There was stuff going on with Cait's mom and dad, but we didn't know about it because we were never there anymore really, and when we were we almost always made sure it was when they weren't home because we kinda had our own life now. A different one separate from them.
And anyway, they didn't tell us about it. I found out later that mom knew, of course, but they had asked her not to tell us anything because maybe, just maybe, it would be alright.
And now I'm glad they didn't tell us because Cait would have been a very different girl if they had.
Because she loved everything about the thing the four of us had and the things we did. So much so that every now and then I even felt just a little bit jealous. Cait was the one who got us into some of the crazier stuff too, like with toys and ropes and whips and stuff, and when we had Lucy's boyfriend tied up in bed and the three of us could do whatever we wanted with him, sometimes she acted like he was hers.
But Lucy didn't mind. She was just happy that we had fallen in love with him too, and she loved watching us with him.
And when she was the one being tied up, whether her boyfriend was there or not, she came hard over and over again. She loved that so much, and she had us tie her up in all kinds of positions, and she told us that was one of her first fantasies, that she was imprisoned in a tower in a castle or something, and maybe the king kept her as a sex slave, or maybe when the prince came to save her he did other things to her instead, or sometimes it was the evil stepmom of course.
And seeing Lucy tied up and gagged and helpless always made me so unbelievably horny.
And Cait couldn't get enough of that either.
Cait couldn't get enough of Lucy.
Or of her boyfriend, and whatever fantasies Cait may have had, with her mom and dad in mind I guess, she made it real with him.
Like that time she brought her strap-on with her, the one she had found in her mom's closet that time, and Lucy said "Ooh, use it on me first."
But Cait said, "No, I'm using it on Toby."
And Lucy gasped with her hands on her cheeks, and said, "Ohh. Yes. Please!"
When he came home, he took a shower and then he joined us in the bedroom, and by then we had Lucy tied up on the bed and Cait and I took his hands and led him to her. He got on top of her and started to fuck her, and Cait put the strap-on on and climbed into bed with them. Standing on her knees beside them she grabbed Lucy by her hair and lifted her head up to it, and Lucy sucked it. Then after a while Cait pulled it out of Lucy's mouth and she grabbed his hair and put the tip of the dildo to his lips, and he hesitated for just a second but then he opened his mouth and Cait shoved it down his throat.
He sucked on it, and I had just been watching them, but now I lay down on Lucy's other side and I kissed her, and then Cait pulled it out of his mouth, and as he was kissing me and Lucy Cait got behind him, and that's when he got it.
He turned to her and said, "He-ey," but Lucy lifted her head to him and kissed him again.
"Please," she whispered, and so he pulled his cock out of her and stood on all fours over her and let Cait do it, and she put so much lube on it and on his ass.
I had to sit up and see, and she put it in him and pushed slowly, and he said, "Hnngh…" and it didn't look like he liked it much, but his cock got even harder if possible.
Cait fucked him like that, first ever so slowly and carefully, like you almost couldn't see her move it in and out, but then faster and harder as he relaxed more, and I lay back down and kissed him and Lucy, and I played with Lucy's pussy and with his cock, and Cait grabbed a hold of his shoulders, squatting over his ass and she was so totally into it, and she was going, "Ah!" with every thrust she made.
"Ah! Ah! Ah!" with her eyes closed, and then after a while she opened her eyes and looked down at the dildo going in and out of his ass, and she bit her lip and hissed, "Fuck, I'm coming!"