I told Jill the dreamlike story that night as we lay in bed. Initially, she was quite jealous and a bit angry, even though it was obviously a dream. There was no other possible explanation.
In her anger, Jill repeated, "How could you cheat on me after all of our years together?"
But, as I told and retold the story, she listened more closely. She realized that if it was real, then they had some apparent power over me. Then there was the fact that I went after her, choosing her over them in the end.
Even if you believed in such things, how would you explain her still being alive?
Over the following weeks and months, it became a regular topic of conversation. The more we spoke of it, the more her view of it changed. Over time Jill seemed to get more excited by the story. She began to insist that I give her great detail on the sexual parts of the story.
Then one night, she boiled over, and we had the most incredible sex. But that was just the beginning. We began experimenting with things that we had never tried. Our first undertaking was sex outdoors since that's where I did it in the story.
We started by just going out dressed late at night and making out on the back porch. It wasn't long before we were rolling in the grass, fucking like animals. Before long, we'd pushed that boundary as far as we could by walking out nude.
We'd fuck on the table, in the hammock, on the porch, and any other surface. We even dared going out during the weekend days. We stayed in the backyard that was surrounded by a privacy fence but could've easily been seen. We even agreed that the possibility of being seen made it that much hotter.
Feeling that we'd pushed the limits of that for now, we moved on to anal. Jill remembered how much Megan had enjoyed my cock in her ass. We'd occasionally rimmed each other during intense sixty-nine's over the years but never went further. I had some previous experience with anal play before we met unbeknownst to Jill. She really wanted to try anal sex next, and given my story about the werewolves, thought I should too.
We went online and ordered her a strapless dildo that was about the same size as my cock. We also got a large bottle of anal lube. While we waited for them to come, we started performing analingus on each other. We would lie on the bed in a side-by-side sixty-nine to lick and probe.
The first night as we were rimming each other. It was Jill that first pushed a finger into my sphincter. I have to admit that it felt fantastic, so I treated her to the same. As we each loosened up some, we began orally pleasing each other's genitalia. It wasn't long before each of us was cumming in the other's mouth.
In the aftermath, we agreed that it definitely enhanced our orgasms. It became a regular part of our nightly lovemaking. We slowly progressed to multiple fingers in preparation for our goal of anal sex.
About a week later, I got home first and found a package for Jill on the front steps. I anxiously awaited her arrival and even stripped to meet her at the front door. Jill opened the door to find me lying on the couch face down. Her package was balanced on my naked ass. I wiggled it back and forth for fun.
Her first reaction was to laugh hysterically. As she settled down, she asked, "Is that what I think it is?"
"I certainly hope so. If it's a present for your mom, I'll be quite em-bare-assed. No bum intended," I quipped before we both broke out into hilarity.
As the laughing eased, Jill took the package and began to open it up.
"Oh my," were the first words from her mouth.
"It seems awfully big," she said wide-eyed as she pulled the dildo from the box.
I hopped up and began stroking myself to compare. I was becoming hard rather quickly at the thought of having that veined phallus filling my ass.
Jill's eyes moved to my swelling penis as she spouted, "It seems someone is excited about giving it a try."
"Very much so," I added as I let my hand feel it's texture.
"Me too! I almost let you do me in the ass last night. I am so ready to try anal. Let's get this thing cleaned and get you lubed up sexy!"
"I'll grab some towels and headed to the bedroom with the lube."
"Okay, I'll clean this thing up and meet you there."
We quickly kissed and headed our separate ways. With the towel laid out, I spread out on my back and opened my legs wide. Applying a fair amount of lube to my middle finger, I began opening myself up.
Jill arrived just after I added a second digit and watched for a moment. I was twisting and stretching my backdoor in preparation and hard as steel. Jill placed the dildo on the bed and pushed her hand into her jeans. She began rubbing herself furiously.
I paused to look at her before she shouted, "No! Don't stop!"
I began pounding my ass, and within moments, Jill climaxed fiercely. It was so intense that she collapsed to the floor as convulsions wracked her body.
Sitting up, I asked, "Are you okay, Baby?"
Panting, like she'd just sprinted down the street and back, Jill replied, "Yes... that was sooo hot!"
While still catching her breath, she began stripping off her clothes. When she was nude, Jill stood up and placed a leg on the bed. She was opening her slick pussy enough to insert her end of the dildo. As she eased it inside herself, her legs began to tremble.
I reached out for her and helped her onto the bed. Once she settled, Jill spread her legs and pushed again. This time she got it inside her puss before she climaxed. In the aftermath, she rolled up onto all fours and crawled toward me.
I was still sitting up when Jill gave me a playful shove onto my back. My legs were already spread a little, but she pushed them apart even further. I grabbed the lube and doused my pucker again before smearing some on Jill's cock. I stroked it to coat it thoroughly when I heard Jill moan.
"Oh shit! I don't know who's going to enjoy this more. I feel every little movement like it's really attached," Jill muttered quietly.
With everything lubed up, I lay back and opened my legs wide. As the tip of Jill's fraudulent johnson pressed into me, I begged, "Go easy, baby."
She did just that as the tip popped inside. I sucked in hard for a moment as she held steady. The pang of pain passed, and I whimpered, "Keep going."
Jill had paid attention when we made love in the past. I'd always eased inside her a little at a time until she opened up. I would pull back out a little before pushing back into her. She was employing that same strategy as I slowly accommodated her.
The fucking motion was affecting her, too, as her end moved in her as well. Each stroke brought her deeper into my rectum and brought her closer to another orgasm. I watched the dildo move in and out of my ass in an odd sort of amazement.
Jill only had about two-thirds of her cock in my ass before her orgasm struck. She instinctively pushed forward and fell onto my chest. Her plunge brought on an intense but pleasurable ache. Jill kept fucking me in short strokes to further her continuing climax. My stimulation was at a near peak when we began kissing voraciously.
Jill realized that I was close from the anal penetration alone and started fucking me intensely. Our bodies molded together, and her lower abs rubbed across my penis with every plunge. We were both headed for head-spinning orgasms as I held her buttocks with both hands. I was aiding her efforts in my butt-fucking when she screamed, "Finger my ass!"
I pushed a finger into her, and we both convulsed into ecstasy. I held her ass tight as I shot several loads of cum between our sweat-soaked bodies. Our face mauling slowed as our orgasms retreated.
Jill's first words were, "Was it as good as the werewolves?" as she snickered.
"Better," I replied.
We kissed hungrily for some time as she slowly began fucking me again. It felt delicious, but I wanted my turn at her ass. Since she was already close to another orgasm from her movements, I let her finish.
As we kissed gently, she pumped me a few more times, saying, "This having a penis thing is addictive. I think I understand why you guys love fucking. I could do this all night. How's your pussy feeling," she stammered as she started cracking up.
"Haha, very funny. Now it's my turn to plow your back forty. First, let's get cleaned up a little and get you properly lubed."
Jill started to ease out of me before pushing back in one last time. "Sorry, I just wanted to feel it again."
"Trust me, baby, this won't be the last time you fuck my ass."
"You liked it that much, huh? Good, I'm glad you enjoyed it because I loved doing you," she managed before kissing me hungrily again. We finally broke apart, and she pulled out, leaving me feeling quite empty. We were both so slimy between the lube and my cum, that we decided to take a quick shower.
Jill rolled onto her back to remove the dildo from her swollen and slick pussy. Once it was finally out, I moved between her legs and lapped at her open slit. Her cum was always quite tasty, but tonight it seemed even sweeter.
I could tell that she was close again, so I pushed three fingers into her while I sucked on her little nub. She climaxed in short order, and I took my time cleaning her from clit to pucker.
I finally relinquished her tasty slit, and we headed for the shower. Our hands were all over each other with plenty of soap to clean our private areas. Once we were finished with the cleansing, we shut off the water and dried each other thoroughly.
Jill jumped onto the bed on all fours while shouting, "Lube me and do me, Honey."
I skipped the oral assault that I had planned and went straight for the lube. I pumped it up and down her crack while coating my fingers. I eased the first finger in easily and pumped it with full strokes.
"Add another, she pleaded. So I did.
With two fingers pumping just as effortlessly, I added more lube. Jill's moans slowly turned to 'mores' before I added a third. Now she was grunting and panting vigorously.
In between noises, she huffed, "Do me with your cock now!"
With my fingers still deeply ensconced in her rectal cavity, I lubed up my cock with my free hand. Once I was well lubed, I slowly withdrew my fingers. With just the tips left inside, I brought my cock in line. I then made a quick switch before she closed up.
With just the tip inside her, I began an easy back and forth.
"It's so warm," Jill blurted out as I pushed into her slick hole.
"Does it feel good, baby?" I inquired.
"Oh, God, yes!" she yelled as she began pushing back against me.
I began matching her thrusts and started pounding her sweet ass with a vengeance. As her climax took hold, Jill's arms gave out, and she toppled face-first onto the bed. Her legs were also weakening, but I had such a tight grip on her hips that her ass stayed up.
Jill was screaming unintelligible words as her juices flowed from her sopping pussy. I felt the stirrings in my balls and increased the pace to bring on my orgasm. It was only another minute or so before I filled her colon with my baby batter.
Exhausted, I rolled down onto my side, pulling Jill with me. My pulsing pole was still inside her, and we both panted away for several more minutes.
With half of a hardon, I pumped her slick anus slowly, copying her doing of me.
"See. It does feel good to keep fucking afterward, doesn't it?" she voiced.
"Oh, yes, it does."
"It's too bad that yours doesn't stay hard all the time, like mine does," Jill teased.
"Well, I'm sorry that your's isn't as warm as mine and doesn't squirt hot juices either."
"Touche!" she pronounced as she pressed back into me tightly.
I sucked on her neck and earlobes as I kept pumping. Her soft moans were getting me riled up again, and I felt myself beginning to grow.
"Oh, God! You are growing inside me. It feels so fucking good! I wish you could experience this. Keep going, but a nice slow rhythm. I want both of us to cum again."
After her final words, I slipped my hand down her belly and began fingering her slippery twat. She immediately turned her head to mine, and we engulfed each other's tongues. Jill tried desperately to reach my backside with her fingers. Unfortunately, her reach was just too short.
Suddenly she pulled her face from mine, and her eyes darted across the bed. She searched before they found her prize. She stretched for her dildo that was just out of reach until I pushed her forward a few more inches. With her penile substitute in hand, Jill lifted her leg before ordering, "Lift yours too!"
She couldn't see where she was placing it but did manage to get the tip between my cheeks. Jill rubbed it around for a few seconds before she was there.
I moaned, "That's it, Baby. Push it in."
Jill put a little pressure on the dildo before it slipped inside my still slick innards. That additional stimulation moved us both rapidly toward our final climax of the evening.
I started to cum first as Jill pulled the dildo into me fully. I, in return, pushed three fingers into her stretched and sloppy slit. All of this while I furiously pounded her tight little ass. Her orgasm eclipsed mine in length and ferocity until we were both spent.
* * *
It was a Saturday morning, and I woke to my morning wood pressing between our entangled bodies. We both were off this weekend and had planned on spending most of that time putting up our Halloween decorations. It would be a rare Saturday night Halloween in one week, and we both had the night off. But at this moment, all that concerned me was being inside Jill.
She was so sexy lying on her side with most of her alluring body exposed. I moved in closer and pressed my rigid penis slowly into her pink labia. She was well lubricated, and I was fully inside her before she stirred. My arms wrapped around her chest, pulling her tightly to mine. As I began pumping her warm box, she moaned quietly and turned to kiss me.
We made love for the rest of the morning and only got up when our bellies demanded. It was noon, and we finally rose, heading straight for the shower. We kissed and played a little under the warm water but eventually finished and dried off.
A late breakfast was quickly made and consumed before we broke out the Halloween decorations. I got started on the yard items while Jill hung lights and webbing around the front door. We worked until dark and then stopped for the night and ate dinner on the back porch.
We'd talked extensively about the prior Halloween over the previous year. As time went by, our sex life exploded due to my elicit dream. We also began to consider the possibility that it may have been real. And, if so, how we would handle the Vampire's advances. The werewolves weren't really a consideration in our minds since both had died.
Jill still wasn't crazy about sharing me with the girls. But, I told her frequently that I'd love to see her with them. Imagining all three of them ravaging her sexy body often gave me the fuel for another of our romps. Jill never experimented, but with all of our new explorations lately, she was open to trying.
All our talk got us feeling frisky again, and we decided to combine our two latest experimentations into one. Jill disappeared into the house and returned a few minutes later. As she climbed the steps from our basement door, I glanced back at her. She was naked and sporting a nice hardon.
Even I was a bit shocked that she would come outside wearing that. But as she reached the top of the steps, I began stripping. As she got closer, I noticed her juices running down the inside of her superb thighs. With a bottle of lube in her hand, she commanded, "Into the hammock and show me your little pink hole."
I quickly moved to the hammock and lay back with my legs spread. As Jill approached, she squirted some lube onto a couple of fingers. I moved to the edge of the hammock, hooking my heels into the webbing to keep from sliding off. Jill applied the lube to my pucker and gradually began finger-fucking me.
Placing the lube on the ground, she used her free hand to swing the hammock to and fro. Jill held her fingers still as the action of the hammock did the work. I was beginning to moan as her actions opened up my back door. She briefly released the hammock as she applied more lube and added a third finger.
My previously quiet moans were becoming much louder. Feeling that I was ready, Jill removed her fingers and lined up her cock, plunging it about halfway in to start. With both hands-free, she controlled the movement of the hammock once again. And within moments, was plunging fully into my ass. The backstroke left just the very tip inside before another pelvic collision between us.
The sounds emanating from our back yard were beginning to sound like something you'd hear at the zoo. The grunts and growls were getting intense, as were the orgasms that we were both approaching. My hands were outspread and violently intertwined in the hammock strings as I began to shoot.
My first blast shot entirely over my head as my body arched into rigidity. I clamped down so hard onto Jill's fake dick that her next backstroke pulled her off her feet. She fell onto me, pulled by the half that was lodged inside her vagina. The sudden jerk left her frantically climaxing as she flailed on top of me.
When it was all over, I had my cum splattered across my face and chest. Of course, Jill's flailing spread it all over both of us.
We lay there panting and kissing for some time before Jill offered, "If those vampire sluts do show up, I'm game for anything."
"Are you sure?" I questioned.
"Definitely. But, there's no way it's getting better than what we've had together in the last year."
"I agree. There is no one sexier or more interested in trying new things than my Baby."
We kissed a while longer while Jill had fun pumping my ass with her plastic appendage. She had a few more mild orgasms before she brought me to another.
"I love fucking you," she exclaimed as we lie there in blissful recovery.
"Why is that?"
"I guess it's the thought of giving you pleasure the same way you give it to me. I love nothing more than feeling your cock pump in and out of my wanton vagina."
"I can understand that. What do you say we double-team one those vampire sluts, filling both of her holes at the same time?"
"Oh, that sounds fun!" Jill squealed.
We lie there tangled in each other's arms and finally fell fast asleep. Jill woke first as the sun was beginning to rise. It was the birds chirping that stirred her naked body.