On the Sunday before Labor Day, I stood at my living room window and stared out at the line of cars parked in front of Myles's house. I'd wanted to avoid being one of the first guests at the party, forced to make small talk with Dana while she waited for others to arrive. But it looked like I couldn't put off going any longer.
Though Myles had insisted I didn't need to bring anything, I knew better than to show up emptyhanded. Now, I retrieved a plate of homemade brownies from the kitchen, then gave my outfit a final once-over. I'd chosen a fairly modest summer dress; it was teal, with an empire waist and flowing skirt. The V-neckline revealed a little more skin than I preferred, but it wasn't as if I had much cleavage to show off. On my feet were comfortable espadrilles.
Outside, the afternoon was sunny and pleasant. A mild breeze held just a hint of coolness, a reminder that the fall season was right around the corner. I strolled across the street, hoping the smile I'd fixed on my face hid my anxiety. This is a bad idea, I told myself. Still, my steps didn't falter. After all, I'd promised Myles I would make an appearance.
Standing on their front porch, I rang the bell. It was Dana who answered the door, and when our eyes met, I sensed her smile was just as phony as mine. "Colleen! So glad you could come." Myles's wife looked as stunning as always. Her dark curls were swept back from her face, and she wore a cute red mini dress with a white collar. Her open-toe white heels added a little bit of height to her frame.
"Thanks for inviting me." I slipped into an immaculate living room with a bay window. Offering the plate to her, I added, "Hope you like brownies."
"Oh, these look delicious." Her stare swept over my outfit. "Love that dress," she said. "It's very... quaint."
My face burned at the backhanded compliment. As I followed her into the kitchen, I wondered how soon I could make my exit without appearing rude.
"Everyone else is outside," Dana said, glancing at the back door. She set the brownies on the counter and then went to open the refrigerator. I started to tell her I'd head out to join the others, but before I had a chance, the door opened.
Myles stepped into the kitchen, carrying an empty plate. "Hal's commandeered the grill," he said to Dana, "and he's ready for—" He abruptly stopped talking the moment he saw me. My eyes widened slightly at his reaction, but he quickly recovered, flashing a welcoming smile. "Colleen, it's great to see you!"
"You, too," I said quietly. Dana was still inspecting the contents of the fridge. With her back to us, she seemed oblivious to our interaction. I seized the opportunity to give Myles an appreciative look, and I knew he was doing the exact same to me. His stare made it clear he didn't find my dress at all quaint. He was wearing a brown and tan striped knit sport shirt, and its V-neck collar revealed a little of his chest hair. How many times had I run my fingers through that hair? I found myself wondering. His Lee jeans fit him perfectly.
"Can I get you a drink?" he asked me. Then, to Dana: "Why doesn't she have a drink?"
His wife turned around and shot him a glare. "She just got here, Myles." Her voice had an edge that made me nervous as hell.
"I'm fine, really," I rushed to say. "I don't need a drink. I'm just going to head outside." Though I was quick to leave the kitchen, I couldn't resist taking a deep breath as I passed Myles. I longed to catch a trace of his scent.
The backyard was full of people, most of them strangers to me. They talked and laughed while milling around numerous folding tables. Before I could find a quiet corner in which to retreat, Myles joined me in the yard. I kept my eyes averted even as he handed me a bottle of my favorite soda and said, "Let me introduce you to everyone."
We made the rounds, and I was unceasingly friendly in greeting Myles's friends and coworkers. For a surreal moment, I felt like his wife. Daring a glance at him, I saw that he appeared unfazed by Dana's foul mood. He kept a hand at my back while steering me from one guest to another, and though his palm never rested directly against my dress, I imagined I could feel the warmth of his skin.
I was relieved when we finally reached Mr. Gibson, my elderly neighbor. He sat in a chair, his arms crossed as he surveyed the goings-on around him. "No introductions required here," Myles said. "Now, if you two will excuse me, I need to make sure Hal doesn't have too much on that grill at once."
I waited for Myles to slip through the crowd, then sat down next to Mr. Gibson. "I'm so glad to see you here," I told him with a smile. "I don't know most of these people."
Instead of returning my smile, Mr. Gibson gave me a sidelong glance. His demeanor unnerved me, for he'd always been kind in the past. I remembered how thrilled he was upon learning that I planned to move back into my parents' old house.
"I'm surprised you'd show your face here," he said in a low voice, his mouth barely moving.
Those words made my scalp prickle in alarm. "What do you mean?"
Finally, he looked directly at me. "I've seen that man sneaking into your room at night. You're carrying on like a couple of horny teenagers."
"Mr. Gibson—" My voice failed me altogether, and I pressed a hand against my face, as though I'd been slapped. I berated myself for being so stupid. All this time, I'd thought our affair was a secret, but my neighbor had certainly noticed.
Leaning closer, Mr. Gibson's expression grew stern. "Your parents raised you better, Colleen. They'd be mighty disappointed to find out what you're doing under their roof."
It felt like my stomach lurched upward to my chest before plummeting back down again. I realized it was only a matter of time until Mr. Gibson told my parents what he knew. My cheeks burned with shame, and I had to blink back tears. You deserve this, I told myself. Did you really think you could sleep with a married man and face no consequences?
Practically jumping to my feet, I fled from my neighbor's scorn. On my way back to the house, I noticed that Dana had now joined Myles outside, and guests were sitting down at the tables to eat. I needed just a few minutes alone to compose myself. Then, I could get through this meal without breaking down crying.
Entering the kitchen, I found the house mercifully quiet. In the living room, I gripped the back of a chair in an effort to steady myself. My breaths were coming far too fast, and I could feel the flood of panic threatening to inundate me. Not only would I have to admit to my parents what I'd done, but I would also have to stop seeing Myles. A sound dangerously close to a sob escaped my lips.
At that moment, a man stepped into the living room, stopping short when he noticed my distress. "Hey, Colleen, are you okay?"
I hurriedly wiped at my face, though no tears had yet fallen. "I'm fine..." I searched my memory, trying to recall the man's name, for he was one of Dana's numerous coworkers whom I'd met a little earlier. Gerald, that was it. "I'm fine, Gerald. I just got a little too warm outside." The lie was inane, but it was the best I could come up with.
Gerald slowly approached me. "Do you need a drink? Maybe you should sit down for a minute." We were practically strangers, yet his tone was uncomfortably familiar.
"I'm fine," I repeated with a weak smile. He was quite tall, and he now stood so near that I had to tilt my head back to meet his stare. My eyes widened when he leaned even closer.
"Did Myles do something to upset you?" As he spoke, his gaze dropped to my breasts.
"Of course not!" I took a step back, folding my arms over my chest.
Gerald's grin turned sly. "Don't play innocent; it's obvious you two are... involved."
"You're crazy!" I tried to step past him, but he quickly moved to block my way. As a nervous sweat broke out on my skin, I feared I might be sick. Suddenly, I felt lightheaded. I was in no shape to fend off this creep, and he knew it.
"The way he hovered around you outside..." Gerald made a regretful sound. "So disrespectful to Dana. Of course, the wife is always the last to know, isn't she? I don't think she suspects anything. Yet."
"Get out of my way," I growled. I'd begun to feel cornered, like a trapped animal. My urge to lash out was intensifying by the second. Again, I tried to move around Gerald, and again, he stopped me.
His blue eyes darkened with his own anger. "Hey, don't be like that." Springing forward, he grabbed my wrist. I gasped when his fingers painfully dug into my skin. "I'm just being friendly, offering to keep your secret. If..." He pulled me toward him, and I had no choice but to obey. I worried his grip would continue tightening until I heard the snap of bones. "If you go upstairs with me. Just for a few minutes."
Hot rage conquered my fear. No longer concerned for my physical safety, I began struggling to break free of Gerald's hold. He merely laughed at my desperate flailing. Out of the corner of my eye, I saw a figure appear in the doorway, and I looked to him for help.
"Get the fuck away from her!" Myles was so quick in advancing upon us that I barely registered his movements. Though Gerald immediately released me, Myles still shoved him so hard that he fell to the floor.
"Relax, man, we were just talking!" Gerald sputtered.
When Myles again lunged, I grabbed his arm. "Myles, no!"
At that point, I still believed we might be able to control the damage. Gerald could run to Dana and tell her whatever he wanted, but she'd believe her husband instead. And Myles and I would quietly end our relationship and return to being mere neighbors. I'd apologize to my parents and make amends with Mr. Gibson. Life would continue as it had before those late-night phone calls began. Except now, I would carry a secret grief at having lost the man I'd grown to love.
In my mind, I saw it all unfolding, that sad and safe future awaiting me. But the road leading to it was obliterated when Myles turned to me and pressed a hand against my cheek. "Are you okay? Did he hurt you?"
I didn't have a chance to answer, or even to withdraw from his touch, for it was then that Dana stepped into the living room. Her shock at seeing Gerald climbing to his feet morphed into raw pain at the sight of her husband regarding me so tenderly.
"What the hell is going on?" she demanded, her voice quaking with barely contained emotion.
"I'm sorry," I whispered, both to her and Myles. Then, I turned on my heel and strode out of their house.
*****
I cried until my eyes were nearly swollen shut. Tucked away in my bedroom, I allowed the grief to swallow me. Through the open window, I heard the sound of car doors slamming across the street as guests left Myles's house that evening. I had no idea how he and Dana managed to pretend everything was okay, even if only for a few more hours. I was an absolute wreck, sick with despair and dread.
Lying in my bed was acutely painful, for I was reminded of all the nights Myles had lain next to me. The heartache felt almost unbearable. My dress was in a crumpled pile on the floor, and I now wore only my nightshirt. Despite the cool air drifting into the room, I remained hot from my nearly constant weeping. In the darkness, I curled up on my side and listened to the last guests depart. The silence that followed did nothing to soothe me.
I could only imagine the conversation taking place between Myles and Dana at that moment. Was he begging for her to forgive him? Maybe he would promise not only to be faithful but also to give her the family she so wanted.
For hours, I tormented myself with these thoughts. How could I go on living across the street from Myles, unable to so much as glance his way? I'd be forced to pretend that these past weeks had never happened.
The alarm clock revealed that it was now half past eleven, but of course, Myles didn't appear at my bedroom window.
Instead, he walked right up to my front door and rang the bell.
Upon hearing the sound, I bolted upright in bed. As late as it was, I could only imagine that Dana had decided confronting me couldn't wait till morning. I wasn't about to have a screaming match on my front porch, but I got up to see if it was indeed her waiting for me outside. Making my way through the darkness, I strode to the living room window. On that moonless night, it was too dark for me to discern who had rung the bell.