Join the best erotica focused adult social network now
Login

Lobster or Crab?

last reply
66 replies
7.4k views
1 watcher
9 likes
Which do you prefer?

Lobster seems to be the epitome of decadence when it comes to seafood.



Being from the Pacific Northwest, we have dungeoness crab, which many people insist is actually better.



I disagree. I prefer lobster personally. The claws are my favorite. I know a lot people like lobster tails, but I find the tail meat stringy.

With crabs, I find that there is just too much work involved for the amount of meat you get.

I do like king crab legs though.



Do you like lobster? Pacific? Atlantic?

Crabs? Softshell? Dungeoness?

Langoustines?



Recipes?
I will take the crab in the second picture. We have plenty down here in Louisiana. I have tried lobster a couple time but did not care for it. My favorite crab dish is Crab Meat AuGratin or Shrimp and Crab Meat Au Gratin. Also love Crab Meat sautéed in butter with or without mushrooms to top a good steak. They are also very good in the soft shell stage on a Poor-Boy, dressed. Having them this way avoids the work of picking the meat. But it is worth it. Give me about half a dozen nice fat ones, boiled in Zatarain's Crab & Shrimp boil, with an empty and a full bottle of Barq's Root Beer. Brandie will be one happy Cajun Gal.

Now I'm hungry!

Brandie
I have eaten a fair bit of both. My wife lived in the Canadian Maritimes during our engagement so we had fresh lobster whenever I visited and we still score a couple every now and then (tank-grown ones from grocery stores, though). But she's also Chinese and they primarily eat crab over there. In fact, on my first trip there to meet the in-laws, I had probably 3 or 4 different types of crab including a freshwater species with hairlike spikes on it's shell (as good as any saltwater one, too). Her sister lived on an island that had a crab fishery at that time so we had some fresh sea crab, too.

In the end, I guess I enjoy both. We actually use a homemade Chinese crab dip (soy sauce and some other seasonings) for lobster so we even cross them over.
Lobster is my first choice.

Anyone up for a crawfish boil and ice cold PBRs?
Quote by Buz
Lobster is my first choice.

Anyone up for a crawfish boil and ice cold PBRs?



The UGA rep is completely correct
Quote by Buz
Lobster is my first choice.

Anyone up for a crawfish boil and ice cold PBRs?



The UGA rep is completely correct
I'm clearly a lobster-enthusiast between the two, although I frankly can't establish a fair lobster/crab comparison as I've always eaten them in completely different circumstances: lobster always fresh and eaten in full (ie. from a live lobster), crab always pre-prepared and eaten as part of a meal that incorporated many other seafood (eg. paella or similar dishes).

The Maritime provinces of Canada are pretty much a lobster-paradise, and we do have our fair share of lobster fishing here in Quebec too, mostly from either La Gaspésie or Les Îles de la Madeleine. My neighbors before I moved to a new apartment were an old retired couple from La Gaspésie and huge lobster connoisseurs. Oddly enough, they always told me that lobster from Les Îles de la Madeleine was better because it mostly lives in rocks rather than living in sand. I've never bothered to investigate the rationale behind it, but considering that this advice essentially forced them to betray their own native region, I've always trusted their recommendation.

Anyway, I usually have 1-2 lobster meal(s) per year during the season (May to July). I obviously favor lobsters from Les Îles de la Madeleine and usually buy rather large live lobsters between 1.5 and 2.0 lbs. If I buy them at an appropriate time when they're being sold for around $10/lbs, that normally translates to no more than around $15-20 per lobster. I'm admittedly a somewhat shitty cook (or rather I'm not all that invested in cooking), but cooking live lobsters is just so ridiculously easy: you just have to cut the rubber bands around their claws and dump them in salty boiling water for around 20 minutes. And I'm naturally writing in the 1st person to express my own undertaking when I'm hosting a lobster evening with my girlfriend (at either of our places), but I'm honestly just as likely to be invited to one myself by either friends or family.

Like DamonX the claws are my favorite part to eat; the legs taste just as good to me but they're quite a bit more trouble for the tiny amount of meat that you get. I usually start by eating the legs to get them out of the way, then the tail, then I finish my meal with the delicious claws. And I totally eat the tomalley too (wow that's a lot of Ts), that green stuff that lobsters have inside their bellies; and the roe if my lobster happens to be a female.

Simply delicious.


Extra bit of trivia: I once read that lobster was considered rather shitty food prior to the 19th century and mostly offered to servants and prisoners. Isn't that so goddamn ironic and hilarious?
not a huge fan of lobster. most likely because i rarely eat it. however, crab is something i eat a lot of and associate with good times. my favorites are alaskan king and snow crab. i like blue crab as well, but it really is a lot of work for little pay off. when i can't get actual crab, crab cakes and deviled crab are a welcome substitute.

Say. Her. Name.


There’s a steakhouse where I live that makes a crab cocktail... it’s basically sweet delicious lump crab meat on top of a cocktail sauce that is more like a small salad than a sauce. They also have lobster mashed potatoes which is made with a whole lobster’s worth of meat. It’s a dead on tie. They both are king worthy dishes.

Another Japanese place makes snow crab legs that have half the shell cut off so you can just pull the meat out. They’re topped with a spicy aioli and ikura... it’s fucking awesome. Way better than their lobster dishes.

It honestly all comes down to how they’re prepared. I’ve had chicken dishes that were better than beef dishes but I wouldn’t call chicken better than beef. Give a good chef a piece of chicken and he’ll make a better dish than a mediocre chef with a piece of aged New York steak.
Lobster all the way! I do enjoy crab but I don't want to work for my meal.
Love both but in the UK these items are beyond my budget for food... very expensive.
We call Lobster 'crayfish' down here in Kiwiland. I don't eat a lot of seafood, and I eat even less shellfish. But, in the past, I have enjoyed the odd crab and crayfish. Very sweet meat, I've found. Delicious.
Quote by Lauradj
We call Lobster 'crayfish' down here in Kiwiland. I don't eat a lot of seafood, and I eat even less shellfish. But, in the past, I have enjoyed the odd crab and crayfish. Very sweet meat, I've found. Delicious.


to my favorite Kiwi.

Here, crayfish (or crawfish, or crawdad) is a freshwater crustacean that looks similar to a lobster. See Buz's post upthread. The US South is famous for cray/crawfish, among other great bits of cuisine.
Quote by Buz
Lobster is my first choice.

Anyone up for a crawfish boil and ice cold PBRs?


NOW YOUR TALKING "SUMPTING" ( Cajun for something ) REALLY GOOD!!!!! Not sure what PBRs are, but give me an ice cold Barq's. Won't need the empty Barq"s bottle for the crawfish. Then get out of this Cajun gal's way. Cause I know how to pinch dem tails and suck dem heads.

Brandie

PS; How do y'all boil crawfish in Atlanta? Or, are you a transplant from South LA.
Quote by seeker4


to my favorite Kiwi.

Here, crayfish (or crawfish, or crawdad) is a freshwater crustacean that looks similar to a lobster. See Buz's post upthread. The US South is famous for cray/crawfish, among other great bits of cuisine.


We're generalists down here Sugar Daddy. We know there is a difference between lobster and crayfish, however, crayfish is much more plentiful down here, we hardly ever see a proper big ol' lobster, so everything that looks similar to one is a crayfish. I mean, if we're gonna start pulling countries/continents up on stuff, I could pull North America up on how everything that looks vaguely prawn-like, you guys generalise and call shrimp. They're bloody prawns!
Quote by Lauradj


We're generalists down here Sugar Daddy. We know there is a difference between lobster and crayfish, however, crayfish is much more plentiful down here, we hardly ever see a proper big ol' lobster, so everything that looks similar to one is a crayfish. I mean, if we're gonna start pulling countries/continents up on stuff, I could pull North America up on how everything that looks vaguely prawn-like, you guys generalise and call shrimp. They're bloody prawns!


Actually, we do have "Shrimp" and "prawns" though most (at least in Canada) tend to use the words interchangeably or at least don't fuss too much about the difference. They aren't that much different really when it comes right down to it. They're both edible, which is what matters when push comes to shove.AJj4EAQktGcSeCYh

I grew up eating jumbo gulf shrimp, which are almost never over six inches long. My introduction to prawn was at La Frigate, a French restaurant at Da Nang in Vietnam. A serving was three prawn. These monsters were about twelve inches long and as thick as my cock. Three was about as much as I could handle. They were served grilled, but I bet deep fried would be wonderful. I later found out that you could buy prawns on the docks for fifty cents a piece. Lobsters were one dollar.
I'm not a huge fan of either and I've had both fresh from the ocean. Both creepy-crawl about the ocean floor; have you ever seen the ocean floor and what humans dump into it? In my typical contradictory manner I am rather partial to lobster rolls.
Any food that I have to break into isn't worth the trouble.
And how hungry did the guy have to be to discover escargot?
Lobster.
Depends on how they're prepared.

░P░U░S░S░Y░ ░I░N░ ░B░I░O░


Quote by Lauradj
We call Lobster 'crayfish' down here in Kiwiland. I don't eat a lot of seafood, and I eat even less shellfish. But, in the past, I have enjoyed the odd crab and crayfish. Very sweet meat, I've found. Delicious.


I thought you call them "bugs?"

Pacific lobster are quite a bit different than Atlantic. They have no claws so they are kind of just like big shrimp.

If you want the real lobsta experience you have to get those huge 50 year old atlantic ones from the North Atlantic. Crack those claws open and dip them in lemon butter.


I'm actually against using either crab or lobster mixed in with other stuff. It's such a delicate flavor that I find overpowering it with strong spices or rich sauces just overpowers the subtlety.
Quote by Buz
Lobster is my first choice.

Anyone up for a crawfish boil and ice cold PBRs?


I love crawfish too. But you need sooo many of them to make a meal. Super hard to get in the Pacific Northwest too.

I have to order them in frozen and its just not the same. There's one restaurant in Vancouver that serves them. The crawfish boil is definitely more of a social thing. Kind of like eating softshell crabs on the East Coast. You just pour them all out on a picnic table and have at her' .

If anyone is ever in Seattle, go to the Crabpot. It's a great casual place on the waterfront.




You get a bib and a hammer....
Quote by DamonX
I thought you call them "bugs?"

Pacific lobster are quite a bit different than Atlantic. They have no claws so they are kind of just like big shrimp.

If you want the real lobsta experience you have to get those huge 50 year old atlantic ones from the North Atlantic. Crack those claws open and dip them in lemon butter.


I'm actually against using either crab or lobster mixed in with other stuff. It's such a delicate flavor that I find overpowering it with strong spices or rich sauces just overpowers the subtlety.


I've heard many times that larger lobsters tend to not be as flavorful as smaller ones. Regular ones are typically around 1.00 to 1.25 lbs. The ones I usually select myself are somewhat bigger and around 1.5 to 2.0 lbs, which I've always found plenty sufficient for each person. To me that's always been the best size to choose for both perfect flavor and perfect quantity.

And I fully agree about the whole 'not mixing with other stuff'. I always eat my lobsters with plain white rice, that way the taste of your lobster isn't tainted by any other flavors while your rice will inevitably adopt the flavor of your delicious lobster/butter. I think that many restaurants that serve elaborate lobster meals do so because they can't get their hands on 100% fresh lobster (or won't be bothered to keep a stock of live lobsters). Can't really blame them and I'm sure they can come up with great recipes nonetheless, but if you're in a region where lobsters are abundant, just buy them live and cook/eat them within a few hours.
as a native new englander, it simply must be... lobstah! personally, chicken lobstahs make for the tastiest lobstahs
I'm a New Englander too who worked for years in the Lobstah Industry and got so sick of the animal I couldn't eat it for years. Now that I can eat it again, I still prefer cold water, hard shell crab. I have also eaten abalone in Hawaii and Conch in the Bahamas. Conch is really very good stuff. We also eat lots of clams here, both quahogs and Little Necks. For those who like sushi, try digging up quahogs, opening them right there in the water, squishing them in the water to get any sand out, and them scrape them off the shell with a knife, and eat then alive! Incredible!!
I am not a particularly big fan of crab legs or lobster tails. I do enjoy a good lobster roll or lobster bisque and I make a pretty good crab cake, or so I have been told.
Lobster it isn't even close
Crayfish ou lobster, you just cut it in two part, get the brain and mix it with butter to make a easy sauce, nap the sauce on each flesh of the two parts, and between 3 and 5 minutes in a oven or better on a barbecue.
Enjoy