I stood in front of Holly's apartment door that Friday evening in early March, a bottle of cheap pinot noir in my hand. Though Holly and I had worked together at the city library for several months, this was the first time she'd invited me over to her place, and as I waited for her to answer my knock, I wondered if I should have splurged on something better to drink despite my tight budget.
When the door opened, it wasn't Holly who greeted me but a man so massively built he seemed to take up the entire doorway. Tilting my head back, I allowed my eyes to widen a little before I managed to say, "Oh, hi." I sounded like a complete idiot, but that was nothing new for me.
The man smiled down at me. He seemed more than a little amused by my reaction as he held out his hand and said, "You must be Josh. I'm Holly's roommate, Troy."
Holly had once mentioned that she had a roommate, but she never said he looked like a Greek god. I was five feet, nine inches tall, and I imagined Troy was close to six and a half feet. His muscles bulged under the snug-fitting black t-shirt he wore. Shaking his hand, I felt his grip swallow my fingers. His hair, light brown and wavy, was cut short, and his beard was neatly trimmed.
"It's nice to meet you, Troy," I managed to say as I returned his smile. So he was gorgeous, and Holly was damn lucky to get to look at him every day, I told myself. All I could do was try not to drool over the man, all the while knowing I'd be imagining him naked the next time I jacked off.
"Come on in," Troy said, stepping aside so I could enter the apartment. "Holly's on the phone with her mom, and she asked me to let you in when you arrived. Make yourself at home."
When Troy turned to lead me inside, I noticed that the back of his shirt bore the logo of a local bar. I'd never been to the place, as I wasn't much of a social drinker and I'd heard that particular establishment could get a little rough. Troy, however, would definitely be able to hold his own in a bar brawl. My stare moved to his ass, and the way his tight jeans hugged those firm, round cheeks. Did this guy have even a single flaw? He was like an airbrushed model.
Glancing around the apartment, I thought I could spot many of Holly's personal touches in the decorating scheme. She adored dolphins, and I saw them embroidered on the couch's throw pillows. There was even a dolphin wall clock. I took off my coat and then sank down into a comfortable chair, awkwardly clutching the bottle of wine I'd brought.
Meanwhile, Troy strode around the apartment, searching for and then finding his keys. "So Holly tells me you two work together at the library," he said to me before slipping on his own coat.
"Yeah, Holly's wonderful." I wished Holly had told me even one thing about Troy, but I had absolutely no information to go on. "How long have you been roommates?"
"About six months now. I work as a bouncer, so she and I are kind of like ships passing in the night for the most part. I normally don't get home until after two in the morning." Troy grabbed his phone from a small table near the door. "Speaking of which, I have to head in to work now," he told me. Then he smiled, and those dark blue eyes of his filled with warmth. "You and Holly have a good evening."
"Thanks. You too," I said just before he left. Then I slumped back into the chair and sighed, wondering if Troy thought this was some kind of date for me and Holly. Holly knew I was gay, so she wouldn't have knowingly given Troy that impression, but maybe he simply assumed it. That bothered me, though I couldn't understand why. What did it matter if Troy thought I was seeing Holly?
Before I could dwell on it anymore, I heard Holly approaching from a hallway which I assumed led to the bedrooms. As soon as she appeared in the living room with a big smile on her face, I stood. "Josh, hi!" she said, then moved to hug me. "Sorry I had to leave you on your own for a bit; my mom called just before you got here, and she can get a little long-winded."
"No problem," I said. Now that it was just me and Holly, I felt some of my nervous tension fade. "Your roommate let me in. He's very nice." I let my voice dip, giving each word I spoke extra emphasis.
Holly grinned, catching my meaning immediately. "Isn't he, though? I'm actually glad he's gay because otherwise, I'd be lusting after him while knowing I don't have a chance in hell with a guy like him."
I began coughing loudly as if I were choking, and Holly's expression grew concerned. "Josh, are you okay? Want me to get you some water?"
I shook my head, but it was several more moments before I could speak again. "He's gay?" I finally sputtered. "Are you fucking serious?"
Holly gave me a puzzled smile. "Well, yeah, but what..." Her voice trailed off as she realized. "Oh."
"Jeez, I wish you hadn't told me that," I said with a rueful grin. "Now I'll be lusting after the guy while knowing I don't have a chance in hell with him."
Holly's eyes took on an impish gleam. "I could, you know, casually mention to Troy that you're gay," she offered.
"Don't you dare," I said. "Let me maintain a shred of dignity in case I ever come over to your place again while he's here."
Holly laughed and slipped an arm around me. "Deal. Now what have you brought us to drink?" She took the wine from me and examined the label. "Ha! I got the same brand. Chardonnay for me, though."
I was relieved to find she wasn't a wine snob, but then again, Holly wasn't like that. One of the reasons we'd become such good friends was that she was so kind to others, always wanting to make everyone around her feel at ease. She was a cute young woman, rather than pretty, but she had the sweetest smile, and I'd noticed more than a few men sneaking glances at her voluptuous figure. She wore her dark hair to her shoulders, and she was always tucking it behind her ears as she worked. Right now she was wearing a sweatshirt and lounge pants, while I was dressed in the sweater and chinos I'd worn to work.
It wasn't long before the two of us were seated on her couch, sipping our cheap wine and working our way through a cheese plate she'd prepared. Holly was on her third glass of chardonnay when she leaned toward me as if to confide a secret. "I really appreciate you being such a good friend during my breakup with John. I know I was a mess at work, and you saved my ass more than once by covering for me when I was crying my eyes out in the restroom."
"I hated to see you hurting, and I wanted to help however I could," I said. Staring down into my wineglass, I released a heavy sigh. "I think I've gotten my heart broken too many times to try any more with relationships, to be honest."
"Oh, come on!" Holly said, giving my knee a playful smack. "You're only twenty-four, Josh, two years younger than me! You have plenty of time to meet the right person."
When I looked over at Holly, I tried not to appear despondent, but I was pretty sure I didn't succeed. "Guys like Troy have far better luck meeting the right person, because everyone wants to be with them, right? But guys like me? I get the attention of a few guys at best, and the chance of any of them being 'the one' is slim to none."
Holly tilted her head, studying me the way she might peruse an interesting book title at work. Though her eyes were already a little bleary from the wine, I saw the empathy in her gaze. "You're totally selling yourself short," she said. "I mean, not many people can compare themselves with Troy. It should be a sin for someone to be that gorgeous. But I think the reason you don't get more attention is because you're a bit quiet, kind of shy. It's not because of how you look. In fact," she went on with a playful grin, "you remind me of a young Cillian Murphy, with your intense blue eyes, and those cheekbones to die for!"
I snorted with laughter, though I was secretly pleased at her compliment. "That's awfully kind of you, Holly," I said. "Too bad you're not a man."
Holly threw her head back and giggled. "Do you think if I were, Troy would give me a pity fuck? Because I haven't gotten laid since John and I broke up, and it's been frustrating, to say the least!"
Her words made me dissolve into giggles as well, and as our conversation turned toward past shitty relationships we'd both endured, she and I drank more and more. I'd meant to pace myself since I needed to drive home, but I ended up finishing almost the entire bottle of pinot noir on my own. "Oh shit," I muttered, pressing a hand to my forehead. "I'm gonna have to call an Uber. I can't drive like this."
"Don't be ridiculous," Holly said, slurring her words. "Just sleep here on the couch. It's comfy."
The thought of curling up and going to sleep right there was appealing, I had to admit. "Are you sure?" I asked.
"Of course. Let me get you a pillow and blanket." When Holly climbed to her feet, her gait was a little unsteady. "The bathroom's right down the hall."
While she prepared the couch for me, I used the bathroom, and as I washed my hands at the sink, I noticed that one side of the countertop held Holly's toiletries and the other side held Troy's. The two of them seemed to make perfect roommates.
When I returned to the living room, Holly offered me a large glass of water. "It's a little late for this, but maybe hydrating now will ward off the worst of your hangover tomorrow." I thanked her and gulped down the water, unaware until that moment of how thirsty I was. "Troy will be coming home later, but he's quiet," Holly told me. "I doubt he'll wake you up."
"How old is he, anyway?" I asked before I could stop myself.
"Thirty," she said. "You know, he recently got out of a bad relationship, too. I mean, he and I didn't really talk about it, but he was seeing a guy for months, and then, from what I heard of one of their arguments over the phone, the guy cheated on Troy, and that was the end of it. Troy seemed depressed about it for weeks."
"What kind of idiot would cheat on Troy?" I asked, more to myself than Holly.
She shrugged and said, "Some people don't know how good they have it, I guess."
"Like John," I pointed out.
"Absolutely like John. That bastard." Holly planted a kiss on my cheek. "Good night, Josh."
Holly was right; the couch was comfy, and almost as soon as I turned off the lamp on the side table and lay my head on the pillow, I felt sleep insistently pulling at me. A nightlight glowed from an outlet near the door, and I figured it provided Troy with some illumination when he returned home in the middle of the night. Again I thought of Holly's roommate, astonished that someone had recently broken his heart. Maybe it was stereotypical of me, but I hadn't guessed he'd be the monogamous type.
I started entertaining a fantasy in my mind of Troy walking into the apartment and stripping naked in front of me, but alcohol-induced sleep proved more powerful than my imagination, and I passed out. I had no idea how long I'd been asleep when the sound of a door opening and closing made me open my eyes. Staring around the shadowy room, I frowned in confusion. "Where the hell am I?" I murmured. Someone to my left turned on a lamp, and though the light was soft and low, I still squinted my eyes.
"Oh, sorry, Josh," a deep voice spoke quietly, and I lifted my head to see Troy looking down at me in confusion. "What are you doing sleeping out here on the couch?"
The sight of Troy chased away my disorientation, and I hurried to sit up. "I had too much to drink, and Holly said I could spend the night." The hangover Holly had warned me about was already making its presence known; it was as if I could feel my heartbeat in the bones of my face, and my head was beginning to ache.
"But why aren't you in Holly's room?" Troy asked. "I thought you two were..."
"Oh no," I hurried to tell him. "Holly's great, but we're just friends. And I'm gay." I blurted all that out in a single breath, again sounding like an idiot. So much for maintaining any of my dignity. It was hard to hold Troy's stare while my face flushed with embarrassment, but I wanted to see his reaction to my words. I watched as his eyebrows lifted in what appeared to be mild surprise.
"Shit, I'm sorry. I shouldn't have assumed anything," Troy said.
I gave him what I hoped was an attractive smile, though I had my doubts, as crummy as I felt. "No need to be sorry," I said. "And I apologize for getting wasted and crashing on your couch."
Troy returned my smile, and I realized that in the hours I'd been asleep, I must have sobered up fairly fast because I now felt my cock stir. Christ, all the man had to do was smile at me and I started to get a hard-on! I was never going to be able to come over to Holly's again.
"Don't worry about it," Troy told me. "I have to say, you're the most mild-mannered drunk I've been around tonight." His eyes moved to my empty water glass on the table. "How about I bring you some more water?"
"That would be fantastic. Thank you." I watched him retrieve my glass and head to the kitchen. As soon as he was out of sight, I ran my fingers through my hair, trying to tame my bedhead. Wiping my mouth with the back of my hand, I was happy to find I hadn't drooled in my sleep. Or when I was awake and staring up at Troy.
After he came back to the living room and gave me the glass, I took several large swallows of water, all the while watching as he shrugged out of his coat. I figured he would wish me a good night and go to his room, but he instead sat down on the couch next to me. Simply being close to him had my heartbeat quickening, and I immediately forgot about my headache. Troy had taken off his shoes, and he now stretched his long legs out before him.
"Was it a rough night at the bar?" I asked, casting a sidelong glance his way.
"Ah, typical for a Friday." Troy rubbed his eyes with the heels of his palms. "Sometimes I think I'm getting too old for this shit."
I set my empty water glass on the table, then turned to face him. "Maybe Holly and I can put in a good word for you at the library," I suggested with a smile.
Troy looked over at me before laughing from low in his belly. "I think I might be a little too rough around the edges for the library, but I do appreciate the offer, Josh."
Every time he said my name, I felt a current of lust travel through me, and I hoped my arousal wouldn't become too obvious as I sat at his side. Though I wasn't drunk, I was still plenty relaxed from the wine, and I blamed the alcohol for what I said next. "You could always model. Or act, maybe."
"Just how much did you drink tonight?" Troy asked, but his grin made it clear he didn't mind my compliments.
"Oh, come on, you know how hot you are," I said, rolling my eyes. I was well aware that after tonight I would look back on this conversation with utter mortification, but it was as if my horniness had taken complete control over my tongue.
I struggled to hide my shock when Troy moved closer to me on the couch, his thigh almost touching mine. "I don't think I do, actually," he said. When he dipped his head to catch my eyes, I somehow managed not to look away. "Why don't you tell me how hot you think I am, Josh?"
This could not be happening, I told myself. No way was a guy like Troy flirting with me. This had to be a dream. Yet when I dared to place my palm on his knee, I felt the warmth of his skin through his jeans and knew he was all too real. My erection was strengthening by the minute, and I didn't care if Troy noticed it. Part of me hoped he would. "I'm pretty sure I'm not your type," I began, "but I think you're so hot that I'd gladly suck you off right now if you wanted me to."
Troy's eyes widened, and while part of me felt a satisfaction at surprising him, another part was already bracing for his rejection. My face flushed from a mixture of arousal and shock at my own boldness, and as I waited for his response, the sound of my breathing seemed too loud to my ears.