* * *
I can't help but admiring and envious of her astonishing beauty, her exposed, reddened buttock contrasted by her lean, porcelain like legs over my father's lap. I watch in silence as my father continues slapping her bare bottom, and her squirming and moaning.
After about a minute or so I can't stand the sight any longer.
"Daddy, please stop. I'm sure Chloe has learned her lesson." I plead with tears swelling in my eyes. I have no idea what my dad's plan is, or if he has any. How does he plan to get away with this? What if words spread out in school? I'm sure he'll be sent to prison and I'll be placed in foster home, and be the laughingstock of the school and the town for the rest of my life.
My father stops momentarily, looking askance at me. "Has she?"
Chloe quickly responds, "YES! I have! I'm really sorry and I promise I'll never hang out or even talk to Beth again."
"Ha! At this point you seriously think I care about what lesson you've learned and what promise you're going to keep? Have you already forgotten what I have in my camera? Get up!"
Chloe pushes herself away from his knees, awkwardly finding her balance with her underwear strapped around her calves. She's standing straight now, but not quite sure if she has permission to pull up her underwear.
My father grabs her ear and brings her into the house.
* * *
"Beth, move that chair in front of the mirror. Get the camera again and record." Father commands.
I quickly fetch the camera again from upstairs. Back in the dining room, there's an old long wooden back armless chair with a white cushion. I bring it to the living room facing the body-length mirror that's next to the TV, across from the couch. I'm not quite sure what he's up to at this point, but I know better not to ask.
He orders Chloe to take off her skirt and underwear, and kneel on the chair facing the mirror. Chloe obediently follows the order as well. Father orders me to turn on the recorder. I can see Chloe glaring at me with her red eyes through the mirror.
He stands behind her, so that she can see him from the mirror that he's admiring his marks on her deep red bottom. She's biting her lower lip, frowning, eyes wet, but doesn't mutter a word. She knows he's right. With the pictures at his hand there's nothing else she can do but obey whatever he wants her to do.
"Take off your top. Let me see your tits."
I gasp in silence. What? What is he doing now?
Chloe hesitated for a second, but not for long. She starts to move her hands around her waist to pull up her white tank top.
"Wait, leave the shirt on. Just take off the bra."
After Chloe removes her bra, he sticks his right hand inside her shirt, while standing at her back. I can see him rubbing her nipples and squeezing her breasts. Chloe shuts her eyes tightly to endure the discomfort and shame.
Then he pulls down the front of her shirts, so her large breasts are exposed and are hanging outside her tank top. Her breasts look like two perfect round melons, full and perky, with beautiful pink nipples on her white porcelain skin.