Saturday 14th April
It was Saturday morning, the weekend after we’d returned from England and I was enjoying a quiet cup of coffee on our back decking. Jill was out, shopping with Gemma for food and drink for the eight-person dinner party we were hosting later that day. And I was enjoying the lull before the storm.
Since we came back, the last five days had been amazing. The transformation I’d seen in Jill was amazing. From passable impression of a love-lorn teenager on the ten days leading to our return to loving and affectionate wife. Jill had been home from work early every night, with dinner simmering away on my return. Always happy to see me, and as far as I could tell she was one-hundred percent sticking to the ‘Dave and Jill only’ plan, with no obvious signs of any untoward extra-curricular activities between her and boss during their working hours.
And despite her self-confessed admission that she was in love with Chris, she didn’t seem to be missing him. Happy to spend all evening with her ‘old toy’, her loving but less than shiny husband of twenty-three years.
We had a great week. Mixing up romantic meals at home with fine dining. Snuggled movies on the couch followed by tender and joyful love-making, followed by talking into the small hours about everything and anything under the sun. The only thing we didn’t talk about was Chris, or Chris and Jill, or Gemma. We’d made a pact that this week was a special time for Jill and me alone, with even the mention of anyone else banned.
So as I sat there drinking my coffee and enjoying the much warmer temperatures than we’d endured a week ago, I was a pretty happy camper. I’d had a great week and by my reckoning, apart from the dinner party tonight, I had another two days of time with Jill to look forward to. There was only one solitary negative thought in my mind, but try as I might I really struggled to ignore it.
What was troubling me was a conversation I’d overheard between Chris and Jill on their last night and morning together in England before we all returned to Miami and normal life. They were cuddled up together on the outside patio, enjoying a last romantic bottle of wine. Gemma and I had retired a couple of hours before so I guess they thought they had the place to themselves, and so were talking as if no one else was around. But we’d drunk so much wine earlier in the evening that I’d woken up to use the toilet.
They were laying along the length of one side of an L-shaped outdoor corner sofa, Chris behind Jill as she lay back on his chest, her legs and backside nestled between his long legs, with Chris’s arms wrapped around her body. As they drank the last bottle of red wine we’d bought earlier that evening, it was Chris who started the conversation.
“You know, Jill. I’m going to miss all this,” he said.
“What, the English countryside?” Jill teased him, gesturing with her free arm.
Chris laughed and squeezed his arms tighter around Jill. “Idiot! No, not this,” mimicking Jill’s gesture towards the countryside. “You. I’ll miss you. You know, being together as a couple, all the time.”
Even in the low lighting, I could see the wistful look on Chris’s face. “I’ve loved all this, being together all of the time, as a proper couple. It’s going to be hard for me, seeing you go back to Dave at the end of the day. Not seeing you at all at the weekend.”
Jill placed her hands on top of Chris’s, a small gesture designed to comfort him and then turned to look at him. Her face showing concern at the feelings of her boyfriend.
“I know, Chris. But at least we’ve still got our three nights a week. And all our time at work.”
But Chris wasn’t for cheering up. His face still looked sad, and he looked like he was trying to make his mind up about something. After a few moments of silence between the two of them, he asked Jill the question on his mind.
“What about you, Jill. Do you feel the same? Will you miss this? Being together all the time?”
What had taken me by surprise was the speed of Jill’s reply and the words she chose.
“Chris, honey. You know I will, I’ll miss this just as much as you. These last nine days have been wonderful. Better than I could ever have imagined. But I’ve got a man to go back to. A man who loves me and who I love.”
Jill’s face showed a strange mix of feelings as she said these words. Part regret, part resignation at the unfathomable dilemma she faced. No way to split herself in two so she could be with both men she loved all of the time.
Chris must have been encouraged by Jill’s response. Maybe sensing some chink of light. He suddenly sounded just a little belligerent. “Jill, honey. Tell me honestly, isn’t what we have better? Isn’t it more exciting? Doesn’t what we have set your heart raising in ways that Dave, however much you love him, can’t?”
Hearing this declaration of war from a man who just eight nights ago said he’d never want to split me and Jill set a million alarm bells ringing in my brain. I felt anger, betrayal, and panic mixing as his words sank in. So much for his intentions – changed through one-hundred and eighty degrees in the space of a little over a week.
I was tempted to storm out from my hiding place and confront this cuckoo in the nest, the only thing stopping me being my need to hear Jill’s reply. To get some comfort and reassurance from her words.
But Jill’s words left me hanging there. In the strangest and most frustrating of places. Half over the edge and half in safety on the cliff edge.
“I promised Dave I’d never leave him, and that nothing between you and me will ever change that. And however things are between us, Chris, I’m not planning on breaking my promise to Dave. I love him and I promised to never leave him.”
The curate’s egg. Jill’s slightly angry-sounding reply to Chris, that she’d never leave me, cheered me and reassured me. But at the same time the fact she’d failed to contradict Chris’s statement that what they had was better left all kinds of unraveling threads in my brain. Maybe she was so cross with Chris that she forgot to tell him what he said wasn’t true. Or maybe she was just avoiding answering the question because what Chris said was true.
Chris seemed to sense that he was on shaky ground, and backed away from this crude attempt at trying to encourage Jill in his direction. His parting comment on the subject, said in jest, was that maybe he’d have to come to an arrangement with Gemma so that Jill and he could spend more time together, but without Jill feeling guilty about it.
His closing words caused the strangest of all the looks I’d seen on Jill’s face during that vacation. “Who knows? She’s so into him, maybe she’ll solve all our problems.” Followed by an exaggerated pause and a hammed-up final word. “Oh, no. I seem to remember you threatening Dave with his head impaled on the spikes at Traitor’s Gate if he ever tried anything like that. Back to plan A then I guess.”
This earned Chris a playful elbow in the ribs. But at least Jill was now laughing and Chris knew he was off the hook, having slightly overplayed his hand. Having misread Jill’s honest answer that she would miss him for a willingness on her part to break her promise and abandon me.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
This little episode from our last night in England hadn’t played on my mind much during that first week back. The way that Jill had closed Chris down at the end of the conversation and then her subsequent loving attentiveness during the last five days had acted as a soothing anesthetic.
So I was a little surprised that my mind was thinking again about this conversation. But who knows, maybe I’m blessed with ESP because barely had I stopped thinking about it, then my phone lit up with an incoming call. ‘Jill Cell’ the little screen showed.
“Hi, honey. We’ll be home soon. But I had something I wanted to ask you before then.”
I could hear nervousness in her voice, and wondered what it was, even as my intuition told me that these days when Jill’s voice sounded like this it was normally something to do with Chris.
“Sure, what is it?” I asked trying to keep the nervous edge in my voice hidden.
“Well, I know this is meant to be a Chris free week, but as Gemma’s coming to dinner tonight, I wondered if it would be okay if I invited Chris around as well?”
I sighed deeply. Jill was right, this was indeed meant to be a Chris free week. Just me and Jill. That had been the deal, the only way I could get myself through the whole ten days of handing Jill over to Chris for all that time in the UK.
As with most couples together as long as us, Jill read my reaction even before I spoke one word.
“Gemma thinks it’s fair as well,” Jill said by way of making it all okay. “Please, honey. It’s only fair.”
Rather than give my response, I’ll hand over to Jill and let her tell the story of the rest of that Saturday and the dinner party.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I’d loved the week that Dave and I had enjoyed together after our return from England. To me, the whole week had been so satisfying, re-connecting with my wonderful husband who I loved so much.
The week had started when we got back home with Dave playfully but semi-seriously taking the three rings he’d given me and looking tenderly into my face as one-by-one he slipped each of them down the length of my ring finger, giving me the softest of kisses each time. Having put the last one in place, he reached inside the neckline of my blouse and fingered Chris’s class ring which still hung there on the gold chain Chris had bought for me.
Dave looked at Chris’s class ring and then looked up at me, still holding Chris’s ring between his thumb and finger. His question obvious, did I want him to remove it or leave it there? I didn’t answer his question with words. Instead, I kissed my wonderful husband’s lips softly and reached behind my neck to undo the clasp and hand the ring and chain to Dave. After all, this week was to be a Chris-free week.
The week was full of romantic meals, slow and tender love-making and long meandering conversations, the like of which we’d not enjoyed in many a year, such are the pressures of family life.
Of course, I missed my nights of passion with Chris, especially as we still spent so much time together at work each day. Seeing him sat there at his desk head down working on something, I’d sometimes find myself staring at him and daydreaming about our time together in England. And when I’d snap out of m daydream, it was like a voice in my head shouted ‘look but don’t touch.’ Like looking at a particularly shiny, succulent fruit and having your hand slapped each time you reached for it.
And so when I was shopping with Gemma for supplies for our dinner party and she mentioned she thought it would be a good idea if Chris came, I was easy prey to her suggestion. I joked with her that she only thought this because it would give her a clear run at my husband, and she just smiled and laughed, not denying or refuting my suggestion.
As we continued shopping, I couldn’t put Gemma’s suggestion out of my head. I had no doubts that her idea was motivated by her own agenda rather than by a concern for my well-being. But even though I knew this, I couldn’t dislike her for it. Although I still sometimes struggled with jealousy where Gemma and Dave were concerned, I’d grown increasingly close to Gemma during our trip to England. It had been me who’d suggested she join us (not without my own agenda when I suggested it) and knowing the pain she was in at the state of her marriage my heart naturally went out to her.
And during the ten days, what started as sympathy and empathy slowly flowered into a deeper friendship. Before that trip, I’d not really spent much time with her, as whenever she was in our home I was normally with Chris. But during that vacation, we spent time together during some of the day trips and meals. And I found myself warming to her as an intelligent, generous and kind person, a personality she disguised well with all the jokes.
Well, she’d well and truly planted the seed in my brain. I’d been without Chris nearly a whole week, since our return the previous Sunday when we’d kissed and held each other at the airport and then headed in our separate directions. I’d loved my time back with Dave, but I’d grown used to being a ‘greedy girl’ – with two men to love and two men to be with. I’d just about managed to resist temptation for all of those hours together with Chris at work, but with Gemma’s mischievous and self-serving suggestion, I’d been given a nudge in a direction I was only too keen to pursue.
It was like that shiny apple I wasn’t allowed to touch was rolling down the table in my direction, surely a sign provided by the gods that I was meant to have the shiny apple.
I’m not going to go back over all the conversations and feelings from that trip to England, but I will say that resisting this temptation was much harder after England than it would have been before the trip. Dave has described at some length how he accidentally overheard me telling Chris that I shared the same feelings as he did, the difficult conversation that followed between Dave and me, and how we ultimately made things okay. The big promise I gave Dave that I loved him with all my heart and would never leave him for Chris being at the center of our ability to move past this difficult set of discussions.
And although Dave faithfully and accurately described these conversations, of course, he was telling things as he saw them from his viewpoint. I’m not criticizing, but of course he couldn’t see inside my heart and my head to fully realize the depth of the feelings and emotions I was going through.
Certainly, no criticism, because even I was being less than honest with myself about my feelings for Chris in the days and weeks that led up to those difficult Good Friday discussions. As someone who’d been brought up in a very conventional and conservative family, I’d crossed enough bridges and barriers to get to the place where, as society and my parents would see it, I was being serially unfaithful to my husband.
So it was no wonder my mind was rebelling at the prospect of being totally honest with myself. Not only was I sharing my body with another man, now I was also sharing my heart with another man. But until Good Friday (how ironic!) and Chris declared his feelings for me and demanded to know how I felt, I just couldn’t bring myself to admit even to myself how I felt about this new man in my life.
But having finally admitted first to Chris and then to Dave how I felt, it was like a giant sluice gate in one of those huge dams had been opened. I found that without the need for half my brain to hold the other half in check and deny some home truths, my sense of love for Chris and sense of being in love with him grew at a rapid pace during the rest of our time in England.
Dave has described some of the outward signs of this, but I think what he saw and described wasn’t even the half of it. My emotions were in free flow. I’d meant every word I’d said when I told Dave that I’d never leave him for Chris, but another thing I barely dared admit to myself was how quickly my feelings for Chris were developing. With Dave, there was that deep sense of love you feel for the people who are central to your life. Your parents, your children.
That love was deep and well-rooted. The kind that gives you a warm feeling throughout your whole body, making you feel secure and contented. But with Chris, it was something different. It was something that was more basic and, I hate to admit it, more exciting. A tingling excitement and anticipation compared to deep-rooted contentment. A breathless exhilaration and feeling of being totally alive, compared to the safe feeling that ‘all is well in the world.’
During our time in England, I’d been too happy at just ‘being with Chris’ to engage in much reflection or self-contemplation. But once back in Miami, things were slow at work and I found myself with plenty of time to think and contemplate. Several times I found myself thinking a strange thought. That the last time I’d felt like this about any man was in those first days and weeks that Callan and I dated, way back more than twenty-five years ago when we’d become boyfriend and girlfriend at the start of our freshman year at college. It was the same giddy excitement, the same rush as I looked at his muscular and masculine body.
This sounds terrible that I’d not felt the same way with Dave. But love and lust come in all shapes and sizes, and what Dave and I had was different. Deeper, more substantial. The kind of solid foundation that a woman needs to build her life upon. The man with which to have and raise children with, before enjoying the quieter times together before starting the whole thing again with grandchildren. A life satisfying and well-lived, different from the rush that a Callan or a Chris might offer. Men who would naturally play the field and who might easily break your heart.