Timothy and Ben immediately stood out to me on OkCupid. Most of the “couple” profiles were a man and a woman. They usually said something along the lines of, “wanting to surprise my man with a threesome for his birthday!” but I wasn’t interested in unicorn hunters. I wanted a threesome the way I had always dreamed about.

I wanted two hot, bisexual men having their way with me in bed.

“Hey guys!” I typed in the message box to Timothy and Ben. “You two are both very hot. Hope you like what you see of me. Interested in meeting up? Let me know!”
They were both slim and toned, with Ben being slightly taller and covered in tattoos. Timothy was shorter with close-shaven dark hair. I could already picture myself being used by them.

I was excited when they messaged back right away, and the three of us made plans to get drinks that Saturday night.

I strolled into the bar in my cutest, most form-fitting black dress and heels. My light blonde hair was done in thick curls, and my lips were covered in pink gloss. I felt sexy, and I hoped they’d agree, too. 

The three of us hit it off. We chatted and flirted for a couple of hours, and it was like we had instant chemistry. I hadn’t necessarily been expecting to hook up with them the same night we met, but when Timothy asked if I wanted to go back to their apartment with them, I couldn’t resist.

Thirty minutes later, I found myself getting the grand tour of Timothy and Ben's nice loft apartment, which was a spacious two-bedroom decked out in the best furniture. 

“And this,” said Ben, turning on the light in the room we had just entered, “is our bedroom.”

He adjusted the light so that it was dim and golden. 

“What do you think, Becca?” Timothy asked, grabbing me gently by the waist. He sat on the edge of the bed and held me in between his legs. 

“It’s so nice here.”

“Could you see yourself getting fucked on this bed?” he asked, his dark green eyes piercing mine. His tone was serious and no-nonsense, and it made me blush. 

“Yes,” I replied quietly. “A lot.” My pussy was throbbing.

While I began to make out with Timothy, Ben stood behind me and unzipped my dress. He took off all my clothes, making me shiver on the spot. His large hands caressed my body. They ran across my ass cheeks, up my spine, and around to my tits. He squeezed them together, massaging them, while Timothy's tongue slipped into my mouth.

“Get on your hands and knees and suck my cock,” said Timothy suddenly. He stood up and got undressed quickly, his cock already halfway hard as it sprung out of his underwear.

While I began to lower my mouth up and down Timothy’s big cock, I could hear Ben undressing behind me. He gave my naked ass a few good smacks, making me squirm.

“Focus,” said Timothy sharply, as his cock slipped out of my mouth briefly. 

Ben ran his fingers over my pussy, prodding me. The cold, harsh nature of his touch made me horny, and when he finally pushed apart my lips, he found me very wet.

“Someone’s a good little slut,” Ben said approvingly.

He pressed his cock inside of me, slowly and intentionally. I reflexively arched my back, which pushed my ass out so he could have even deeper access to my pussy. 

“Good girl,” Ben sighed with a click of his tongue, “that’s what I like to see.”
I was stuck in between two cocks for the next ten minutes of my life. Several times, I was close to cumming, but the minute that Ben realized it, he backed off. He told me I wasn’t going to get to cum without permission.

Finally, we all crawled on top of the bed. My pussy felt empty without cock in it, and my jaw was deliciously sore from sucking off Timothy for so long. I was grateful when the guys started to fuck me again. This time, Timothy got behind me in a spooning position and began to fuck me passionately from behind while Ben laid in front of me in a 69 position, eating my pussy while he fucked my face.

I had never had sex quite like this before, with nearly every part of my body and all of my senses being used by two men. 

“Fuck, that’s hot,” groaned Timothy into my ear. His hand had a firm hold on my waist as he fucked me. His cock sunk into me and stretched me out in a way that Ben's skinnier cock hadn’t. 

I wasn’t sure what all the guys had in store for me. We had talked about some ideas while chatting at the bar, so I shouldn’t have been so surprised when they both pulled out of my holes, spread my arms and legs apart, and tied me to the bed.

I was completely restrained and spread eagle for them both, and I watched in horny agony as Ben and Timothy began to make out in between my legs. It was sexy to watch them kissing and caressing, as they each stroked their cock's. 

“Okay,” said Ben, turning his gaze back to me now. “What should we do with you now?”

“Would our little toy like to cum?” asked Timothy, smiling evilly. 

I nodded. “Yes, please!” My voice was dripping with eagerness. The sensation of nearly cumming had been building up in me the entire night. I was more than ready for it.

Ben opened up the nightstand and pulled out a vibrator. He turned it on high and pressed it against my clit, immediately making me pull and yank at my restraints.

“I think she likes it, baby,” said Ben, laughing as he looked at Timothy.

When I came, it was uncontrollable. I was a shaking, dripping mess. The guys leaned over to play with my nipples and tits as I orgasmed, only prolonging the intensity of my climax. They knew just how to tease me and drive me mad.

After I was finished cumming, with my body still weak and shaking, Timothy plunged his cock into me while Ben got behind him to eat his ass.

“Since you’ve been so compliant for us,” said Timothy, “how does receiving two loads of cum up your cunt sound?”
“I would love it,” I said. My voice was so breathy and frantic. I could have done this all night with them.

Ben's tongue up Timothy's asshole must have made my pussy feel even better, because Timothy didn’t last very long. He pumped into me a few more times, hard strokes that hit my very centre, and then he was flooding me with spunk. Timothy threw his head back and moaned, his jaw opening and closing with pleasure. My toes curled.

Finally, Timothy pulled out and it was Ben's turn to have his way with my sloppy pussy.

“Goddamn,” he said, pulling apart my pussy lips to observe the amount of cum gushing from me. “She’s really been properly filled up.”

I bit my lower lip. I felt like a true sex toy. 

Ben was not as gentle as Timothy. He bucked his hips wildly against me, slamming his cock over and over into my pussy. He only slowed down when his boyfriend spread apart his ass cheeks and stuck his tongue into his asshole.

“Shiiiiiit,” moaned Ben, “you ready for this cum, little slut?”

“I am! Give it to me! Please. . .” I whimpered, trailing off as Ben wiggled his hips, making his cock sweep every inch of my pussy.

Ben had just as much cum built up as Timothy did. It gushed inside of me, hot and thick. I could feel is splashing against the walls of my pussy, and when he finally pulled out, a big gush of cum went with him. It began pooling underneath me.

The guys began to undo my restraints, rubbing my wrists and ankles as they went. Ben brought a pillow under my head while Timothy went to the kitchen to get us all some water.

“What did you think?” asked Ben, his lips quirked up into a half-smile. He was tracing light circles around my breasts.

“You guys are fucking fun,” I giggled and shook my head. “Seriously, where did you two come from?”
“Are you guys talking about me?” asked Timothy, when he came back with the water.

“I didn’t want to speak for you,” said Ben, “but I was just about to tell Becca that we might be interested in having a lot more fun with her very soon.”

Timothy crawled onto the bed on the other side of me. He scooped me up in his arms, and suddenly, the three of us were in one big embrace.

“No, I agree,” said Timothy, breathing against my hair. “Lots more fun, very soon.”

A blissful smile crept up my face. I couldn’t believe my fantasy had come true.