. I noticed his hands were big. I knew she liked that.
"Hi, I'm Michael. What's your name?" He waved and smiled. He was a little shorter than Ben, with thinning black hair going to grey, and he wore square glasses.
"Hi, I'm Tommy. What's your name?" He was shorter yet, a little younger than the others, with a hipster haircut and a thick blond beard.
"Hi, I'm Jason. What's your name?" He was a little heavier than the others, about my build, but he was the tallest of the group and had red hair and freckles and a very shy smile.
"Hi, I'm David. What's your name?" He was a black man built like a linebacker, and he was the one who had spoken to Ben as they were getting out of the limo. Of the group in that booth, he was clearly still in the booth out of loyalty to Ben as he spoke confidently and could easily have been mingling elsewhere.
They were mostly coworkers, though one (I think Michael) was Ben's college friend or something. Jason and Tommy wore wedding rings. They were all grateful that Faith had broken the ice and I was astonished that she was soon laughing and joking with the whole group. Soon, they asked if they could “buy” her a drink. "I’ll have a wine from the red cooler." She pointed to our cooler among the others by the bar, then reached behind her to touch my hand. "And another bourbon neat for him." The guys briefly looked around her at me, as if noticing me for the first time, and Michael and Jason trotted over to the bar area.