I have both but i recently bought a butt plug from love-sextoys.co.uk that is awesome. After using this butt plug i must say.....a big yes for Butt plug.
To get into the mood for sex you can discuss erotic topic with your partner, erotic pics and jokes. Try oral, sensual touch and massage. You can also use Sex Toys to get into sexy mood. You can get a vibrator. Both you and your partner will both enjoy using it. Try this Love-sextoys.co.uk/vibrators/ Hope this will help you.