Though no one was around to overhear us, Arthur leaned toward me, bringing his lips to my ear. "I'd love to watch you and Dwight again, and I'm more than happy to pay for the privilege of doing so." He then went on to tell me just how much he would pay.
My eyes widened at his offer. "Um..." I floundered helplessly, unsure of how to reply. Arthur's words, and his nearness, started an insistent pulse of excitement low in my belly. That pulse almost instantly traveled to my pussy. Yet I couldn't stop myself from saying, "I don't understand. A man like you doesn't need to... pay to watch."
Arthur straightened up. Even in the shadows, I could discern his solemn expression. "I miss my wife terribly, Celia. While I'm not ready to start dating again, I still have certain... needs. For months now, I've taken care of those needs myself. But watching you and Dwight tonight, and coming just as you orgasmed... it made me feel so alive."
I dared to reach for his hand as I whispered, "I understand."
His shoulders visibly relaxed. "Take some time to think it over, and discuss it with Dwight," he said. "Can I give you my card?"
Still a bit stunned, I managed to nod. Arthur took a business card from his wallet and held it out to me, along with a very generous amount of cash. "I told Mona I'd give you your tip when I found you. I took care of her as well."
"Thank you." I even stumbled over those simple words.
"My pleasure, Celia. Hope I hear from you soon." With a playful wink, he turned and strode around the building.
I waited until he was out of sight before going inside. After a brief trip to the restroom to finish cleaning up, I returned to waiting tables. Dwight kept flashing me sly grins, which I did my best to ignore. Only when we'd closed up the bar and were ready to leave did I approach him. "Got a minute to talk?"
"Of course," he said. "My car okay?"
I nodded. Once we'd said goodnight to Mona and made sure she was safely inside her car, I settled into the passenger seat of Dwight's old Mustang.
He immediately reached for me, but I held up a hand and blurted out, "Arthur is willing to pay us to have sex while he watches."
When I told him how much Arthur would pay, his shock mirrored my own. "What?!"
I was relieved that he didn't reject the idea outright. "I haven't talked specifics with him yet," I went on. "I wanted to make sure you're interested."
Dwight turned farther in the driver's seat so that we faced each other. A streetlight provided some illumination, but I was glad to hide in the shadows it didn't reach. "Do you have a thing for this guy?" he asked.
I started to say no, then realized that would be a lie. After tonight, maybe I did have a thing for Arthur. But right now, it was an attraction I wanted to nurture from a safe distance. "You're the one I'm fucking," I pointed out. Placing a hand on his thigh, I added, "Wouldn't you like to earn that kind of money while doing something we both very much enjoy?" If I were completely honest, I'd admit that I was willing to do it for free. Having Arthur watch us earlier made me more aroused than I'd ever been before.
But I guessed Dwight would need the monetary incentive to go along with such an arrangement. My palm slid higher until I reached his crotch.
Though he moaned at my touch, he asked, "You sure we can trust him?"
"Absolutely." A grin formed on my lips. "Seeing as how you're already getting hard, I think the idea of him watching us turns you on."
"The idea of fucking you again is what turns me on," he said. "But alright, I'm game."
My pulse quickened at his words. Hadn't I been hoping to hear them? "I'll let Arthur know."
He looked down at my hand working between his thighs. "You shouldn't be a tease, playing with my dick like this."
"Who says I'm teasing?"
When Dwight reached for me again, I let him pull me onto his lap. It didn't take long for him to move the seat back, and for me to free his cock. He actually pulsed in my grasp.
"I can't get enough of you," he growled. "You look so sweet and innocent; I never would have guessed how dirty you are."
"Do you like me dirty?" I asked while straddling his thighs.
"I fucking love it!"
I rewarded him by sinking down onto his hard dick. With my hands on his shoulders, I began to move at a fervent pace. "We've got to stop fucking at work," I told him through a grin.
"I'm not sure I can!" Dwight leaned back against the seat, gazing up at me. "I'm always ready for your sweet pussy, Celia."
His words made me ride him even faster. I loved the way he filled me completely, heightening my lust until I was right on edge. "And I'm always ready to be your naughty little slut!"
Dwight's hips gave a fierce upward thrust while he held me fast. As our fucking grew frenzied, devoid of all control, I imagined Arthur watching us. The fantasy made me come in record time, and Dwight's loud groan let me know he was close as well. I couldn't help but wonder if he was imagining the same thing.
My wails sounded especially loud in the confines of Dwight's car. Even as I shook in his grip, I continued bouncing up and down on his cock, doing everything I could to prolong my bliss.
"I'm almost there!" he warned.
"Come inside me!" With previous partners, I'd always insisted on condoms, though I had an IUD. But I was consumed by a wild need for Dwight to fuck me with no barrier, and to feel him flood my pussy with his cum. It was as if my body craved every drop.
And he didn't need convincing. After driving his cock inside me with yet another powerful thrust, he came hard. I could feel the shudder coursing through him while he gave me what I so longed for.
This time, I kept Dwight inside me. Resting my head against his, I closed my eyes while he stroked my back.
"Are you sure you want to do this?" he whispered. "We can always tell him no."
I didn't hesitate to reply, "I'm sure." Maybe I answered too quickly, for I felt him tense a little beneath me. "Think of what we could do with the money," I added.
Dwight was quiet for a long moment. Finally, he said, almost grudgingly, "I guess we'd be fools to turn it down."
*****
When I contacted Arthur the next day, I struggled to hide my nervousness, yet his warm voice quickly put me at ease. Once we'd gotten the arrangements for payment out of the way, we decided on the following Monday evening for our get-together, which happened to be one of the rare nights when both Dwight and I were off work.
Just before we ended the call, Arthur's voice lowered to a murmur. "I'm so looking forward to this, Celia."
Though I realized how ridiculous it was to feel a rush of pleasure at his words, I grinned like a silly teenager. "Me, too."
On Monday night, Dwight picked me up at my apartment. I'd bought a new dress for the occasion, and while its bold red color suited me, I had to resist the urge to tug it farther down my thighs. The fabric was clingy, accentuating my every curve.
"My God, you're gorgeous!" Dwight's stare moved up and down my body as he spoke, and I noticed the growing heat in his brown eyes.
He'd dressed in jeans and a nice button-up shirt. I liked that he'd left the top buttons undone. "You look pretty damn fine yourself."
Dwight wrapped an arm around me as we walked to his car. I was glad to be able to hold onto him, for I didn't feel all that steady in my four-inch black heels. "Are you nervous?" he asked.
I was nervous, but I didn't want to admit it. "We've done this before."
"Yeah, but that wasn't planned. Tonight, it's like we're performing." He opened the passenger door of the Mustang for me.
Before I climbed into the car, I studied his face through dusk's deepening shadows. "Are you nervous?"
Dwight flashed a smile that bordered on cocky. "Trust me, sweetheart, I'll be able to perform."
During the drive to Arthur's house, we worked each other into a state with furtive caresses and kisses stolen at red lights. Beneath my dress, I wore only a thong, and the crotch of the skimpy undergarment was soon drenched. With my hand between Dwight's thighs, I could easily feel how hard he was for me.
When we reached Arthur's neighborhood, Dwight let out a low whistle. "Check out these mansions, Celia."
Looking around, I understood what Dwight meant: we didn't belong here. Arthur lived in a sprawling one-level dwelling, with a perfectly landscaped lawn and an attached garage. "It's a gorgeous place," I said, simply to fill the silence in the car.
Dwight parked in front of the closed garage door. "Yeah, I don't feel bad about taking this guy's money," he muttered.
"Hey." I placed a hand on his arm. "Arthur's a good man. He lost his wife last year; he's lonely, and..."
"I understand." Dwight released a sigh, but then he offered me a reassuring smile. "I promise I won't be an asshole."
We headed toward the front door, hand in hand. Arthur was quick to let us in after Dwight rang the doorbell, and he greeted us as though we were old friends. "Come on in," he said, giving my dress an appreciative stare. "You look absolutely beautiful, Celia."
I blushed at his compliment, all the while hoping Dwight didn't notice. "Thank you, Arthur."
"Please make yourself at home." He was still wearing office attire, and I wondered how late he'd worked that evening. Had he kept himself busy at his desk until the very last moment? His tie was gone, and he'd rolled his shirtsleeves up his forearms.
While he closed and locked the door, engaging the security system, Dwight and I took off our shoes. I was happy to be rid of the uncomfortable heels.
"You have a really nice place," Dwight said.
As Arthur explained that he was thinking of selling, since the house was too large for one person, I tried not to be obvious in glancing around. Instead of checking out the expensive décor, I found myself studying a large painting on the living room wall. It was of a stunning woman who appeared to be in her mid-forties. Her blonde hair was styled in an elegant updo, and as she sat in a high-backed chair with her hands folded in her lap, I noticed the wedding ring she wore. Her gaze was almost dreamy, focused on something in the distance, and her smile, while faint, held an unmistakable happiness.
I ended up being way too obvious, for Arthur paused at my side and said quietly, "That's my late wife, Melody."
"Beautiful," was all I could say while gazing up at her portrait.
"Yes, she was." Arthur's voice grew thick with emotion, and I feared I'd only worsened his grief. Yet he quickly recovered. Turning to Dwight, he said, "How about I make the three of us some drinks? I won't even pretend to be as skilled at it as you are, Dwight. But you're here for pleasure, not work."