Present Day:
“Dad… Dad, are you in there?”
Silly question really because I know he is in the house somewhere.
I work as a Family Physician in a local medical clinic and visit home a couple of times a week to check on my father who lives alone. This evening when I enter the house, it is dark, no lights, and the heating is set excessively low. I turn up the thermostat and switch on the kitchen and living room lights.
I find dad asleep, sitting in his recliner in front of the switched off television.
He is sound asleep with his sweatpants pushed down around his knees and holding a pair of my panties in his lap.
~ ~ ~
I owe my dad everything.
I was twenty-one years old and in my third year of medical school when my mother, Barbara, died. She had been sick for two years before the end, and then our small close family of three became a traumatized family of two. Although her eventual passing was expected, it still came as a hammer blow.
I do not know where my Dad found the strength to continue, but he did so in spite of his loss and pain. Perhaps my struggles to complete my medical education gave him purpose because he provided me unconditional love, emotional support and paid the bills even as his furniture business was going through difficult times. He funded my years of medical school and residency. Thanks to my father, I fulfilled my mother’s hopes for me, responded to his devotion and achieved my own aspirations.
I am now twenty-eight years old and thanks to my dad, I am a Doctor.
So I should understand what is going on with my dad, right?
~ ~ ~
Three Years Earlier:
This particular situation had its beginnings a couple of years earlier when I was twenty-five years old and trying to survive my second year of residency at a local hospital. The hours were brutal, but I had divided my living arrangements between staying in the student apartments adjacent to the hospital and going home for a few hours each week to check on my dad.
On one of my days back home, I was doing what I habitually did, cleaning up after my dad. Those chores consisted mostly of tidying the house, washing dishes and doing laundry. I had just hung my dad’s freshly laundered shirts in his closet and had begun vacuuming the carpet in his bedroom when I moved a couple of pairs of shoes out of the way to run the vacuum cleaner under his bed. It was at that moment I discovered a little pile of female undergarments.
The second I saw them and realized what I was seeing, I was surprised, and then I burst out laughing. Oh my god, dad had finally found himself a girlfriend. A secret one at that, because he had never mentioned a word to me about meeting someone special or dating anyone in particular.
To my knowledge, dad had no women friends at all in the years since mom passed. In my years of residency at the hospital and earlier at university he had never mentioned other women, had never brought one home and in fact, he did not seem to have a social life what so ever.
It was always a concern to me.
Although I felt some guilt over the time I could not spend around home, my chosen career demanded my full attention. I had my mom’s wishes to honor along with my undying love and gratitude to my father who was breaking his back in his business to ensure that I received that medical education.
After mom passed, I had hoped dad would join a men’s club, take up fishing or god forbid, buy himself a pair of lime-green trousers and an orange shirt and learn to play golf or at least something requiring social interaction outside of his work, but he did not. He just worked at the store every day, went home each evening and then returned to work the following morning.
As for that small pile of intimates, I had inadvertently discovered...
I felt it extremely important that I respect my father’s privacy and so giggling like a schoolgirl, I carefully vacuumed under his bed being extremely careful to steer around the pile of nylon and lace trophies my dad had collected. When I completed cleaning under his bed, I could not resist an amused glance at the little collection.
I switched off the vacuum cleaner and poked the pile with the end of the hose, and as the little heap fell apart and separated, the items lost their anonymity, and I could recognize each individual garment.
They were all my own panties.
I seriously doubted that my dad had taken up cross-dressing and from their scrunched up appearance it was evident that my panties were soiled. If I eliminated the possibility of another woman wearing, staining and discarding them under his bed, then my dad was using them for his pleasure.
There I was, a twenty-five year old, reasonably well-educated and levelheaded woman, not knowing whether to freak out screaming or pretend I had seen nothing, close his bedroom door and run away.
I sat down on the side of dad’s bed and tried to draw a breath. I attempted to think of a harmless, simple explanation, but there really was not one.
Dismissing the obvious was difficult. My underwear had not migrated themselves from the dresser in my bedroom to the carpet under my father’s bed.
I was reasonably well trained working as I did in a medical field and yet found myself lost as to this situation. It was proof positive that one can be educated to the point of inertia.
I said nothing to my father about my discovery and returned to my apartment at the hospital the following day.
Don’t get me wrong. Yes, I was confused and more than a little freaked, but I did seek advice. I was in the correct career to be able to tap into research, co-workers, and friends to find answers.
Posing the question as a hypothetical, or a possible hospital related inquiry, I asked various friends and co-workers about an unidentified client’s dilemma, i.e., a grown daughter discovers her dad has been using her underwear for sexual gratification.
The answers were quickly forthcoming from both female and male co-workers. They ran the gamut from intellectually obtuse, to outrage, and lewd snickers.
‘It is totally inappropriate for a father to have taken a pair of his daughter’s underwear, for ANY reason.’
‘There may be people who would rationalize such behavior, but I can't think of a single one.’
‘I don't envy your client’s position. It sounds as if her dad has some issues going on.’
‘Wow, that dad is a total sicko.’
‘Obviously a case of misplaced affection possibly related to his lack of any familial, social, or romantic intimacy.’
‘It sounds to me that he is deranged.’
‘Perhaps he has a sexual attraction for his daughter, or perhaps not. The underwear perhaps may simply be a generalized symbol representing all females, not necessarily his daughter. But it sounds fucked up to me.’
‘A father using his daughter’s underwear, that’s like so fucking gross.’
Now even though many people would find the behavior to be gross, the term “gross” actually means ‘to the naked eye,’ so that opinion was from someone who did not even know the English language.
After a few more of those helpful insights, I reached out to a mentor I had studied with during my internship, and who I respected. She was a long-time psychiatrist.
Her advice was direct and to the point.
‘THAT WOMAN NEEDS TO CONFRONT HER FATHER ABOUT THIS! It is unconscionable for him to steal his own daughter’s clothing. One might argue a thin line between admiration, and unhealthy obsession, and by that, I mean some form of comfort item may be excusable, but the theft and sexual use of a daughter’s underthings is inappropriate at the least and foul and disgusting at worst. It would be my considered opinion that her father has an ongoing father-daughter incest fantasy and is in need of immediate, professional psychiatric help.’
Now, where was I to go with advice like that?
This was my own father who I was attempting to analyze and diagnose. God only knows we had both suffered from mom’s passing and yet he had sacrificed and done his very best for me. Did I really want to confront him about something as silly as panties? ‘Hey dad, do you enjoy getting off with my underwear?’
Another glaring possibility was that if I attempted some form of psychiatric intervention and it became public knowledge, it could well destroy whatever was left of my father.
Should I tell him that he has a mental problem and that his behavior is morally reprehensible, plain wrong and disgusting or dismiss the use of pieces of material for emotional comfort as inconsequential?
The choices appeared to be to say nothing, or the alternative, an ultimatum to, ‘get help or I will cut you out of my life.’
It seemed that the more I learned, the less I knew. I do not care if it emanates from years of clinical research or a group of guys talking over beers in a bar, what you do learn is that everyone has an opinion and it does not necessarily follow that it is right or wrong. What it is; is just an opinion.
What did I learn from all of that advice? I learned what everyone else intrinsically knows. Opinions are like anuses, everybody has one. It is easy to make a judgment on people when you do not know them, but he is my dad.
I cared about my dad.
I loved him.
~ ~ ~
Okay, it did not make it right; my dad should not be using my underwear in that manner. Was it disgusting and depraved, an incestuous perversion or something relatively harmless? I decided to put some distance on it, and I stopped worrying about it. It pleasured my father, it was private and of no one else's concern. What the hell, it was just a pair of panties.
You can overthink, worry too much and drive yourself crazy when perhaps the simplest thing to do was to give it some room and lessen the emotional factors associated with it.
I did allow some time to pass. However, I eventually spoke to my father about it. It was inevitable. I did wish to clarify issues in an understanding and nonaccusatory manner.
I began with the obvious, the one over-riding concern, the primary question that I felt needed answering. I was compelled to ask even though I already suspected the answer.
I asked him quite plainly. "Dad, how can you be using my underwear for sexual gratification, without it being some form of incestuous fascination?”
He smirked and spread his hands a little too dismissively, replying, “You don’t think that most young boys haven’t been curious about their sisters and mothers panties, or husbands looking through their wife’s lingerie. I know you are disgusted with my behavior, but at least I am honest enough to admit it….
“I found your hidden collection, Dad.” I snapped back. “I’m not so sure that makes you honest. If you needed… ah… comfort items of that nature for sexual stimulation, you could have bought items for you to use. We could have gone to a department store and bought items for you.”
Dad looked at me. “I didn’t want store bought things, Mary. I wanted something more personal. Not a piece of rag, Mary, but something pretty of yours.”
That was not what I wanted to hear. It changed dad’s fascination with a conventional universal female symbol and made it personal, extraordinarily sexual and potentially incestuous.
I tried to address it head-on. “But Dad… you aren’t supposed to use your own daughter’s underwear for sexual pleasure… it’s… “
“Perverted and kinky?” He broke in. “That I’m a sick old man? Do you know how much you resemble your mother… your hair, your smile, even your voice… You know I hoped you might wear some of her dresses, you know, just sometimes, at least around the house.””
That was the most chilling moment. Had dad’s loneliness and grief finally taken him to a place where he envisioned his daughter as a surrogate, a look-alike… wife?
For my soul, I could not be angry with him and strove for some understanding. “DAD… dad, please… Dad, I am not Mom, I am not Barbara. I am your daughter Mary.”
Dad reached out and took my hand. “I know hon, I know. You just look so much like your mom when we were dating…”
“You need to find yourself a girlfriend, Dad.”
Dad had tears in his eyes. “I really do miss your mom.” He replied.
“You miss mom, so you take my panties. How does that explain anything?”
As long as I live, I will never forget his eyes.
He reached out and brushed my hair with his hand. “You have her hair and face, you smile the same way, and you even laugh the way that she did. You look just like Barbara did in our early years of marriage.”
“But I can’t be Mom for you dad. I am your daughter, Mary.”
“I know that, Girl. I’m not crazy. But please understand that so much of you, is your mom.”
~ ~ ~
When my father has sexual interludes with my panties, the sexual nature of his behavior was undeniable. He was sexualizing me, his daughter, whatever his protestations that he was only missing mom.