So imagine my surprise, when one night at a neighbor’s get-together, Abby brought up Kayla just as our hostess was opening the second bottle of red saying, “I think you two would be great in bed together.”
My jaw almost hit the table. “What did you just say, dear?”
“I said you and Kayla would be great in bed together. Don’t you think?”
“I … I never gave it a thought until this moment,” I replied.
“Well, what do you think?”
“Ab, I don’t want Kayla. I want you,” I said, finding myself breathing hard. To prove my words I pulled her knee up onto my leg. The long tablecloth hid my action from the others dining with us.
“You wouldn’t fuck her?” she said sotto-voice.
“You’re joking, right?” I replied, pretending to wipe my mouth with a napkin.
“No, but … later we could pretend that I was her.”
“What?”
“Just the once, baby, it’ll really spice things up.”
Now, we had role played all sorts of shit---had done so ever since we first jumped each other’s bones---in fact, we had pushed enough boundaries to last a long while, but this was different. The aforementioned Kayla was six feet away from us, and although she wasn’t looking at us, I thought Abby was bringing the subject much too close to home.
I shook my head and kissed my wife. not caring that the others saw us. I was hoping to change the subject, but Abby wasn’t having it.
“Come on,” she whispered. “Promise me you’ll call me Kayla as you fuck me. I want you to call me by her name; tell me how much better she is. Tell her I’m a stupid little whore and you’re in love with her. Tell her you want her more.”
Abby kept at it for the remainder of the evening, even pushing me into Kayla’s arms for a goodnight kiss as we were leaving our host and hostesses' home.
The weirdness continued the following weekend when Abby whispered in my ear during dinner at Club Jonny’s.
“That girl at the next table wants to fuck you. She told me the other day when her mouth was on my cunt.”
I smiled and pretended I don’t hear her, but when she moved her hand to my thigh and touched me, she knew her words had registered with a high C.
Abby looked around the room taking everything in before blithely resuming her previous line of conversation without missing a beat. “When was the last time you fucked my ass?” This with a Mona Lisa smile accompanying the words.
I don’t answer her, but I spent the next few minutes recalling that particular event while she sat there looking at me as if I’d said something incredibly funny.
Know this---It takes at least two to play any real game. I had been doing a lot of thinking since her remarks about Kayla the week before. She had been incredibly hot in bed that night, begging me to call her Kayla until I finally did so. Less than a minute later she’d had the first of two huge orgasms that left the both of us reeling senselessly.
Inasmuch as I had enjoyed the sex every bit as much as Abby, I decided to throw my hat in the ring as it were, and in as challenging a tone as I could muster up, I leaned over her and pretended to push a lock of hair behind her ear and said, “Speaking of your ass, I want you to take it into the powder room; pick an empty stall, bend over and lift your dress and wait for me. I’ll be joining you momentarily.”
Her blush was almost imperceptible. She mumbled something I didn’t understand and excused herself. I waited a full minute before standing. Looking down at her chair I saw the wet spot she’d left, and casually dried it with my napkin before following her into the powder room.
***********************************************************************************
Later that night as I took her anally for the second time, she moaned, “I want you to do all the things
to her that you do to me.” “Caught off-guard, I asked, “Do what to who, Abby?”
“To Kayla, of course; those little things you do so well, like fucking me, making me cum so hard and so long. Anal, oral … you know.”
I rolled Abby onto her back and held her arms above her head with one hand. She was covered in sweat and both our bodies were near exhaustion. When I let her go, she knew well enough not to move. After two years I no longer had
to tie her up.
“I’ll fuck her tomorrow,” I whispered as I pushed two fingers inside her. Abby arched her back as I lifted her off the bed with my hand. I slammed into her, my hand a blur as I bit her neck.
After she came on my fingers, I whispered, “Maybe I’ll let you undress her and hold her down while I play with her. Maybe I’ll let you push her to her knees and hold her hair as she gets me hard.”
Abby started moaning louder, but only half her noises were because of what I was doing to her; the other half was her thinking about what I was telling her we might do to Kayla.
I was proven right about this when I added: “If you’re good I’ll let you slap her face before pulling her pretty lips to your cunt. Would you like that? Do you want to close your thighs around her head as I fuck her from behind?”
“YES!” she moaned eagerly, “I DO want to kneel over her mouth and pull her hair.”
I hadn’t expected this forceful a reaction from her, and goaded by it, I added a third finger.
“UGH!” she grunted, and pressed down against my fingers.
Abby’s nipples were harder than I had ever seen them. “I want to bite her fingers and scratch her thighs,” she moaned between pig-like snorts. “I want to drown her in my cunt as I tell her she’s almost a good girl. I want to fuck her harder than you’ve ever fucked me.”
Abby was cumming before all the words were out of her mouth. I let my body weight pin her to the mattress and glanced into the bedside mirror and saw myself with one hand in her hair and the other in her snatch as she shook and screamed out her pleasure.
I kissed her and she moaned into my mouth. Then she was trembling for long minutes, her vagina clenching so tightly around my fingers I began wishing it was my cock inside her.
“I think she’s going to like us,” I said when Abby collapsed beneath me.
“You really mean what you said back them?” she asked before kissing me, and pulling my cock inside her.
She was in the kitchen when I came home the next day.
“You’re later than usual, honey,” Abby said, with pent-up excitement in her eyes. The dining room table was set, and there were flowers as a center-piece. The candles, already lit were burned down halfway.
“Why didn’t you call?”
“Sorry about that, Ab,” I answered, “I was caught up in something. I’ll tell you about it after I shower.”
She was standing by the sink, her cute derriere resting on the edge of the kitchen table.
“You’re going to shower? But everything’s ready … more than ready,” she whined.
"I wasn’t at work, Abby.”
“But …” a shocked expression came over her face. "Then where were you?”
"Don't worry," I said, "I'll tell you everything after I shower.”
“No,” she said and came up to me and sniffed my shoulder, then my hair. “You … you were with someone. A … woman!” she said accusingly, and her eyes filled with tears.
“I was going to tell you after I … washed her scent off me---Kayla’s scent,” I added.
Abby’s eyes went wide. The tears started coming and wouldn’t stop.
"I called her from work, basically invited myself over to her place.”
“You didn’t!” she said, but knew I had.
“I told her I had something to tell her; and that I'd rather tell her in private."
Shaking her head as if trying to clear it, Abby said, “Um, so what did you have to tell her?”
"Nothing," I said. "I lied."
Abby stared at me in disbelief. “You didn’t!”
“You’re repeating yourself, Abby. She met me at the entrance to her apartment and we started up the stairs.
She lives on the second floor, you know.”
Taking a big breath, Abby said slowly, “I know.”
"Well, I found myself staring at her ass. It really is a nice one, you know?”
Abby nodded her head, consciously or unconsciously I couldn’t tell, so I kept going.
“I was thinking of what you said last night, Ab.”
“Huh?” she said as if suddenly pulled from a deep dream.
“Remember? You said you wanted me to do all the things to Kayla that I’ve done with you.” Abby’s eyes closed as I went on. “Those little things … like fucking you, making you cum so hard and so long. Anal, oral … you know.”
“Ohhhh.”
“Remember what I said next, Abby?”
“Noooo!” It came out as a wail of denial.
“I told you I’d fuck her tomorrow.”
“You … you’re making this up!” Abby sniffed, and then wiped her arm across her nose, leaving a trail of slug-like mucus
on it.
“Anyway, I grabbed her by the arm and made her stop on the stairwell.
"You screwed her on the stairs---in public?”
"Well first I asked her if she wanted to see it.”
“You … you really asked her that?”
I looked directly into Abby’s eyes and said, “Sure. Anyway, Kayla turned around and looked at me. And that's when I asked her if she wanted to see my cock."
"Oh, my God. I can't believe you really said that."
"Well, I did."
“And what did she say?" Abby said in a hoarse whisper.
"Oh, she just looked at me, then looked at my bulge and nodded.
"So … you showed it to her?” Abby said after licking her dry lips.
“Yeah … I did, Abby.”
“What … what did she do?”
“She watched me stroke it.”
“Was it hard?”
“Silly question, Ab, of course it was.”
Abby was silent for a while. She was still leaning against the kitchen table. Then she pressed her crotch into the pointed corner and asked, “Did you jerk off for her?”
Abby's neck was reddening, I could only imagine how flushed she was elsewhere. I didn’t reply just then, choosing to watch as her hips began to move in a very small circular way as ground her pussy against the table’s corner, trying to get off on my story.
“Did Kayla say anything during this time?”
"She certainly did. That's one nasty friend you've got there."
“OHHH!” Abby gasped involuntarily.
"That’s exactly what she said, Abby.