Join the best erotica focused adult social network now
Login

Breaking All the Rules

"Couples agree to a swap but not everyone follows the rules"

62
12 Comments 12
2.3k Views 2.3k
10.0k words 10.0k words

Author's Notes

"This story was inspired by danniloves19. The character "Danni" is modeled after her. That is her in the cover image. The sex is based on her fantasies. If any other women want me to write their fantasies, please send me a message."

"Honey, I need to talk to you," Anna told her boyfriend.

"What's up?" asked Joe.

"So you remember Danni, my friend from work?"

"The cute Southern Belle with nice ... assets?" he asked, miming breasts.

"That's the one. So I've talked to her in the past about how we've had threesomes and swung. I guess she told her fiance, and they are interested in doing a swap."

"Really? Well, I know I'd be interested in Danni. How's the fiance?"

"Shocker, Joe is interested in the bubbly 23-year-old with perky tits and a sexy accent. Here is my shocked face," joked Anna, mugging a stern face. "But seriously, he is not bad. I've talked to him a few times when he picked Danni up from work—decent vibes and kind of handsome. Danni assures me he has the proper equipment to do the job. Just one issue..."

"Uh oh. What's that?"

"So they are both a bit young and haven't done anything like this before. Apparently, they have a bunch of rules they want everyone to follow."

"Oh boy. What rules?" Joe said with a chuckle.

"I don't know, but they want to meet for drinks tomorrow to discuss."

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Joe and Anna, both 32 years old, had been in a semi-open relationship for six years. They met in the gym. Joe was Anna's trainer. It wasn't long before Joe went from shouting orders and encouragement at Anna in the gym to shouting orders and encouragement at her in the bedroom.

Joe was a classic fuckboy. Everyone said he looked like a young Jon Hamm. At 6'2'' with an athlete's body and sparkling blue eyes, he had no problem attracting women. He had run up quite the body count before he met Anna.

Anna was a classic ugly duckling. She was chubby and awkward in high school. She spent her time reading, mostly spicy fantasy and sci-fi. She loved stories about 8-foot-tall orcs and aliens kidnapping human women before seducing and falling in love with them.

In college, she blossomed and slimmed down. The guys in college called her "the Sleeper Agent" because her plain Jane appearance masked a sexually aggressive and adventurous nympho. She had gathered a small harem of frat boys and athletes of both genders who would come running the moment she summoned them.

By the time she met Joe, she had learned to style and dress herself, so men found her quite attractive. After they started hooking up, Joe quickly fell in love with her. He was happy to give up other women, but Anna pushed for a more adventurous sex life. They engaged in threeways and foursomes. This past summer, they took an ocean cruise and engaged in the swinger lifestyle.

While their sexual adventures were primarily driven by Anna, Joe enjoyed them. He particularly got off on pleasing women in ways their partners could not or would not. Many of the men in the swinging scene were selfish lovers, just looking to add to their body count without regard for anyone else's pleasure. Hearing a woman say, "My husband never..." was about the sexiest thing he could imagine. He went wild.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Danni and her fiance, George, had been college sweethearts. Now 23 years old, they met in their sophomore year of college at South Mississippi University. They both grew up in conservative households. They both lost their virginities to their high school sweethearts. Danni fooled around with a couple of guys during freshman year of college but didn't count them. George had two previous partners.

They got engaged the week of their graduation and moved up north to Chicago for their new jobs. George was in finance. Danni taught special ed at a school with Anna.

Anna shared stories of her sexcapades with Danni. Danni had always believed in one-woman/one-man, but hearing Anna discuss her open sex life with no shame or embarrassment planted a seed in her mind. Was she going to regret not sowing her wild oats when she was young?

Danni shared Anna's stories with her fiance. She could tell he had the same doubts. With their wedding 3 months away, they decided to sow a few oats.

Danni was concerned that if they were going to sleep with other people, they needed to be responsible with each other's feelings. She had them each write a list of deal breakers so neither of them would have any regrets.

They both insisted on condoms being used. They didn't want to bring home any diseases. They also both agreed neither of the men should cum anywhere on or in the women. They had both used condoms with their previous partners, so they were the only person they shared cum with. They wanted to keep that sacred.

George didn't want Danni to tell the other man that he was better than George in any way, so they made the rule "No comparisons." They could say, "Your [X] is so hot," but couldn't say, "Your [X] is better than my fiance's."

George also proposed a one-and-done rule. George was not the type of guy to cum and get hard over and over again in a night. He didn't like the idea of him having sex once while Danni had sex multiple times.

Danni didn't want any degrading sex talk. She didn't want to be called a slut or a whore. She didn't want George calling anyone those names either.

Danni forbade the use of the word "love." That didn't just mean, "I love you." It also included "I love your [X]" or "I love how you do that." Those were both too close to "I love you." It was a slippery slope to avoid.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Danni and George were eager for their meeting with Joe and Anna. They got ready after work. Danni wore a white sundress with a low square neckline that laced up the front. It highlighted her perky braless tits and her tiny waist. The short skirt showed off her tanned legs. George wore a blue polo and jeans.

They were too eager to wait at home, so they showed up early. They sat next to each other in a booth, checking the door every few minutes. Danni was giddy. She was wet even though they were only meeting to talk. She noticed George was getting hard, too. She gave his cock a cheeky squeeze and giggled. George tickled her back. They could not sit still.

Both their heads shot around when they heard the door open. Anna walked in wearing a light orange summer sleeveless mini dress. It tightly hugged her curves while showing off her cleavage and toned legs. Joe wore a short-sleeved henley that hugged his muscles and broad shoulders. The short sleeves revealed his tattooed arms. Joe smiled at Danni, causing her jaw to drop. George mentally undressed Anna and liked what he imagined.

"Hey guys," called Anna, snapping Danni and George out of their stupors. Danni popped up to hug Anna.

"You must be George," said Joe as he offered his hand.

"Nice to meet you," replied George as he tried to give a firm handshake.

Joe turned and hugged Danni, surprising her. He enveloped her in his strong arms. He then took Anna's hand and led her to the seat next to George. He wordlessly gestured for Danni to sit on the other side of the booth. He slid next to her and put his arm around her. Anna sat next to George and gave him a quick peck on the lips, leaning her body into his while she let her hand linger on his chest.

"This is exciting, guys. I am happy we could get together," said Joe with a smile.

He held George's gaze, trying to gauge his reaction. Swinging is not for everyone, and they wanted to evaluate if George and Danni could handle it. Taking Danni from George's side to his and putting his arm around her were calculated moves, as was Anna's kiss.

Danni was staring up at Joe like a starstruck teenager. He was easily the most handsome man she had met in person. She loved how strong his arm and chest felt around her. He made her feel so small, like he could drop her in his pocket and walk away. She didn't notice what Anna was doing next to George.

George kept an eye on Joe, making sure he didn't try anything funny. Once he realized he was just going to put his arm around Danni, he let himself enjoy Anna's body against his. Her breasts smashed against his arm. Her hand played with the buttons on his shirt. He relaxed, his smile grew, and his cock stayed hard.

"I believe we have some things to discuss. What is on your mind?" Joe commanded the table the same way he commanded any room he walked into.

Danni was enjoying listening to his deep voice when George's voice broke through. She realized she was staring at Joe. She looked at George as he spoke and tried to play it cool. She blushed and hoped no one noticed how flustered she was.

"Yeah, Danni and I have been discussing this. We are both really into the idea of swapping with you guys. We just want to make sure everyone has the same expectations so no one is disappointed or gets hurt."

Joe and Anna exchanged bemused glances at Danni and George's naiveté but politely remained quiet.

George fished out his phone and opened the Notes app. He and Danni went through their rules and the reasons behind them:

1. Must wear condoms

2. No cumming on or in the girls

3. No comparisons

4. One and done

5. No "love"

6. No degrading talk

"So what do y'all think?" asked Danni with her sweet Southern drawl.

Anna and Joe exchanged glances. Joe nodded to her to start.

"I don't think either of us have any issues with the rules, per se. Our concern is your inexperience and attitude. The two things that can lead to a bad swinging experience are jealousy and envy. A lot of people think swinging is a sexy idea, but the moment they see their partner with another person, jealousy takes over."

Joe chimed in, "But luckily, jealousy is the easy one to test. George, why don't you kiss Anna?"

"Wait, what?" George protested.

"Let's not dance around what's happening. We are all talking about having sex. If a little kissing makes things awkward, this can be a short conversation."

"You're right," said George as he tried to gauge Danni's reaction. She nodded at him.

George turned and gave Anna a chaste, closed-mouth kiss. Anna reached her hand behind his head and kissed back forcefully, pushing her tongue into his mouth. She continued to kiss him as she took his hand and put it on her breast. She then lowered her hand to his lap and gave his cock a squeeze. George returned the squeeze on her breast. Anna broke the kiss and looked into his eyes for a few moments before turning back to Joe and Danni. George's hand lingered a moment longer on her breast.

"Danni, how did that make you feel?"

Danni had enjoyed that little show more than she expected. It was a sexy kiss to witness, first off. Second, she loved seeing George so turned on. He is usually in charge when they have sex. Seeing him being submissive and blown away was hot. Anna could probably teach him a few things. Finally, she was a little envious of George. Anna was so sexy and confident. She wished she could have been on the receiving end of her kiss.

"I think that was incredibly sexy. I think George enjoyed it too."

Anna interrupted before George could respond, "I know he enjoyed it." Anna made a show of her running her hand along George's cock and thigh.

George blushed and stammered. "What can I say? That was a swell kiss from a real lovely gal."

They all chuckled at George's phrasing.

"Well, it's our turn," said Joe.

He pulled Danni in closer, towering over her. With his free hand, he brushed the hair out of her face. He stroked her cheek with the outside of his fingers, then tilted her chin up. He leaned in and kissed her tenderly. He kissed her again with just a little more passion. His hand slid to where the back of her head met her neck. He pulled her in tighter as the passion of the kiss increased. Danni matched his passion, kissing him back. Her hands ran along his chest.

Joe broke the kiss. Danni leaned in to try to continue the kiss, but he was too tall. She stared up into his eyes with lust. He returned her stare. Her chest heaved as she caught her breath. She could feel her arousal building. She wished they could go and have sex right now.

George had mixed emotions. He thought Joe kissed like a girl with those tender kisses, typical big city beta. The way Danni kissed him back was different than how she kissed him. He wondered if she was faking it. If he was honest, he was a little jealous, but he was completely confident that Joe wouldn't be able to please Danni the way he could.

"That was sexy, I guess. Good stuff," stated George unconvincingly.

"Well, I guess jealousy isn't a problem," Joe said with a hearty laugh.

"Then let's talk about envy," started Anna. "The other thing that can wreck this is one partner being envious of the other partner because they had a better experience. No matter what rules we put in place, someone is going to have a better time."

"I want the both of you to imagine this scenario. We do this. Now, you end up having a lousy experience. There is no chemistry. Everything is awkward. Maybe the guy can't get hard, and the girl can't get wet. You don't end up getting to cum. Then you go and see your fiance. They are floating on air, completely satisfied. They rave about the wonderful night they had and all the incredible things they did. They didn't know sex could be like that."

"So, is your reaction: how dare they enjoy being with another person while I couldn't? Or is your reaction: I am so happy for you. You finding pleasure brings me so much happiness."

Anna paused. Joe agreed with her, stating, "It's this one-and-done rule. I am fine with keeping it in place, but it suggests you are trying to keep score. You can't keep score in swinging. It can't be a competition or a zero-sum game. It's about maximizing the pleasure for you as a couple, no matter who gets more."

George internally rolled his eyes. "What a bunch of nambie-pambie, pinko bullshit," he thought. He held his tongue because he didn't want to insult Danni's friends. He started to wonder if this was really about Joe. Maybe he had issues getting it up, so they want to lower expectations of something. That wasn't something he needed to worry about. He always took care of business (except when he drank too much, or had a stressful day at the office, or was too tired, or played too much golf, or ...).

"That makes sense to me. I would want George to enjoy himself even if my night doesn't go great. What about you, George?"

"Oh yeah, definitely. Danni's happiness is my priority no matter what happens to me," he stated insincerely.

Danni smiled at him. She loved hearing him say sweet things like that.

Anna and Joe looked at each other. They could practically read each other's minds. It was clear that George didn't have the right attitude, but he is an adult. They had warned him, and it was up to him to decide for himself.

"Ok. I guess we are all in agreement. A toast to tomorrow night. May we all get what we are looking for," Joe said as he raised his glass. The rest of the group raised their glasses and drank.

"Now, if anyone has second thoughts before tomorrow, no big deal. No one's feelings will be hurt. You can back out at any time," stated Anna maternally. "Let's exchange numbers with each other. We can call or text to arrange logistics. Also, feel free to make requests like lingerie or roleplaying or positions or whatever will make this the best experience."

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

George was speeding as he drove home. He couldn't wait to get home and have sex with Danni. Anna had made him so horny. Danni was in the same boat. Her pussy got wet the moment Joe wrapped his arm around her. She could have slid home after spending the evening cuddled up next to his muscular chest.

Danni's phone buzzed. It was a text from Joe.

"Let me know what size bra and panties you wear. Making a trip to lingerie shop tomorrow morning."

That text was quickly followed by another: a picture of his erect cock with the text, "Thinking of you," surrounded by hearts. There wasn't anything in the picture to give a frame of reference to the size of his cock, but she had the sense it was large. It was perfectly straight with a slight upward curve. It was the best-looking specimen she'd seen.

Between the idea of a strange man buying her lingerie and the knowledge that she had given him a massive erection, she was ready to tear George's clothes off. This was a whole new level of horniness. She replied to Joe with the bug-eye emoji and the licking emoji, along with her sizes.

George asked who was texting her. She said it was Joe but lied, saying he was just texting to confirm he had her number. Lying to her fiance turned her on even more.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Joe and Anna snuggled in bed after having sex. They discussed their impressions of Danni and George.

"I have zero issues with Danni. She's in it for the right reasons. She has the proper perspective. She'll have a great time," stated Anna.

"Agreed."

"George, on the other hand, I think he expects Danni to come home complaining that you couldn't please her like only he can. If she says anything else, his heart will break."

"Definitely. I get the vibes he hasn't experienced much variety of sex. He is used to dictating things, and Danni is eager to please. I am debating in my head how he will respond to you when you pounce on him. Will he get intimidated by a sexually aggressive woman and lose his hard-on, or will he cum in his pants?"

"I'll have to ease him into it. Hopefully, he lets me take control until I get my one allotted orgasm. I feel like if he is on top, it'll be two pumps and a dump."

They both laughed. This looked like a situation where Joe was going to have the better time, but that wasn't what swinging was about. Even if George can't perform, the sex she and Joe will have that night as they recount their experiences is the main attraction.

"Now, Joe, you have to promise to play by the rules. I know you think they are silly, but this is someone else's relationship you are playing with. They're planning a wedding, so be a good boy."

"I promise I will follow the rules," Joe said with a smirk.

"Why do I feel like you're planning to pull an 'Air Bud - well technical, there is no rule that says, blah blah blah'?"

"I have no idea what you could mean, but now that you mention it, where could I find a golden retriever at this hour?" Joe replied, laughing. He honestly planned to follow the rules himself, but after spending the night with Danni in his arms, feeling her press her body into his the moment he sat down, hearing her contented moans and that kiss (What a kiss!), he knew she would not be able to control herself. He was going to tease, torture, and please her until she had broken each rule.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

The next day was the big day. Danni and George were both giddy. Danni was especially excited. She was bouncing off the walls. The plan was that the men would stay home, and the girls would go to the other's house at 9:00 PM, but Danni was so eager she started getting ready at 6:00. She showered and shaved every hair below her neck. She was admiring her bald pussy in the mirror. A cheeky idea popped into her head. Intentionally choosing to act before common sense could rear its ugly head, she took a picture. She captioned it, "My little friend can't wait to meet your big friend." She texted it to Joe. She couldn't believe herself.

Joe texted back, "Tell me what you're going to do with that."

This was so dirty. She was shaking as she typed back, "I am going to ride your big penis with it."

"Call it a 'cock'."

She felt dirtier from the language and being ordered around by a man who wasn't her fiance. "I am going to ride your big cock." Before she sent it, she decided she needed to up the stakes. She added, "But first, I want to suck your cock."

She giggled as she hit send. She couldn't believe she was sexting a man while her fiance was 20 feet away in the other room. They hadn't discussed whether texting was allowed, so she decided it better not to mention it to George. What he didn't know wouldn't hurt him. She had no idea how true that was going to be tonight.

Joe responded, "You'll have to wait until after I eat that cute little pussy of yours. I am already drooling for you."

Danni felt herself get flush at that comment. She'd never been with a guy that eager to eat pussy. She imagined how hot Joe would look between her legs with his mouth covered in her pussy juice. Her knees got wobbly just thinking about it.

She noticed in the mirror that her pussy was visibly wet. She considered getting George to fuck her to tide her over for the next few hours, but she didn't want to ruin his night with Anna. She did think of a fun idea for her and George.

She asked George to pick out an outfit for her to wear tonight. George was offended at first, but Danni encouraged him not to take it that way. He begrudgingly picked a tight, bright red mini dress she'd bought by mistake. It looked different in the ad. She wasn't able to return. She only wore it once, but it felt too slutty, so she never wore it again. He thought she'd veto it. George also picked out some lacey underwear, not her sexiest stuff. He didn't want to waste the good lingerie on Joe.

Danni took the items George picked and took them into the bathroom. She knew Joe was buying her lingerie, so she opted not to put on the underwear. She pulled on the dress. Her nipples visibly stuck out through the fabric. The fact that there was only about an inch of material covering up her naked pussy made an already slutty outfit the sluttiest.

"But hey, if ever there was a time to look like a slut, it's when you're going out to sleep with your friend's boyfriend," she thought.

She did worry that George might notice the lack of underwear or how wet she was, but she decided it would be a fun game to try to keep it a secret until she left. When Danni strutted out of the bathroom without any objection to the dress, George regretted his choice. She looked so hot. He debated canceling the whole thing and fucking her right there, but he desperately wanted to fuck Anna.

At 8:45, Danni received a text from Anna saying she was about to leave. At 8:46, Danni was backing out of the driveway. She drove a manual transmission car, so she needed to keep her legs apart. She looked down and noticed that her skirt had ridden up past her pussy which was dripping on her seat. She felt so sexy driving down the road, dressed like a slut with her wet pussy on display. She fantasized about getting pulled over. She made eye contact with a passing trucker who blew his horn. She felt so dirty.

She somehow arrived at Joe and Anna's house at 8:57, even though it was 15 miles away. She hadn't even realized she was driving that fast. She got there so fast she saw Anna leaving the front door. Looks like the two women had different ideas of what "about to leave" meant.

Danni pulled over. The plan was for the couples not to cross paths. They wanted to avoid anyone seeing their significant other with another person. Danni was pretty sure this was just for her and George's benefit, but she respected it.

She watched Anna strut down the driveway towards a waiting Uber. She looked radiant. She was wearing a full face of tastefully done makeup. Danni wished she could do makeup like that. She had such a youthful glow that whenever she did makeup, she looked like a little girl who got into her mom's makeup kit.

Anna wore a black gown. The neckline plunged almost to her belly button. The slit up the side went up to her hip. She wore black stilettos. She wore her wavy brown hair down. She was the picture of glamour. She would have fit in on a Hollywood red carpet. Danni was envious that George got to spend the night with her.

Danni set a timer on her phone for 2 minutes. She didn't want to come barging in the second Anna left. She didn't want to seem too eager even though she was, in fact, too eager. She watched the seconds tick off. She stopped the timer with 9 seconds remaining and walked up the driveway.

She rang the doorbell. Joe opened the door. He was wearing a fitted blue suit with a white shirt. The shirt had three buttons open, revealing some chest hair and a part of a tattoo. He looked like a male model in a perfume ad.

Danni opened her mouth to say "Hi," but no sound came out. She blushed. Joe looked down at his prize. He thanked his stars he was blessed with the opportunity to corrupt this innocent woman. He wrapped an arm around her back and another under her butt. He liked how small she felt in his arms.

He picked her up like she weighed nothing. She squealed with delight like a schoolgirl, wrapping her arms around his neck and kicking her feet back into the air. Joe kissed her. Danni's giddiness was vaporized by the burning lust inside her. It shocked her how fast his kiss ignited her passion.

Joe kicked the door closed. He pressed her against the door as their kiss continued. Danni's heart pounded in her chest, hard enough for both of them to feel it.

Joe broke their kiss and stared into her eyes as he lowered her back to her feet. Danni was hoping he'd just bend her over and plow his hard cock into her. She needed to fuck this man ASAP. Instead, he turned around and casually asked her if she preferred white or red wine.

Her head was spinning. She replied with a stunned, "Yes?"

Joe just chuckled and said, "Rosé, it is."

She tried to follow Joe but almost collapsed on the first step. Her knees were like jelly. She made it as far as the doorway to the kitchen by the time Joe returned with her glass of wine. She leaned against the doorjamb, trying to look cute / not fall to the ground.

Joe put his forearm on the doorjamb above her head and leaned over her. Danni looked up with puppy dog eyes at the man towering over her.

"You look incredibly sexy tonight. Are you sure you want to do this? You can still leave and be a loyal fiance. The woman who walks in the door is rarely the one who walks out it."

Danni was so smitten a bulldozer couldn't have gotten her out. "Pretty sure."

"You're so cute. I can't wait to have you in my bed."

"Why are you waiting?" she asked, almost begging. She had spent all evening studying his dick pic. She was past ready. She was desperate.

"Then it would be over too soon. If we're only allowed to have sex once, we are going to have to get creative to make it last."

Danni hated the one-and-done rule. What a stupid rule. But she was equally aroused to find out what Joe's idea of "creative" was.

"What are we going to do?" Danni asked timidly. He could have said anything. She would have walked over hot coals if his hard dick was on the other side.

"We are going to enjoy our wine; then you're going to try on your gift."

Danni maintained eye contact as she downed her entire glass of wine.

"I guess you're thirsty."

"Very."

She remembered there was an end table next to her, so she reached out her right hand to put down her glass but didn't break eye contact. She then heard the glass break on the ground. The end table was to her left.

Neither of them broke eye contact.

Danni managed to squeak out an "Oops. I should clean that up."

Joe said, "Don't worry about it. You're already going to spend a lot of time on your knees tonight."

She moaned. Her pussy spasmed as she considered the implications. She desperately needed to get fucked, and soon.

Joe downed his glass of wine and successfully set it down on the end table. He scooped her up in his arms and carried her towards the bedroom. It momentarily occurred to her that George would be carrying her like this on their wedding night. Joe leaned down and kissed her, and just like that, George was purged from her mind.

Artemise_Will
Online Now!
Lush Cams
Artemise_Will

Joe tossed Danni onto the middle of the bed. She noticed a set of scarlet red lingerie on the bed.

"Did you pick this out for me?"

"No, Anna did. She always decides what my slu ... um ... my women wear."

She could tell he almost called her a slut. She wished he had gone through with it, which confused her. Her high school boyfriend once called her a whore when they were fooling around, and she slapped him across the face (not in a fun way, either). But for some reason, she craved Joe's abuse.

"Where should I change?"

Joe walked over to a chair in the corner and said, "Right here," pointing at a spot in the middle of the room.

Danni obediently went to the spot. Joe sat down. Danni locked eyes with him. She grabbed the bottom of her dress and pulled it over her head in one swift motion. She threw it in a corner. She spread her legs slightly, feeling the cool air against her wet pussy. She could feel a drop rolling down her thigh. She arched her back and stuck out her chest. She was presenting herself for Joe's consumption.

Joe loved her body. Her tits were perfectly perky. Though smaller than Anna's, they were equally sexy, with light pink areolas about the size of a half-dollar surrounding her erect nipples begging to be sucked. She had visible tan lines from sunning in a bikini. Her pussy looked delicious. He loved how wet she was for him. No lube tonight.

He pointed in the air and twirled his finger around. Danni understood he wanted her to spin around, and she complied. He groaned as he stared at her ass. Even though it wasn't large, it stuck out from her tiny waist and thin legs. Her smooth skin was flawless. The bikini she tanned in must have been pretty modest since almost her whole ass was pale. It was going to look so good with his red handprints on it.

"Panties first," Joe commanded. A shiver went down her spine. She loved being ordered around.

She walked over to the bed naked, except for her high heels. She examined the panties Anna picked out for her. They were almost entirely sheer except for the gusset. The cut is what is known as "cheeky."

She faced away from Joe and bent over at the waist, giving him a show. He drooled at the sight of her pussy lips pouting at the top of her thigh gap. Her tight little asshole looked good enough to fuck. Her ass was begging to be spanked.

She slowly pulled up the panties, looking over her shoulder for Joe's approval. They fit perfectly. The cut cupped each cheek. He smiled approvingly.

She picked up the bra and asked in her Southern accent, "May I, sir?"

"Good girl. You may."

She liked calling him "sir" and loved him calling her "good girl."

The bra was also sheer. It fit like a glove. Danni caught her reflection in the mirror. She looked so sexy. She felt powerful. She looked to Joe, waiting for his next command.

"On your knees."

"Thank you, sir," she purred as she obeyed.

Joe savored this moment: an innocent-looking Southern Belle on her knees, obeying his every command.

"Come to me."

She started to get up when he said, "No. Crawl."

She couldn't help but smile and obey. She felt like such a whore as she slowly crawled on all fours. She held eye contact with him as she slunk across the floor. When she got to where Joe was sitting, she sat up and placed her hands on his knees. She licked her lips as she waited to be commanded.

Joe patted his thigh. Danni crawled into his lap. He grabbed her by the base of her skull and pulled her in for a kiss. Suddenly, Joe grabbed her hair and pulled her head back. He feasted on her neck. She moaned like an animal in heat. He worked his way down to her chest. He bit her nipple through her bra. She squealed.

She panted like a dog as he continued to maul her. She was on fire. Every part of her that he touched burned. George had never made her feel this way. She was no longer Danni: dedicated special ed teacher, good Christian girl, and loyal fiance. She was a being of pure lust that needed to be consumed and fucked.

Joe pulled away from her. "Be a 'good girl' and undress me."

The way he spat out the words "good girl" with such contempt was more degrading than being called slut or whore ever could be. She loved it.

Danni pushed his blazer off his shoulders and pulled it off each arm. She ran her hands down the front of his shirt, feeling his muscles underneath. She started unbuttoning his shirt as fast as she could, but her fingers fumbled the button. Joe took hold of her hands and stared into her eyes calmly. "Slower."

She took a deep breath and slowly exhaled through puckered lips. More deliberately, she started undoing his buttons. Gradually, more and more of his body was revealed, but the waiting was agony. She needed to feel his body pressed against her. She needed to feel his muscle flex as he tossed her around and filled her with his cock. Why did this shirt need so fucking many buttons?!

At last, she undid the last button. She threw his shirt open like a kid opening presents on Christmas morning. She ogled his chiseled torso. He had muscle definition like a model, but unlike a model, he had chest hair. She ran her fingers through it. It felt so manly. He was well tattooed. Danni had never been with a guy with tattoos. It was hot.

"May I please worship you, sir?" she asked like a proper Southern lady.

"You may."

She ran her nails down his body. His muscles were so firm compared to George's soft body. She brushed her face against his chest. His chest hair tickled. She inhaled his musk. She smelled as good as he looked. She licked his nipples. He squirmed a little. She looked into his eyes and gave his nipple a little bite before sucking on it. He groaned contentedly.

She kissed her way down to his abs. As she did, her hands explored the muscles of his neck, chest, and lats. Every inch of him was firm and toned. Her body slid down his lap. She could feel his hard cock against her body. It was torture to be this close to it but not be able to have it inside her.

After paying attention to each of his six-pack abs and iliac furrows, she knelt between his legs with her hand on his belt buckle. She looked up with big, pleading eyes. In a desperate, almost begging tone, she said, "Please!"

He paused for a moment to enjoy her agony. Her chest was heaving as she panted. Her nipples were trying to fight their way through her bra. She quivered with desire for him.

After what felt like ages but was only seconds, he nodded slightly. She tore off his belt faster than he thought possible. She ripped the button off his pants entirely. She grabbed either side of his pants and yanked them apart to force the zipper down. She thanked god when she saw he wasn't wearing underpants. She didn't have time for more layers.

She pulled his pants down to his ankles. His cock sprang free. At last, there it was. The thing she wanted most in the world. The only thing she truly needed. Her purpose and her salvation. It was bigger than George by a wide margin. It was more beautiful than in the picture he sent.

She wrapped one hand around the base and the other just below the head, with plenty of room in between. Her engagement ring sparkled on her finger as she stroked his cock. She rose on her knees and leaned forward to put it in her mouth when she felt Joe grab a handful of her hair and stop her.

"Wait."

She whimpered. She was like a starving man presented with a feast he couldn't eat. She looked at him with a tear running down her cheek. Her agony and desperation were apparent.

"What kind of girl throws herself at another man's cock while her fiance sits at home?"

Joe loved watching her squirm. When he first opened the door tonight and saw how eager she was, he knew he was going to love torturing her. Women are rarely so open in their desires. Most women try to play it cool, so it takes some time to make them beg. Danni had no pretenses. She arrived ready to beg.

Now, he was going to make her break every one of her rules. He would abide by them until she crossed each line. First up, "no degrading name calling."

"Please! I just need to suck your cock!" she begged, and drool ran down her chin.

"What kind of a fiance begs to suck another man's cock?"

It finally clicked in Danni's head what he was doing. Her mouth curled into a lusty smile. Her pussy throbbed. She squeezed his cock.

"A slut. A worthless whore begs to suck cock."

Danni felt so powerful and sexy, calling herself a slut.

"That's not a very nice name to call yourself"

"Fuck you. Call me your cocksucking slut and shove this down my throat."

One rule down, five to go.

"Suck my cock, you cocksucking slut."

Danni dove onto his cock. She took the head into her mouth. She ran her tongue around the rim. She flicked her tongue along the slit. Joe threw his head back and groaned, "Good girl."

Danni's excited squeal was muffled by his cock. She took his cock out of her mouth. She licked from the base to the head and back down. She took his balls in her mouth one at a time. She stroked his cock with both of her hands. A pearl of pre-cum emerged from the tip. Danni licked it off and swallowed it. She suckled the head, trying to get as much pre-cum as she could.

"Play with your pussy, slut."

Danni shoved her hand into her panties. She quickly coated her fingers. She gently ran her finger around her clit. A bolt of lightning exploded through her. She tried to scream, but the cock pushing into her throat stifled them.

Joe wrapped her hair around his hand and took control of her head. Submitting to him, she removed her hand from his cock. Instinctually, she began pinching her own nipple. Her other hand continued playing with her clit. After just a few minutes, she was already hurdling towards an orgasm.

Joe fucked her mouth with a steady pace. The room was filled with the repeated gluck, gluck, gluck of his cock in her throat. He groaned. He looked down at the prize between his legs. Danni was flushed red from head to toe. Tears ran down her cheeks as he fucked her face. Her mute moans were so sexy. She looked amazing in the scarlet lingerie his girlfriend bought for the little adulterer.

The beautiful moment was shattered when Danni's body began to shake. Joe could tell she was cumming hard. He pulled his cock out of her mouth as she screamed. Her body continued to convulse and spasm. She fell forward and rested her head between his thigh and cock.

"FUCK! OH GOD! OH GOD!" she screamed before going limp.

She thought about how different this was from sex with George. She never orgasmed from sucking cock. Her thought was interrupted by Joe pulling her up into his lap by her throat. He wrapped his arms around her and kissed her. George would never kiss her immediately after having his cock in her mouth.

He picked her up and carried her to the bed. He tossed her into the middle. He grabbed her thighs and pulled her so her pussy was at the edge of the bed. He knelt next to the bed and breathed her in.

"I am going to make this mine. I'll ruin you for him."

"Please! Yes!"

He licked her slowly from back to front. She pulled her labia apart so he would have full access to her clit. He chuckled at her desperation. He kissed her clit and then sucked on it. He circled his tongue around it. He flicked it with his tongue. Danni was moaning with delight.

He replaced his tongue with his thumb. He gently rubbed her clit as he pushed his tongue into her pussy. Danni was thrashing around. In four minutes, Joe had shown more variety in his oral skills than George had in four years. He reached up and roughly squeezed her breast. He rubbed the nipple between his calloused thumb and forefinger.

Joe returned his mouth to her clit and built a steady tempo. He could tell from Danni's body and moans she was getting close. He slowly slid two fingers into her pussy and gently massaged.

"Oh fuck! Oh fuck! Oh fuck!" she panted.

"Have you ever been eaten like this?"

"Never! You're so good."

"Has anyone made you feel this good?" Joe was worried he was being too obvious that he was going to make her break another rule.

"No one eats pussy as good as you!"

"Not even..."

"You eat pussy so much better than George. Oh fuck! He never makes me cum for real. I have to ... OH FUCK! OH FUCK!"

Two rules broken, four to go.

Danni's screams became unintelligible. Joe put all his focus back on her body with renewed passion after making her break another rule.

"OH GOD! I AM CUMMING!"

Her hips bucked uncontrollably into his face. Her pussy spasmed on his fingers. She grabbed him by the hair and pulled his mouth off her clit. It was too much. All she could do was lie on the bed, moaning and trying to catch her breath.

Joe stood up. His cock stuck out in front of him, lewdly dripping with pre-cum. He stood between her legs, his cock resting on top of her from her crotch, almost to her belly button. His balls nestled against her pussy. He looked down and wondered if he was going to be able to fit his cock in the petite girl. He let her catch her breath before he made her break the next rule.

"You taste so good. I'd pay to eat your pussy."

"Deal," she laughed. "That was the best head I have ever received."

"Uh oh, that sounds like a comparison."

"I would never have agreed to that rule if I knew how much better you'd be than George. Fuck."

She looked down at his cock resting on top of her. "You are so much bigger than George. I think you might split me in half."

"I'll go slow. You're not the first tight cunt that I needed to stretch out before I fucked her."

"Oh fuck, Joe. Fuck me better than George. Make me your slut!"

"Won't we need one of those?" He pointed at some condoms that Anna had left on the nightstand. Danni looked at the condoms and then down at the big cock leaking cum on her belly, back to the condoms and back to the cock. This was a lot more serious than name-calling and comparisons.

She looked up at Joe and, with determination and certainty, said, "No."

Joe stood still and put his hands behind his back. "I won't break the rules. You'll have to."

Danni grabbed his cock. It felt hard and heavy in her hand, completely different from George's. She ran it up and down her labia mixing his pre-cum with her pussy juice to lube up his head. She wrapped her legs around his waist and pulled him until his head popped in. They groaned in unison.

Three rules broken, three to go.

She pulled him in as far as she could. She felt her pussy stretched to the max. She was more full than ever before. She looked down and saw she had only taken half his length.

"Fuck! I am so full. I can't take anymore."

Joe smirked. "Yes, you can."

Joe took her legs from around his waist and relocated them so her feet were by his shoulders. He held her by her calves as he slowly pulled back and then thrust forward. Danni felt like all the air went out of her body. She could only stare open mouth up at Joe, and he pushed more and more cock into her. As he stretched her pussy, it felt like he was rearranging her organs. It was painful in the best way.

Joe kept up this assault until he finally felt their bodies collide. He held there and let her body adjust.

"God, I am so full. Fuck!" Danni moaned.

"You like that feeling?"

"I love that feeling. I love your cock, and I love how your fill and stretch my pussy more than George ever could."

Four rules broken, two to go.

Joe smirked. He barely even tried to get her to break the L-word rule. He was eager to break the last two since they'd be the most fun.

Joe slowly started to pound her pussy, increasing his tempo as her body adjusted to his cock. Danni arched her back. He reached down and unhooked her bra. Her perky tits looked amazing, defying gravity and jiggling with each thrust. Her perfect pink nipples begged for attention.

Danni whimpered with each thrust. She was lost in a haze of lust. Nothing in her life had prepared her to handle this much pleasure.

"Tell me how much you love this."

"I fucking love being your slut. Your cock is so much better than my fiance's. I love your cock."

Just then, Anna let out a laugh. She wasn't surprised that Joe got Danni to break some of the rules, but she was surprised at his efficiency and brazenness.

Anna's night so far had been moderately enjoyable. She didn't trust George to please her if he was in charge. She also knew he wouldn't take orders from a woman, so she cloaked her commands as requests to serve him (can I please sixty-nine you, Daddy? Can I please ride your cock for you, Daddy? Etc.). Once she had given herself an orgasm from riding him while playing with her clit, she let him get on top for his two pumps. She asked about a shower, hoping they could play some more, but he was falling asleep. He was out cold by the time she was out of the shower. She hurried home, hoping she could still join in with Joe and Danni.

She walked up next to Joe and looked at the picture of pure pleasure that was Danni.

"Hey baby, how was your night?" asked Joe.

"Pretty good, actually, and getting better."

She kissed Joe passionately. Then she bent over and sucked on Danni's nipple. Danni looked up and shrieked. She hadn't noticed Anna come in.

"Sorry, Danni. Didn't mean to startle you, but your tits were begging for my attention. Don't worry about George, he had his fun and is sleeping soundly. We actually followed all the rules, unlike some people."

Anna lifted the untouched condoms off the nightstand.

"I am so sorry, Anna. It's all my fault."

Anna laughed. "Don't worry. I'm not mad. And I am sure it isn't all your fault." She gave Joe an accusatory glance.

"I haven't broken a single rule, at least without being made to," Joe stated honestly.

Joe returned to pounding Danni's pussy. Anna climbed on top of Danni and kissed her passionately while filling her hands with Danni's breasts. Danni entered the gates of heaven. Joe by himself was a new height of sexual pleasure. Joe and Anna together transcended that level and several more.

As Danni started to feel an orgasm build inside her, she stopped kissing Anna back. Anna dismounted her. She turned her attention back to Danni's perky tits, sucking on her nipples. Her hand slid between Danni's legs, and she caressed her clit. This was like putting Danni's orgasm on steroids. It felt like it would tear her in half. She gripped the sheet so tight her knuckles went white. She screamed like an animal under attack.

Joe could feel her pussy tighten on his cock like it was trying to pull his cum out. He groaned.

"Fuck! I am going to cum soon. I guess I need to pull out," he teased, slowing his tempo.

"No!" Anna and Danni yelled in unison.

"But the rules," he teased again, slowing almost to a stop.

"Fuck the rules. Make me your cum slut. Fill me more than George. I love your cum!"

Joe smirked and returned to his tempo. Danni screamed like a banshee and shuddered uncontrollably. Her pussy spasmed on his cock, and started milking it.

"Fuck! I am cumming!" he yelled, slamming as deep into her as he could.

Joe unleashed a powerful blast of cum deep into Danni, escalating her already powerful orgasm to epic heights. Anna rose from Danni's body and kissed Joe as he finished emptying his load into her friend.

Five rules broken, one to go.

When Joe released his last drops of cum, he pulled out and staggered back into the chair. Anna kissed Danni tenderly and helped her scoot into the middle of the bed. She moved between her legs and kissed her friend's well-used cunt. Danni squealed with surprise before moaning as Anna started licking her pussy. Anna decided to correct their transgression and eat Joe cum out of Danni's pussy.

Anna knew Danni would be sensitive after the fucking she received, so she licked and kissed as gently as she could. Danni moaned. She couldn't believe how Anna got her turned back on so soon after orgasming. She also couldn't believe how much she was enjoying being with a woman. She looked down at Anna, and she was so hot between her legs, still wearing her gown.

Joe noticed his cock re-hardening at the sight of his girlfriend eating his cum out of her friend's pussy. He got out of the chair and got behind his girlfriend. He pulled up her skirt and discovered she wasn't wearing the panties she left the house in. He slid his cock into her. It was rock-hard after a few pumps. The sensation of Joe's cock growing and hardening in her pussy made Anna moan. She rotated her hips around his cock.

The room was alive with the sounds of sex: Anna lapping and sucking at Danni's wet, cum-filled pussy, Danni's moaning, the slap of Joe's body against Anna's as he plowed into her, the bedsprings squeaking and the bedframe creaking.

"Oh fuck, Anna! I love how you eat my pussy. So much better than George!"

Danni grasped the sheet and threw her head back, screaming as she got close to cumming yet again. Anna loved making Danni go wild. She loved making straight girls cum. It was the ultimate conquest. She was also happy Danni was almost done. She could feel her own orgasm growing and wanted to dedicate her attention to it. She loved it when Joe would repossessed her pussy after fucking another guy.

Danni screamed, "I'M CUMMING!!!" As she did, she squirted powerfully for the first time in her life. She didn't know what her body was doing, but she loved experiencing it.

"Holy fuck, Anna. Even I wasn't able to make her squirt. You're so fucking incredible. I love you," professed Joe.

"I love you, too. Now take my pussy back. George made it cum, but I need a real man to own it."

Anna remained in the ass-up, face-down position, her favorite position of submission. She fucked Joe back aggressively since she was done with Danni. Joe grunted like an animal as he lost control. Anna loved how he went wild on nights she fucked another guy.

Danni was enthralled by their performance. Joe fucked like a man possessed. His eyes glazed over as if his soul and humanity left his body. He was a beast. Anna was sexier than any pornstar. Still in her dress and heels, her makeup and hair were nearly flawless. Danni could tell she was consumed by pleasure the way her eyes rolled back and moaned.

Danni came around the side of the fucking couple. She reached her hand inside Anna's dress and caressed her breast. They were so different than her own, much softer and larger. She pinched Anna's large nipples. She reached her other hand to Anna's clit. She wanted to return the favor Anna had done for her earlier.

Anna screamed into the mattress, "I FUCKING LOVE BOTH OF YOU!"

Suddenly, she arched her back, and her eyes bulged. She moaned as her body quivered. Her eyes lost focus, and her moans turned to whimpers. Her pussy clamped onto Joe's cock like a vice, and she collapsed on the bed.

Joe affectionately rubbed her ass and back while keeping his cock inside her. He knew she basically went catatonic after a big orgasm. He exchanged triumphant glances with Danni. She was so proud to have contributed to Anna's huge orgasm.

Then, a light bulb went off in Danni's mind.

"Did you cum yet?" she asked Joe.

"Not yet," he groaned.

"One more rule to break."

Danni hopped out of bed and pulled down Joe's face to kiss him. It was hot kissing a guy who still had his dick in someone else.

"Get on your back. You've done enough work. This slut needs to earn her next load of cum," ordered Danni.

Joe was exhausted and more than happy to lie down. He felt bad giving what would likely be his last load of cum tonight to Danni instead of Anna, but rules are rules.

Danni knelt with her knees on either side of Joe. She reached back to guide his cock into her. She realized the angle didn't work with his large cock. She got up on her feet and squatted down. They groaned in unison as his cock head popped inside her. Emotions and pussy juice flowed through her as she got re-accustomed to his superior cock. It slid in so easily since it was already coated in Anna's juices.

Six rules broken, none to go.

She bounced on his cock. It was an amazing sight to see. Joe marveled that his cock fit inside such a petite girl. Anna, emerging from her coma, turned over and thought the same thing. She kissed Joe as her little friend bounced on his cock.

Danni's skinny thighs burned as she rode his thick cock. Seeing both Anna and Joe watch her ride cock thrilled her and renewed her strength.

Anna repositioned herself so she was kneeling next to Danni. She reached down and massaged Joe's balls, making him moan and expediating his coming orgasm. Her other hand massaged Danni's breast. She looked Danni right in the eyes as she rode her boyfriend.

"You look like such a hot slut riding cock, Danni."

"I love riding your boyfriend's cock. It is so much bigger than George's."

"I know, baby."

"Oh God, it's so hot that you fucked my fiance and me tonight."

Danni's body started to tremble. Her legs were losing strength, and her orgasm was building. Anna could tell Joe was close, too.

"Joe, you already came in her. Now you need to cum on her. Cum on both of us."

Danni moaned at the idea of further breaking the rules and wearing Joe's cum sent her over the edge. She fell off his cock, and waves of pleasure crashed over her.

When it became obvious Danni didn't have the strength to kneel in front of Joe as he came on her, Anna positioned her with her head hanging off the edge of the bed. Anna quickly lay next to her in the same position. Joe hopped out of bed and stood in front of them just as he shot his load. He took turns blasting each of them, at first on their chests, then their chins, and finally the rest of their faces. He shoved his cock in Anna's mouth so she could suck off Danni's juices. Joe collapsed in the chair. He pulled out a bottle of Gatorade he had stashed there earlier.

With their heads hanging off the bed, the cum ran down from their chins and faces into their mouths and hair. Anna turned and gave Danni a sloppy cum covered kiss. Joe watched the girls swap his cum.

Once they had cleaned the cum off their faces, they talked about how much fun tonight was.

"Just the three of us need to get together again soon," suggested Joe, earning him a dirty look from Anna. She didn't like him interfering in other people's relationships.

"Definitely, but with working and all the wedding planning, I don't know when I will have a free night," said Danni.

"Well, you're not planning on staying with him the night before the wedding, are you? Tradition and all," offered Joe.

"Joseph! Behave yourself!" Anna chastised.

Danni bit her lip and smiled at that dirty idea. Was she slutty enough to cheat the night before her wedding?

Published 
Written by SmutPeddler100
Loved the story?
Show your appreciation by tipping the author!

Get Free access to these great features

  • Create your own custom Profile
  • Share your erotic stories with the community
  • Curate your own reading list and follow authors
  • Enter exclusive competitions
  • Chat with like minded people
  • Tip your favourite authors

Comments