I looked at both of them as they looked at each other. There was concern on both their faces. I mean damn it, my wife had cheated with her new girlfriend and Shelly was afraid of what I was going to do.
Eve began, "Ed, I almost jumped Shelly when I got her naked at your house. Shelly has an incredible body, as you know. It was so much better than I had hoped. She is the most beautiful thing. It's like a dream for me. I wanted her so badly my pussy was soaked.
I restrained myself, and we drove to my house for me to change. When I had her in my bedroom, it was like I was a spider and had Shelly in my web. I did a little strip act for her as I undressed, hoping to light her fuse. I know it was lit already. Her eyes were full of lust, and she looked so horny, but we didn't do anything. I asked her to help me dress. Shelly fitted my bra, feeling my breasts, and helped me step into my thong panties. I could feel her hot breath on my skin as she pulled the thong in place, covering my bald pussy.
I was trembling with desire at that moment, so I faked the fact that I had to pee and ran to the bathroom to get away from her before I attacked her. The sexual tension was so thick we needed a machete to hack through it. I came back and rushed to get dressed so we could leave.
We met the girls and had a wonderful time. We had a delicious meal, lots of shots, and crazy drinks. I danced with each girl, but I dominated Shelly, and I was ready to fuck her right on the dance floor.
Ed, you must know that Shelly only reacted to me and was never aggressive. It was all me. I finally needed to feel her, so I dragged her to the ladies' room. I pulled her into a stall and looked into her eyes. She was dazed, but when I kissed her, she melted into me, and I took full advantage. I pulled up her skirt and pushed my hand into her thong. Her pussy was flooding, so my fingers easily slipped into her, rubbing her G-spot. I rubbed her clit with my thumb as I went in for the kill. In seconds, Shelly started cumming on my fingers, trembling and moaning into my mouth. She came so hard she almost collapsed, so I had to hold her up. I kissed her softly, lovingly, until she gathered herself.
When our breathing slowed, I whispered, 'Let's get out of here, your house!'
Shelly bit her lip and nodded; yes, we snuck out the back door and found my car; once inside, I jumped Shelly, kissing her, and we started making out like teenagers.
After we kissed and felt each other up, we needed a better place, so I drove Shelly home, and for the rest of the night, we had incredible lesbian sex. We fucked each other in all the ways lesbian fuck."
Eve stopped talking and took a drink of water.
I looked at Shelly. She was chewing her lip and squirming in her seat, wanting to talk.
"So, Shelly, take it from here," I suggested.
Shelly looked at Eve, then at me. She drank coffee and then started.
"It is hard to add much to what Eve has told you. I will add that I had never thought about cheating on you or being with a woman until Eve started to hit on me and talk about lesbian loving.
Eve told me about lesbian loving and I my weakened state, convinced me it would not be the same cheating, as if I had some guy with a big, hard cocked fucking me all the time.
Ed, I love you so much and have missed you so badly. I lost control, and once things started I was swept up in all the lust and couldn't stop it. Sex with Eve was incredible, she is a fantastic lover. Everything about it was so different. It was not better than sex with you Ed, which is also incredible, but lady love is completely different. I know you don't want to hear that, but Eve did things to me is that I had experienced with you, but Eve’s way was so much better. She made me cum so many times. She knew every place to kiss, touch, rub, bite, and God; she could eat pussy.
Ed, you are an incredible lover and amazing when you eat my pussy, but I am sorry to say that Eve is a twenty on a ten scale, and you are a full ten out of ten. It's not that you do anything wrong. It is just that Eve does everything so much more right. It is because a woman knows what a woman needs, and as good as any man is, they will never eat pussy as good as a woman. I’m sorry!
Dildo’s and a strap-on are a different story. As good as that big black strap-on felt fucking my horny pussy it can never compare to your beautiful hard cock, Ed. I mean, your cock is hot pulsing and alive while the strap-on is just not the same. The feeling, no heat, and texture are all totally different. They are plastic and are not alive. There is the physical part, a woman's hips don't move like a man's do. Though a woman can fuck another woman, a woman is designed to receive a good fucking, not to deliver one. So, a man will always be the superior fucker, never a woman.
Ed, when I took the therapist’s advice and I went out last night, I had no plans to get laid by a man or woman, I was just testing the lesbian waters. But once Eve rescued me from the lesbian, and started dancing with me, my sexual antenna was standing up tall. Our bodies pressed together, and our hands were all over each other. God, my pussy was dripping wet. Then Eve dragged me off the dance floor to the bathroom and into a stall. I was so horny I was ready for anything and everything. I wanted it all. I am sorry.
Ed, it all started when we had our Zoom talk yesterday. Normally I can get off while we talk giving me some sexual and emotional relief, but yesterday for some reason I could not get off and cum while we were on the Zoom. That left me so fucking horny for you, baby. I needed you so badly right then. But there was no way since you weren't here, like it has been for the past seven months. God, it is so damn hard when you are away. I stay horny all the time, and I have to fight my urges every day. I am so sorry Ed. I am just a horny woman craving sex.”
Shelly started to cry as she stopped for a minute. She drank coffee and wiped her eyes. I could feel her pain. I experienced some of the same thing, but I could jerk off everyday and did most days as did all the guys.
Shelly started again…
“But then, as we partied and Eve plied me with all the shots, my desire went wild, and I was out of control. I needed to cum so badly I had my hand between my legs. All I could think about was your hard cock fucking me.
When Eve saw the stated I was in she took advantage and dragged me to the bathroom into a stall. In the bathroom I went crazy, not thinking of anything but needing to cum. Eve was mean, not letting me get myself off. Then Eve stripped me, and I stripped her, and we saw each other naked, there was a lust filled explosion that started raging inside me. It was not for Eve but for you, Ed. God I needed your big cock right then, but you were not there.
Eve suddenly became your surrogate and seduced me fucking me with her fingers like they were your cock. She kissed me, and I melted. God, Ed, it was so fucking hot. Then her three fingers worked their magic, and I started to cum over and over, soaking her hand as she fucked my pussy. I even called your name as I came.
Ed baby, in my head, it was you kissing me, not Eve. It was your fingers sliding inside me, fingers fucking me. God, I came so hard thinking it was you. I almost collapsed.
But it was Eve who held me tight, not you. I wasn't thinking about Eve, only you, until she whispered, 'Baby, we need to leave.' Ed I realized you weren't there and suddenly knew what had happened and what would happen next."
I listened to each of them. I looked at them. Shelly had her hands under the table. From her graphic story and seeing the look on her face, I was sure she was playing with her pussy. That was a good thing; I wanted her to be as horny as she could be for what I had planned to happen next.
Shelly continued…
"When we got to the car, Eve pushed me against it and passionately kissed me. I thought she was going to fuck me right there, and Jesus, I was ready for it. Sorry baby, but it was no longer you, it was all Eve. All I wanted at that minute was to be fucked by somebody, and Eve was there, ready for me.
We dove into the car, broke the speed limit, and got to our house. When we got home, we stripped each other naked almost before the door closed. We kissed hard, and our hands were all over each other. Ed, I was utterly available now and quickly became Eve's playground. Baby, she ruled the field and made all the moves. Eve promptly pulled me down the hall and pushed me on the bed. Her mouth kissed me all over, and she did beautiful things to me. I closed my eyes, envisioning you between my legs, but when Eve's long tongue slithered up inside me and tickled my G-spot, I knew it was not you. My mind went blank, and I surrendered to Eve. Her tongue and fingers quickly pushed me into a sexual frenzy. I soon exploded cumming so hard that I could not stop and came continuously for almost an hour. I finally had to push Eve away, begging her, 'Please Stop,' or I thought I would die.
Once I recovered, I had to repay Eve, so I went down on her eating a woman for the first time. I thought I wouldn't like it, but I owed it to her, so I did it. Not knowing what to do, I did what I liked and what Eve had done to me. God Ed, it was incredible, and I loved her pussy. I went crazy unable to get enough of her.
Knowing I was pleasing Eve as she had pleased me was beautiful. It was such a turn-on. So, I ate her pussy until she pushed my head away and rolled on her side in a ball. My jaw is still sore from what I did. But I can still give you a hell of a blow job right now if you want!
After I made her cum and roll over. I felt amazing. We lay together, cuddling and kissing softly. Finally, I dosed off, sleeping briefly as Eve did, too.
I was woken by Eve, sitting on my hips with the big black strap-on dangling in my face. That thing was ten inches long, thick, and black as coal. You saw it. It scared me. I couldn't imagine being able to take that big cock in my little pussy.
Eve smiled down at me as she stroked that big black cock. As I watched her, my pussy started to get wet and twitch. My hetero side was back, and I needed to be fucked. I rose on my elbows, taking the big head in my mouth, and closed my eyes. You were there in my mouth, Ed. Yes, it was bigger than you, but it was you.
I sucked you and took you as deep as I could. I gagged but took you to the back of my throat. I stroked your shaft as I bobbed on you. It was surreal, and my pussy started to flood. I felt Eve's fingers fucking my pussy, loosening me up for that big boy.
I sucked and sucked, coating you with my saliva. I finally pushed you out and sat up, kissing Eve. I pushed her on her back and moved over her. I squatted and put the fat cockhead against my wet hole. God, it felt so big I was really afraid it would hurt me.
Eve reached up and pinched my nipples hard, twisting them, pulling them, and suddenly I came hard again. I shuddered, and as my pussy gushed, she gripped my hips, pulling me down on her big cock. Eve slammed her hips up against me, burying the black monster deep inside me.
I was shocked and screamed as she started to fuck me. I had never had a cock, real or fake, that big inside me before last night. The feeling was unbelievable, I just kept cumming over and over. I rode her as she fucked up into me. We set a rhythm, and we fucked for a long time. Big Blacky never got soft, so he was ready all the time. I kept cumming until finally, I had cum eight or ten times, and I collapsed on Eve. Our breasts mashed together, and our hard nipples poked each other, and we kissed.
I lay there like a corpse, totally sated and breathing erratically. My mind was blank for a while, but then I thought of you, Ed, stuck in that God-forsaken place. I missed you so much, and I realized what I had done. I tried to reason it out, but no, I had cheated. It wasn't with a man, yet I had cheated with a woman. I didn't think you could ever understand that. Damn, I didn't understand it myself. It happened so fast it was like a tidal wave of lust just rolled over me. I cried, dripping tears on Eve, and she stroked my back and hair. Eve whispered, 'What's the matter, baby?'
'God, Eve, I have cheated on Ed. I am horrible. How could I do that to him? He is off protecting our country, and I am here cheating. I feel so ashamed. How can he ever take me back? I am a terrible wife!'"
Just then, Eve jumped back in the conversation…
"Ed, Shelly was so distraught, so I got right in her face and told her, 'Shelly, you are not a terrible person or wife. You are a horny wife with no way to satisfy your needs. You didn't fall for another man and fuck him. You have been loyal all this time, and last night I seduced you. You resisted every approach I had until I touched your pussy then you were mine.' Ed, if there is fault here, it is on me. I have wanted Shelly and I got her. You may hate me after tonight, and I would understand that, but I wanted you, and Shelly, you needed to be loved, so I loved you."
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I watched Eve closely as she spoke, and Shelly looked at me. I was sure Shelly was telling me what happened the way she remembered it. I felt sure Shelly had fought her urges for all these months. I also felt that if Eve had not pushed her, Shelly would not have cheated.
As Eve finished, I stopped them both. "OK, that's enough; I get the story." I got up and got a beer out of the fridge. I looked at it, "Have these been in the fridge since I left?"
Shelly smiled, "Yes!"
I popped the top off the long neck and took a swig. I didn't gag, so it was still OK.
I sat back down and looked at the two of them. It was time to roll out my plan for restitution. I wondered how they would take it. It was not vengeful but would teach each of them a lesson. I knew I would like it, and I was sure they would, too.
"OK, ladies, I have heard both your stories and believe it or not, I think you were both honest and telling me the truth as you see it. Neither of you thought you would ever have to answer for what you did last night, but now you both do!
Shelly, you must pay because you cheated on me, your husband. And Eve, you must pay because you seduced my wife, causing her to cheat on me. It all happened to satisfy your lusty wants and Shelly's needs.
So here is what is going to happen. Eve, you will go into the guest room bathroom and shower, cleaning yourself and making your body squeaky clean. You will dry off and lay naked on the bed with your arms and legs spread out toward the corners of the bed. When you are ready, I will come in and blindfold you. You will remain lying there blindfolded until I tell you to move. Do you understand?"
Eve looked at me, wondering what I had planned, "Yes, I understand."
"Shelly, you will go into the master bathroom and shower. You will wash all of Eve off you. When we are done, you will dry yourself. You will change the sheets on the bed and lay on the clean sheet just like Eve, spread eagle, and I will blindfold you. You will remain there until I tell you to move. Do you understand?"
Shelly looked at Eve, then at me. She nodded, "Yes," not knowing what would happen.
I was getting excited, knowing this was going to be fun.
"OK, go Shower, NOW!" I stated firmly.
Both ladies scampered off, and I heard the showers start.
I set the second part of the plan in place. I went out to the garage and cut two blindfolds from the heavy black material I had. I doubled it over so there was no way they could see. I found two large elastic bands to secure them with. I cut eight lengths of rope, four for the queen bed and four for the king bed. I cut eight strips of towel material and used duct tape to make the cuffs. Now I was ready.
As the girls showered, I tied the rope to the beds and prepared the wrist and ankle bands. I put the blindfolds in the bathrooms and waited for them to finish. I was in Eve's bathroom first. As Eve stepped out of the shower, I waited with a towel.
"Ed, what are you doing in here?" Eve asked nervously.
"I am here to dry you and get you settled on the bed with your blindfold in place."
"What are you going to do to me?" There was a shakiness in her voice that told me she was scared.
"You'll see!" I was sharp with my response.
I finished drying Eve and pulled her hair back in a ponytail. I put a rubber band around it. I turned her away from the mirror and put on the blindfold, securing it with the large band.
"Can you see?" I asked.
She shook her head, "No."
"OK, Good, let's go in the bedroom." I steered her to the bed and laid her down.
"Hands over your head," I stated.
I took her right hand and fastened the towel band tied to the rope.
"What, what are you doing?" Eve was very nervous now.
"Quiet, or I will gag you!" I stated firmly.
I tied the other wrist and then Eve's ankles. I pulled all the ropes just tight enough to secure her but not too tight.
Eve moaned as I ran my fingertips up her legs and down the other one. I flicked her nipples and dragged my fingers down the middle of her body, making her squirm and murmur. "Ed, what are you doing?"
I stopped just above her pussy, not touching it, leaving her squirming as I left the room, closing the door. Eve was primed and ready.
I walked down the hall into the master bathroom just as Shelly stepped out of the shower, dripping wet. I took a towel and dried her, not doing anything sexual, drying only.
Shelly looked at me, "Ed, what are you doing?"
"Drying, my wife," I said as I finished.
"Turn around away from the mirror." I put her hair in a ponytail like Eve, and then I put the blindfold in place, securing it with a band.
"What is happening, Ed? What are you going to do?" Shelly was extremely nervous.
I didn't answer. I led Shelly to the king bed. Laying her in the middle, I secured her arms and legs like I had done Eve's.
"Ed, what are you doing? I don't like this, you know that. Please let me lose."