Join the best erotica focused adult social network now
Login

My Gym Bro Used Me As His Fuck Toy

"Not as straight as he seemed"

33
5 Comments 5
7.8k Views 7.8k
2.9k words 2.9k words

When I first started working at the gym, I stood out right away, in a good way. People commented on how hard I worked. James once told me that members would stop him and comment on how great of a worker I was multiple times a day. James also told me that he liked when I was there because he never had to worry about what the club looked like (minus the ladies' locker room, of course).

A few months into the job, I was pretty comfortable with how things were going. I started working out regularly and with intensity, and my body showed the results.

I would come into the club, and people - co-workers and members alike - would come to talk to me. It really made me feel welcomed. For the first time since the good times with Tommy, I felt like I had a place where I belonged.

There were gorgeous men (and women) everywhere! Besides the belonging, the eye candy was the best part about the gym.

I remembered one day when I had gone upstairs during the midday lull to do some deep cleaning in cardio. I put each machine on its highest incline so that I could raise them up and clean underneath the machines.

As I was doing my work, this guy I had seen, always at this time of day, named Spencer, walked up to me.

His body was INSANE!

At any given time, Spencer could walk into the room and easily be the biggest guy in there. I had seen him from a distance, but we never really talked more than 'hi'. He had tattoos everywhere, even on his face and hands. I had seen him with his shirt off a couple of times, and when I tell you he had such a defined set of abs. Like forget a 6-pack; he had a 12-pack. His chest and abs were also covered in thick, coarse, dark fur.

He also had a girlfriend... rather a series of girlfriends... Every month, there was a new girl. Every girl was beautiful, fitness model status, you know, sculpted and thicc.

I had the treadmill lifted off the ground, and I was mopping underneath it as he approached me.

"Hey dude," he said to me.

"Hey man!" I replied.

"I just wanna say thank you for always being on top of everything. The gym was always super clean when you were here."

I was surprised by not only him verbalizing his appreciation but also his friendliness. He had a very unfriendly, untouchable disposition at a glance, but talking to him, he had humility that was intoxicating.

He smiled and reached out his hand. "I'm Spencer," he said.

I told him my name as I shook his hand. "Nice to meet you."

After that, Spencer and I would talk a bit more than just 'hi' or 'sup'. Once when I was working out, he approached me and gave me some pointers on my form, which revolutionized my workout. When he left, he said, "Anytime you need advice or anything, let me know."

I loved the way he dressed too. Jordans, joggers, cut sleeveless shirts, or hoodies. Ball cap or beanie. His looks were always on point.

He would even introduce me to his girlfriends from time to time. He was just such a cool guy. Maybe like a year or two older than me, but with so much lived experience, he felt much more mature.

Needless to say, I had a big crush on him. But alas, he was straight, so I knew that I could look, but I dared not show interest outside the bro-verse.

Spencer left my gym. I was super bummed about it. But he said it was getting too expensive, and there were many other cheaper places to work out.

Months went by, and I didn't see him. I had put him out of my mind. I also was moving up at the club a bit. I had started to work the desk and was a safety monitor of sorts.

One day I was coming down the hallway, and saw a beautiful girl approaching me. Big tits, long flowing dark hair, she dressed in the Victoria's Secret Pink label (this was back when that brand was huge at the gym). She had a trim waist and very thicc... assets.

Her beauty was eclipsed, however, by a large shadowy deity looming up behind her.

I staggered in surprise.

"Spencer!?" I gasped to myself. They were down the hall, so I'm sure he couldn't have heard me.

But he saw me.

He stretched his arms as if to give me a long-distance air hug, "Bro!"

We met in the middle of the hallway. I told him it was good to see him again and asked if he had re-joined. He said he had not, but his girl had a guest pass. I was again a bit disappointed but still so happy to see him.

He suggested that we work out some time and gave me his number. I played it cool, but was shook with excitement. He made me feel things I didn't know I could feel again.

Spencer made me feel hope.

At this point in my life, I had just gotten used to the city. I knew what I could afford, where to shop. I had a job that gave me a sense of regularity. And while I didn't think it would happen... I could be alone in my room at night, thinking about Tommy (my best friend... not a story that I've published here, but it's detailed on the podcast), and not cry.

And the truth is... It wasn't just him, but the fact that I had new friends. New scenery and people that would enter my dreams at night. Suddenly my high school life just didn't seem relevant to who I was anymore. I was shedding a skin. And it all happened without me willing it, or even noticing it.



Spencer texted the next morning on my day off.

Sup

Nothing dude wyd

Chillin, wanna work out ... I'm thinking legs?

I was excited and nervous. While I was in good shape for once in my life, I knew I couldn't keep up with Spencer. My fat kid spidey-senses were tingling but I wasn't about to pass up the opportunity to be with him. 

I met him upstairs in cardio, pretty close to where we first met. I hopped on the adjacent treadmill and began to warm up with him. 

To my surprise, I could keep up with his workouts. I have very strong legs and back, probably from all the time spent on Tommy's farm ...and re-racking the free weight room. 

One of our last stations is the squat rack. This is a workout that I don't do on my own. It makes me nervous. 

He loads some plates on, and as the workout progresses, he has me spot him because he's going until failure. Which means that as he squats, I stand behind him and squat with him. 

When it was my turn, he kept pushing me, "One more bro you got this." On my last set, my legs are pretty much jelly and I start to tremble. 

"Oh fuck!" I exclaimed just as I tried to come back up.  I looked at him in the mirror standing funny with a nervous look on his face. 

"You got it?" He asked. Clearly I don't got it. 

"Help me!" I managed to say. Finally, he sprung into action, standing behind me and lifting the bar. 

On my way back up, my ass grazed his crotch, and I felt something warm and very hard. I set the bar back in position and looked back. Spencer was beet red and his hand covered his bulge. When our eyes met he had a look of panic on his face. I collapsed against the side of the rack not trying not to fall out completely, then finally lay down on the hard rubber floor. 

I didn't say anything. I just lay on the ground not sure that I wouldn't need a wheelchair to get out of here.

"Great save," I managed to say. He didn't acknowledge my sarcasm. He wouldn't even look at me, even though I was practically lying at his feet. 

Despite all of this a smile has grown on my face.  He's standing there, with his hands clasped together, very nonchalantly covering his hard-on. 

I reached up, "Give me a hand will ya?" 

He looks down at me with an 'oh, give me a break' expression. 

I laugh. The situation was hilarious to me, and very flattering. I laid on my back and rotated my hips to show my ass. "It's better than pre-workout." I said, giving it a playful slap. 

JessicaPolle
Online Now!
Lush Cams
JessicaPolle

Finally, he broke and started to laugh too. I lifted myself off the ground, my legs still wobbly but I managed.  It's an awkward moment for the both of us. The Spencer I knew had a sort of dark vibe, kinda scary, until you get to know him...he is really a sweet dude and very humble. Even still,  I had never seen Spencer less than confident. His embarrassment only made him more attractive to me.  

I got up after spending some time catching my breath. "You good yet?" I said. He gave a little nod. 

I was a couple of steps in front of him as we walked out of the weight room, when I felt a light smack on my ass.

?!

I almost didn't know what to say..."That's all you got?" I looked him up and down "I thought you worked out." 

You should have seen the squirrely look that came across his face when I said that. His eyes widened, his mouth opened slightly, but also there was a smile in there too. 

He was getting off on the tease. He was into it! He was into me! All this time? 

I was hoping I would get some sort of acknowledgement of his feelings when we got back to the parking lot. But all I got was a, "great workout...Later man." 

Later that night my phone lit up with a single-word text.

Hey

Whats up dude

nm...wyd

chillin wby 

same...you sore?

I wanted things to go further so I replied,

...not yet:)

There was a long break in the conversation...

Come over

I couldn't believe this was happening! He texted me his address, and after another quick shower, I was parked slightly down the street from his house. Per his request. He lived at home with family, and was trying to be as discreet as possible. When he finally emerged out of the dark, he climbed into my vehicle and was very quiet. He looked gorgeous in his skin-tight muscle shirt. I noted that he was even wearing cologne. He was fidgety and nervous, and seemed to be fighting with a voice in his head.

"I'm not gay," he said finally.

"Cool, I was really hoping we could just talk about girls." 

He laughed and shook his head. "Asshole." 

We talked a bit and I asked him how long he was into me. 

"Into you? ...I'm not into you. You have a fat ass and nice dick sucking lips, that's all." I felt like I should have been offended by his objectification of me, but I wasn't. I had wanted him for so long, that I forgot to bring my good sense with me. I was so hungry to taste his body, so hungry to have those powerful arms that I had studied for years wrapped around me, that I was willing to compromise.

"Okay...so when did you notice my ass," I asked.

He laughed, "like the first time I met you. It's fat. I always wanted to fuck that ass." He was strangely impersonal. The Spencer I knew was kind. Quiet. Yet always a sweetheart.  

This was my first experience but not my last with a 'straight' guy not willing to accept his homosexual desires. Often times straight men will try and detach themselves from their homosexual desires by objectifying the person, and the act. "A hole's a hole," all that. I didn't fully understand it at the moment.

"Can I kiss you?" I asked. He seemed to chew the question over, but then he just shrugged and leaned in to me. His kiss was unrelenting. It was okay but there was no real passion behind it. It was all performance. His tongue snaked around my mouth. I felt nothing. It was as if he learned how to kiss from watching porn.

I caressed his shoulders. I forgot how extremely muscled he was. Okay I know this sounds weird, but it was like his muscles responded to my touch. There was a tingle that came from them, almost a vibration when I touched them. It was like they were teeming with life. I wanted to really feel them, so I reached under his shirt and caressed his chest. His whole torso was covered in fur. My fingers combed through till I found his built chest and rubbed all over it. It was like an electric current flowed from him, into me. I searched for his nipples and found that they were pierced. When I flicked them, he growled and bit down on my neck. 

He was a monster. 

I loved it.

I saw the bulge in his pants and went for it. He helped me remove his pants, and his dick, which was about 6.5 inches long, with average girth, sprang forth. A more experienced me would have taken my time. I would have teased him. But we both had years of wanting each other, and I was impatient. 

I started sucking him ferociously. He palmed my head with his hands and roughly fucked my face until my jaw was sore. He reached down while my face was in this lap, and gripped and fingered my ass. He was so rough. But I could take it.

I was surprised when he asked me to pull mine out. I got up and leaned back, reclining my seat so I could. I was already fully hard, and when the full length of my shaft came out he gasped.

"Fuck dude!" He wasted no time reaching out and grabbing it. "Fucking huge!" His mouth watered and his eyes glittered. He just stroked it for a while without saying anything. Then he flipped his hat backward and plunged down on it.

Honestly, I don't think the head was bad. I just don't remember it being great. What I do remember is what happened next, after he slobbered all over it. 

"Fuck me," he said. Our eyes met. He had a pleading gaze that was unsettling to me. I could see some deep shame in his eyes. But I knew the hunger had overruled his sense. He may not be fully comfortable with being seen this way, but the hunger will make you do things that may seem like the deepest of self-betrayals.

I wanted to protest as he climbed on top of me, but I was in shock. This was a plot twist I did not see coming. I keep lotion in my glove box and fingered some into him. 

It happened slowly. He slid down a few inches, his face twisted in pain. Then back up.

"Maybe we shou-" I started to say, but he clamped his hand down over my mouth. 

For the next hour, he rode my cock, barely switching positions. As if I weren't even there. He just used me as a fuck toy. 

His eyes rolled back and he started speaking in Spanish...I didn't even know he spoke Spanish. I would later find out it was his first language. 

He beat himself off furiously. After about twenty minutes of solid fapping, he sprayed his nut all over my ceiling, back seat, dashboard and me. I felt his hole pulsing and started to cum myself. He slid down as far as he could go, just past halfway as I pumped my milk into him. 

He kept my cock in him until I slid out from not being hard anymore. I felt panicky. I just fucked him raw! What the fuck was wrong with me?! I would later go in for an STD panel, and was so relieved when my results came back negative.

We fucked several times more, with condoms. But the gentle, humble Spencer was gone. Whenever he would speak to me it was all about sex. Not even about me, just my appendage or my ass. And yes... I let him fuck me as well. 

You know, I really liked Spencer as a friend. But once things became sexual he was unwilling to be that anymore. I had asked him out on a date many times. I told him how much I cared about him, yet it was like talking to a brick wall. Only one time did ever acknowledge what I was saying.

you know we would  have been so good together 

I know              

*************************************

Thank you for reading

Mr. Brooks

Published 
Written by MrBrooksConfesses
Loved the story?
Show your appreciation by tipping the author!

Get Free access to these great features

  • Create your own custom Profile
  • Share your erotic stories with the community
  • Curate your own reading list and follow authors
  • Enter exclusive competitions
  • Chat with like minded people
  • Tip your favourite authors

Comments