Join the best erotica focused adult social network now
Login

Truth or Dare?

"Sophie saw sides of people she’d never seen before."

93
13 Comments 13
8.3k Views 8.3k
3.2k words 3.2k words

Author's Notes

"I hope you enjoy my story, make sure to like and leave a comment and/or some feedback ❤️"

It was Friday morning in a sunny suburban neighbourhood when two 17-year-old step-siblings, Julian and Sophie, decided to throw a pool party while their parents were away at a doctor's conference in San Francisco. Excitement buzzed in the air as they planned every detail for that same night.  They invited their friends, set up colourful decorations, and stocked up on snacks and drinks. Their parents had no shortage of alcohol but they needed to accommodate the younger crowd.

The sun shone brightly, making the pool glisten invitingly. They had their parent's permission to throw the party, but any damage was coming out of their allowance. When 6 pm rolled around,  friends started arriving, laughter filled the air, and after a few minutes of mingling everyone jumped into the cool water, splashing and playing games. Julian and Sophie took turns hosting contests, from cannonballs to water races, and the atmosphere was filled with camaraderie.

As the sun began to set, they gathered everyone for a barbecue by the pool. The warm glow of fairy lights added a magical touch to the evening. Sitting together, they shared stories of their first kisses and enjoyed the delicious food.

The sun cast a warm golden hue over the backyard but the energy shifted as Sophie suggested, "How about we play a game of Truth or Dare?"

The group cheered in agreement, and they formed a circle on the grass, the pool shimmering behind them. Julian started the game, confidently pointing to his friend Alex. "Truth or dare?" he asked, a mischievous grin on his face. Alex pondered for a moment before declaring, "Dare!"

Julian thought for a second with a playful glint in his eye and then said, "I dare you to kiss Sophie!"

The group looked at him in disbelief, Alex chuckled but accepted the challenge, he stood up and made his way over to Sophie. Internally she was so glad for this moment. She had always wanted Alex, Julian of course was aware of this fact. He, in part, planned this party to provide them an opportunity. Alex was a classic American cutie. Wavy brown hair, 6 ft 2, brown eyes, gorgeous physique and to top it off, he was an all-round sweet guy.

The air was thick with excitement and a hint of nervousness. Sophie felt her heart race, a mix of surprise and thrill washing over her. Alex was now in front of her. The air between them became electric.

Alex leaned in, his eyes locking onto hers, and for a brief second, time seemed to stand still. The world around them blurred, and all that mattered was the connection they shared. As their lips met, it was like a spark igniting; a rush of warmth and exhilaration coursed through them both.

The kiss was soft yet charged, filled with playful energy. Their friends erupted into cheers and playful teasing, but in that instant, it felt like they were the only two people in the world. When they finally pulled away, both Alex and Sophie wore wide smiles, their cheeks flushed with a mix of embarrassment and excitement. Alex returned to his spot.

With the energy still buzzing from Alex's kiss with Sophie, the game continued to ramp up. Alex turned to Sam, a mischievous grin spreading across his face. "Truth or dare?" he asked, clearly plotting something fun.

Sam, feeling bold, replied, "Dare!"

The group leaned in, eager to see what Alex would come up with next. Alex's smile widened as he said, "I dare you to kiss Sophie!"

There was a moment of shocked silence, followed by a chorus of laughter and playful shouts encouraging Sam. Sophie blushed, caught off guard, embarrassed by the unexpected twist, she was sure Alex felt something. Sam, armed with only his confidence, stepped forward, his heart racing as he approached Sophie.

As he leaned in, the atmosphere around them crackled with excitement. Sophie, however, looked downcast, stunned by the development. Sam gently pressed his lips against hers, he felt electric and filled with the thrill of the dare. It was playful and light, laced with laughter and the adrenaline of the game.

When they pulled apart, the group erupted into cheers, teasing both Sophie and Sam.

Sam, still riding the high of his dare, turned to Julian with a cheeky grin. "Alright, Julian, your turn! I dare you to kiss your step-sister Sophie!"

The group erupted in laughter, and Sophie’s eyes widened, a mix of disgust and intrigue as to whether he’d do it.

Julian, always up for a challenge, raised an eyebrow and smirked. "Alright, challenge accepted! We’re not related after all, are we, Sophie?"

He stepped forward, the playful tension in the air thickening as everyone watched intently.

Sophie caught between sexual excitement from her last 2 kisses and disgusted by the idea of Julian kissing her, couldn't help but laugh in nervousness. Julian leaned in, grabbed her neck from behind and laced his fingers through her hair, their lips met in a dark, aggressive kiss. It was surprisingly rough considering they’d been close since their parents married.

When they pulled apart, the group burst into cheers once again. Sophie stared at the 3 boys, shaking her head, while Julian grinned, clearly enjoying the moment.

“That’s it. Party over,” said Sophie. “Everyone get out, it’s not fucking funny.”

The girls left first, expressing their sympathies but also happy for her for finally getting a kiss from Alex. The guys left a few minutes later, after having a chat with Julian, she was unfortunately just out of earshot so couldn’t hear what they were saying.

Julian cleaned up outside while Sophie cleaned up the kitchen. She was fuming with her brother. She wanted to kill him. How could he kiss her like that In front of their friends? It was disgusting! How did she even let him do that? She felt ashamed of her actions.

Julian came inside with a bag full of rubbish. He placed his phone on the kitchen island, face down. Audio Recording on.

“What the fuck was that Julian?” she exclaimed, her voice rising slightly. “You can’t kiss me like that in front of everyone!” She had no idea she was being recorded.

Julian, still grinning from the thought of her lips, shrugged nonchalantly. “It was just a dare, Sophie. Chill out!”

But Sophie wasn’t having it. In a swift motion, she raised her hand and gave him a sharp slap across the cheek. The sound echoed in the room, instantly silencing him. “Seriously? That was so disrespectful!” she shot back, her eyes blazing with frustration.

“How dare you slap me,” he said, his tone shifted to anger. At that moment he grabbed her arms, pushing her back into the kitchen island.

“How dare you lay a hand on me after you got what you wanted? Do you think I knew what they were going to do? You should be slapping Sam and Alex too!”

Sophie was shocked and humiliated, never having seen this side of Julian. “Get the fuck off of me!” she shouted.

She was interrupted by the sound of the doorbell. “I’ll get it then I suppose,” said Sophie, rubbing her back where she had hit the kitchen worktop.

She made her way over to the front door. She could see two men through the frosted glass.

She opened the door slowly, and to her surprise, it was Alex and Sam. She tried to close the door not wanting to see them. Alex put his foot in the way quickly. “We just wanted to apologise, we feel really bad. Please let us in.” Alex said sincerely.

She rolled her eyes and opened the door, they made their way back into the kitchen together. Julian had seemed to calm down, his phone was still on the tabletop, recording every word.

“Julian texted saying how upset you were, we couldn’t leave like that. We’ll be going to college when the summer is over, we don’t all want to leave on a sour note, do we? Can you forgive us?” Alex begged. Sam was just standing there looking sorry.

“Fine, I’ll forgive you,” she replied.

Sophie couldn’t stay mad at him for long, he had those beautiful big brown puppy dog eyes. She also couldn’t get their kiss out of her mind. She wanted more.

“Hey, want to go upstairs?” she suggested, her voice low and inviting.

Alex raised an eyebrow, intrigued. “Are you sure? What about Sam and Julian?”

Sophie shrugged, a mischievous grin spreading across her face. “I’m sure they can find a way to keep themselves entertained, right boys?” She said, looking at them both. “I’d rather be with you right now.”

Alex stealthily reached back and grabbed Julian’s phone from the worktop, slipping it into his pocket. Sophie took his hand and led him towards the staircase. Once they reached the top, Sophie glanced back and winked at Alex, opening the door to her bedroom. The atmosphere shifted instantly, filled with a mix of excitement and tension.

“Now that we’re alone…” she whispered, stepping closer to him. Their eyes locked, and the air crackled with chemistry. Sophie leaned in, her heart pounding, as Alex wrapped his arms around her waist. The moment felt electric, and she knew they were about to share something special. Alex picked her up and lowered her onto her bed. He slipped the phone out of his pocket and placed it on the nightstand.

AshleyQueen
Online Now!
Lush Cams
AshleyQueen

“Do you by any chance… have a blindfold? I like a little spice in the bedroom,” he asked in a low and husky voice.

“Uh, I have my sleeping eye mask? Will that do?” she replied as she took it out of her nightstand.

“That’s perfect,” Alex took it out of her hand and pulled it over her hair, placing it on her closed eyes.

“Can you see anything?”

“No,”

“Fantastic,” he growled.

Sophie reached up, her fingers gently brushing against his cheek, feeling the warmth of his skin.

She leaned in, her lips finding him in a tentative kiss that quickly deepened. Sophie wrapped her arms around his neck, pulling him closer as their bodies pressed together. She loved feeling his weight on top of her.

As they kissed, her hands began to explore, running through his hair and down his back, feeling the muscles beneath his shirt. Alex responded, his hands sliding around her waist, holding her tightly as if he never wanted to let go. For Sophie, the world outside disappeared, and all that mattered was the warmth of their connection. For Alex, he was well aware of his surroundings. The door was wide open and Julian and Sam were sneaking up the stairs in silence. Alex continued kissing Sophie, hands on her firm C-cup breasts.

“I’m just going to pull you to the edge of the bed baby, It’s my favourite position,” he said breathlessly.

“Whatever you want,” she replied with a grin.

Alex grabbed her legs and slowly pulled her to the end of her bed, stripping her out of her shorts and panties. She was excited, visibly dripping wet. Leaking down on her inner thighs.

Julian and Sam were now in the room, naked from the waist down.

“I’m going to have you gagged on my underwear, can you do that for me, baby?”

“Whatever you want to do,” she giggled, wiggling her little hips in anticipation. He removed his shorts and boxers, stuffing his boxers into a ball and shoving it in between her waiting lips. She moaned in excitement.

“Stretch your hands above your head, grab your bed railings for me,”

She did as she was told.

Alex’s body was pumping with blood and adrenaline, excited by the sight of her laid out in front of him, following his instructions without question. He leaned forward and kissed her stomach, in a way saying sorry for what was about to happen. He slipped the tip of his hard cock into her aching pussy. Julian tied Sophie’s hands to the bed railing. Sophie’s forehead wrinkled in confusion.

Alex ploughed into her with his hard shaft, not giving her a chance to think. Julian and Sam held her legs in place. She was so ready to be fucked. So eager, thinking she was going to be fucked by the boy of her dreams.

Alex kept going, in and out, in and out, slapping against her thighs. At least, she thought it was Alex. Her eyes filled with tears as she bit down on the boxers harder. She could hear his moans, and recognising his voice gave her the tiniest bit of comfort. His moans were growing louder and more strained until he collapsed on her body, warm and sweaty, releasing spurts of his hot cum into her pussy. She heard him sigh and pull out of her slowly, they were probably watching as his cum soaked cock exited her hole. She tried to pull her legs together, but Julian and Sam still held her.

“Get ready for round two, gorgeous,”

Sophie recognised the voice as Sam. Her lips were dry but her cunt unfortunately was sopping wet, full of cum. Easily able to accommodate another man.

“You shouldn’t have slapped your brother, Sophie, that’s not very sisterly,” he said before ramming his cock into her wet cunt.

His balls slapped against her as he moved. He was having the time of his life, feeling her tight walls constrict around his rock-hard dick. “Take this pounding, you know you like it. I can feel you enjoying it.”

He was so enjoying fucking her tight pussy, so much so that he tightened his hands around her thighs while he rammed into her, he kept going like this for a few minutes, fingertips digging deeper into her thighs. She would never admit that she enjoyed the feeling, dancing on the line between pleasure and pain. Once he was ready he released his thick stream of cum into her used hole. The floor at the foot of her bed was soaked with the mixed sperm of Sam and Alex. It was slowly dripping out of her.

Finally, it was Julian's turn. He’d been wanting this for a while. They were close as step-siblings, yes, but he’d always found her attractive. She had beautiful long brown hair, green eyes, C-cup perky breasts, long legs, and shapely curves… all at only 17! How could he be expected to live in the same house as her without having a taste? Sophie had never really thought about him like that since they first met. Sure, he was also a cute guy, but he was going to be her brother.

Alex and Sam held her legs in place.

“Sophie, Sophie, soph… Why did you have to make me angry? Hmm? We could have stayed good friends, innocent siblings, but you tried to destroy our relationship. Alex knew you wanted him. Sam’s kiss was just a joke. My kiss, we could have left it at that, if you didn’t slap me.”

Julian climbed on top of her body. He took the boxers out of her mouth. She was so tired, she couldn’t get a word out. He kissed her lightly, slipping his tongue between her lips. She kissed him back, knowing this wouldn’t be over until he was pleased.

“Fuck me, Julian, please,” She whispered. Julian melted hearing her say those words.

She knew there was no getting out of this now. She had to allow herself to be used, for him to finish. He kissed his way down her neck, and slid his hands up her T-shirt, against her naked breasts. He positioned his huge cock over her used pussy. Instead of pushing into her, he dragged her into his hard throbbing cock. He fucked her and fucked her until she was close to orgasm. He had slid her T-shirt up over her breasts, he enjoyed watching them bounce up and down as she rocked. Occasionally sucking and biting her nipples between strokes when he slowed down. Her moans were filling the room. Alex and Sam enjoyed listening to her.

“Fuck Julian, you’re so big! You’re filling me right up!” she screamed as he was hitting her cervix slowly and steadily.

“Let go of her legs boys, Sophie, wrap your legs around me, baby.”

She did as she was told.

His thrusts began getting harder and harder, slamming into her body. He was growling with each thrust, moaning as he pulled out.

“I’m going to come all over this tight pussy, be ready to clench your cunt around me. You have to keep my cum inside of you, no spilling out like you did the others.”

Again, she did as she was told.

He unloaded his balls into her exhausted body, a wave of euphoria overtaking them. A few drops of cum escaped her cunt, pooling on the floor with the others.

“You’ve been a good girl, servicing us. I’m going to release you.”

Her legs had gone slack over the edge of her bed, she didn’t have any energy left after the ordeal.

Julian climbed over her body. He was straddling her now, he kissed her slowly. She responded to him, slowly sliding her tongue against his, tasting him. She moaned into his lips. She needed some comfort.

“Boys, we’re done here, fuck off out of here.” He barked.

Both Alex and Sam grabbed their clothes and bolted, closing the door behind them. Julian untied Sophie’s hands and removed the mask from her eyes and kissed them, tasting her salty tears. He pulled her up onto her pillow and slid the covers onto her warm body. He took off his T-shirt and slid into the bed next to her. They both looked up at the ceiling. Her bed will never feel the same again.

“You’re mine Sophie, aren’t you? I loved what you did for me. You’re such a good girl. I’ll take good care of you. My good girl… my pretty sister. You’re divine,” he kissed her cheek softly. “Can you be a good girl and spread your legs for me?”

She did as she was told.

He slid his index finger against her wet cunt. Scooping up some of their cum into his finger.

“Open wide,” he commanded.

She did as she was told. She sucked his finger clean.

“Such a good girl,” he said, over and over, feeding her his cum.

“Let’s sleep,” he whispered after a few minutes.

He picked up his phone from the bedside and turned it away from her view, stopping...

To continue reading this story you must be a member.

Join Now
Published 
Written by Ddysilentgirl
Loved the story?
Show your appreciation by tipping the author!

Get Free access to these great features

  • Create your own custom Profile
  • Share your erotic stories with the community
  • Curate your own reading list and follow authors
  • Enter exclusive competitions
  • Chat with like minded people
  • Tip your favourite authors

Comments