Quote by CassidyCumsFirst
He might be scared of getting you pregnant because he doesn't believe that your telling him the truth. Sometimes girls try to trap guys into marriage that way.

One way of finding out for sure is have him fuck your ass and see if he still pulls out. If he doesn't bother to pull out, then you know for sure he wasn't pulling out of your pussy cause he thought you were lying about being on the pill. If he does pull out of your ass, then maybe he just likes to shoot his load on you or try for the money shot.