Join the best erotica focused adult social network now
Login

That One Time In College

"A night that started rather innocently and ended much sluttier than I would have imagined."

84
19 Comments 19
25.5k Views 25.5k
3.5k words 3.5k words

Author's Notes

"Its been a while since I posted. Thanks for you patience. I enjoyed reliving some of the moments I wrote about in this story. <p> [ADVERT] </p> I hope you enjoy too."

The college category piques my interest here. It takes me back to a time when I was curious and increasingly adventurous. I'm fond of those days and grateful for them. On one particular night, I was more adventurous than I thought I could be, and I thought you might like to read about it.

It was a random Wednesday night during my sophomore year. I had a boyfriend that I was getting serious with, but I was also into my own thing. I pretty much only got to see him on the weekends, so I pretty much did as I pleased during the week.

That night I grabbed some pizza with some friends then headed over to a somewhat low-key house party for some beers. Mike was there with a few of his friends, and I chatted with them for a bit. Mike was several inches taller than me, skinny, and rumored to have a big dick. I have no idea how that rumor started, nor did I know if it was true. That being said, I couldn't help but wonder what he may be packing down there.

As the night went on, we were all having fun and feeling good from the alcohol. My curiosity began to grow about the potential size of Mike's penis. I don't consider myself to be a size queen, but the handful of cocks that I had enjoyed at that point in my life varied in size considerably. My boyfriend's dick was the biggest I had had, and I was curious as to how he might compare to Mike.

Eventually, they started to run out of beer at the party, and most of us weren't old enough to buy more. Luckily, I had a case of beer back at my apartment and thought it might be fun to invite Mike over. My roommate was out with her boyfriend and planning to stay at his place that night, so I'd have the place to myself. Mike was a nice guy and didn't have a girlfriend. Perhaps he'd be game for a no-strings bj and that would satisfy my curiosity. Nah, that wouldn't be a good idea, would it?

I pondered that for a bit as people were finishing up their last beers and making their exit. Most people weren't trying to hang out too late anyway, given that it was a school night. Perhaps I should just go home and get some sleep.

Mike and his friends made their way past me on their way out. “Hey, I have a few beers at my place if you're game to hang out a little longer,” I just kinda blurted out.

“Really? I'm totally game for a few more beers!” exclaimed a voice from behind Mike. It was Mike's friend, Anthony. He was totally drunk but obviously game for more beer. It wasn't what I originally had in mind, but I ended up bringing Mike, Anthony, and their friend, Jared, to my apartment. There go my plans of seducing Mike. Oh well. It was probably for the best. Besides, they all knew I was dating Johnny, so they'd probably think I was a slut if I started flirting with Mike. I figured I'd have a few beers with them and could still call it an early night.

We cracked open some beers at my place and started playing card games. It was innocent at first, but then we started playing a card game where you got to make a rule if a certain card came up. Usually, the rules involved having to drink more or doing something silly. Of course, Anthony had to take it to a different level. He made a rule that the next person to draw a spade had to take their shirt off.

“Whoa, c'mon, Anthony! I'm the only girl here. That's not a fair rule,” I objected.

“Hey, rules are rules,” he retorted.

“No, no, no. You're just trying to get me topless.” Which I'm sure was true. I must admit, I had pretty awesome boobs at the time (much better than I have now). I was a full C cup and filled out my bra quite nicely. I did well sans bra, too, as they were quite perky. I wasn't afraid to show them off, but the stakes weren't right.

“If you're going to make a rule that I would have to take my shirt off, I have no interest in seeing any of you shirtless in return. How about you make a rule that you guys would have to take your pants off? Unless, of course, you're afraid that I might see your dick.”

“Oh, I'm not afraid. I'll whip it out right now,” ...and he proceeded to do just that. Did I mention that he was drunk? He literally unzipped his pants and started waving his dick around.

“Hey! No one wants to see that! Put it away!” exclaimed Jared.

Mike just kind of quietly sat there shaking his head before calmly remarking, “Good job, Anthony. Now you're going to ruin the game.”

“What?” Antony shrugged as he zipped back up. “I was just trying to be funny. Besides, you surely can't be shy about showing off big Mike. I'm sure Claire would want to see that. C'mon, Claire! Show us your boobs. And then we'll all take our pants off. Trust me. You'll want to see what Mike is hiding in his pants.”

I looked to Mike, who was basically blushing. “Real classy, Anthony,” was his response as he took a sip of his beer and shot a look of disapproval at him.

There was an awkward pause among all of us before I spoke. “Fine. I'll play along. It's just a little fun among friends, right? I'll tell you what. Why don't you guys take your pants off and line up along that wall? You're right that I'd love a good look at what you're packing down there. If you can be gentlemen about it, I'll take my bra off.” I stood up and took my shirt off to show them I was serious. I wore bras that were well padded in those days, and it didn't show any hint of nipple. They were speechless for a moment, and they eyed me up like a piece of meat. I was both comfortable and confident standing there without a shirt on. I thought I was hot shit back in those days. I'd love to have those perky boobs of my youth back!

After looking me over, Anthony eagerly stood up to head to the wall. “Not so fast,” I corrected. "Leave your pants and underwear here at the table before lining up along the wall." My boobs had them hypnotized as they calmly complied with my demand. I sipped on my beer as I watched all three of them take their pants off and head over to the wall. I was feeling more confident and naughty in the situation, and I probably could have made them do anything I wanted just to see my boobs. I told them to line up by penis size and I would be over to inspect.

“Well, I guess it's Jared, then me, then Mike,” Anthony announced. Jared and Mike stood there kind of bashfully as Anthony stood there, seemingly proud, with his dick hanging out. I must say, Mike clearly had the biggest dick of the bunch, but I tried not to make a big deal of it. I walked past and gave them all a look. I must admit, it was thrilling to see them lined up with their dicks out like that. Three distinct shapes and sizes, all of which I'd surely enjoy...

“Very well,” I remarked as I turned around with my back to them, undid my bra, and let it drop to the floor. I covered my tits with my hands before I turned around.

“Oh come on. Let's see them,” Mike pleaded playfully. With a smile, I dropped my hands and grabbed my beer. The guys went wild and made a lot of comments about my boobs as they grabbed their beers too. This excited me and I made comments about their dicks getting harder. I have no doubt that my nipples were nice and pointy too. Before long, I was grabbing their balls and cocks as they groped my boobs. It was thrilling to watch their cocks grow before my eyes and to have three hard cocks to play with as they were more or less fighting for position for my attention.

Another round of beers, and all three of them were naked and I was down to my thong. They were groping my butt too, but I was reluctant to let them touch my pussy, which was surely soaked. I had a hard cock in each hand and bent forward to take Anthony's cock in my mouth. Hands were all over my tits and butt. I lost track of whose hands were whose and began to lose myself in the moment. I was starting to ache for them to touch my pussy, but I continued to resist any touching down there. I gave Jared a turn with my mouth, then Mike. My god, his cock was huge! Might be the biggest I've ever played with. I couldn't believe this was really happening, and at this point, I tried not to care about any repercussions. Even if we stopped at this point, they've already formed opinions about how slutty I may be.

I knew from experience that I crossed a point where I was going to have to get these three guys off. I suppose it would be rude not to, given the situation. I kinda wanted to get off too, and I started to think about the box of condoms that was on the fridge. I was pretty sure that there weren't enough for all three of them. There were only two left if my math was right, and I didn't know if Mike would have fit anyway. I continued to suck on Mike while I jerked the other two. Anthony squeezed my tit hard as he ejaculated without warning. There was warm cum all over my hand and the floor, probably got some in my hair too. The smell of that cum drove me wild!

I took Mike's dick out of my mouth to look at Anthony. He had an unsure look on his face, then I looked at Jared while I still had his hard cock in my hand.

“It's a shame. I was just about to tell Anthony about the box of condoms on the fridge. Want to get one?” As Jared made his way over to the fridge, I pressed my tits against Mike and invited him to touch my pussy. I also asked Jared to grab another beer from the fridge.

TiaraGrande
Online Now!
Lush Cams
TiaraGrande

I put Mike's hand on my crotch and it felt great! I let out an embarrassingly loud moan as I enjoyed his touch. Admittedly, I really wanted to fuck Mike more, but I was nervous about his size.

“I want your big dick inside of me, Mike, but I think Jared needs to loosen me up first, if that's OK.” There were no complaints. Mike slipped his finger behind my panties and fingered my pussy a bit.

“Seems like you're ready,” he declared before pulling my panties down. It felt liberating to finally be naked, and I thought about trying to fuck Mike right then and there.

However, Jared was clearly ready to go, and he fucked me on the table with the condom on while Mike waited patiently. The condom was nice and full when he was done. I offered to remove it for him, and I also took a little taste of the contents before throwing it out.

Mike's turn was next. He was starting to get bashful about getting seconds. I grabbed him by the dick and assured him that the warm-up session was a good idea. Jared chimed in with comments about how tight my pussy was. I laid Mike down on the floor and slowly lowered myself onto him.

Despite being warmed up from sex with Jared, Mike's dick still felt huge. I couldn't believe I was struggling to fit him as I was sure I was wet enough. I was beginning to wonder if I was really up for this challenge with my little princess pussy. I whispered in his ear how great his big dick felt as I slowly fucked him. I swear that made his dick even bigger and it was kinda getting painful... but it was still super thrilling.

I looked around the room for a moment, and Anthony was pretty much hard again. He was slowly playing with his cock as he watched us. Jared was sipping his beer, mildly paying attention. I was starting to fit more and more of Mike's dick, but it was still kinda painful.

Mike was thrusting upwards a bit, trying to get deeper, but it simply got too uncomfortable. I didn't know if I should be embarrassed, but I apologized and announced that my pussy needed a break. I went down on Mike and still couldn't get over his size. As I was sucking his dick, I was wondering how much of his dick I had taken in my pussy and how much more was left. I could taste my juices on him and wondered if I was truly wet enough. I certainly had a tingly feeling down there and was hopefully getting wetter with the thrill of that huge dick in my mouth, knowing I was being watched. Before long, I could feel hands groping my tits and ass again. I was hoping they wouldn't touch my pussy as I truly did want a break.

“Oh my god, this feels great,” I could hear Mike's voice as he had to be close to cumming. I fondled his balls as I continued to suck him off. I could sense him starting to tense up just before he ejaculated in my mouth, letting out a moan as his cock pulsated. My mouth was almost immediately overwhelmed. I swallowed as much as I could, but he was still cumming when I took his dick out of my mouth. I gripped the base of his pulsating cock as I more or less watched him finish ejaculating onto the floor. Although I'm pretty sure I took a squirt to the face too. The smell of cum was intoxicating and thrilling.

I looked at Mike and smiled as Anthony was fondling my tit and making crude comments about Mike's monster cock and monster load.

“I need a sip of beer,” I announced as I made my way to the fridge. I got beers for everyone, and there was a bit of an awkward moment as we somewhat reflected on what we had just done. Mike was about to get a towel to clean up the mess on the living room floor, but I insisted that we all needed some beer first.

We had a nice calm moment sipping beer naked as Anthony cracked a few crude jokes about needing to hang out like this more often. The cheap light beer was ice cold and felt extra refreshing for some reason. As I enjoyed my beer, I couldn't help but look over their cocks again. Jared was fully soft at this point and back to regular size. I reflected to myself on how much smaller he was than Mike. Anthony more or less had another boner, and I'm pretty sure he was going to try to go again. Mike was getting soft but that thing still looked huge.

I was about to suggest calling it a night when the door unexpectedly opened. It was Monica, my roommate! Yikes! She wasn't supposed to be home tonight. Well, this was awkward.

Anthony jumped behind the chair to cover up, and Jared put a pillow over his crotch. Mike was awkwardly frozen for a moment as Monica eyed up his meat.

“Monica! I thought you weren't coming home tonight.” I was trying to search for words as my eye caught the cards on the table. “You obviously missed a bit of a game of cards. I'm sure this looks worse than it really is.”

Monica's face turned red, and I couldn't tell if she was mad or embarrassed. She looked like she wanted to run out the door as I approached her. In hindsight, her naked roommate approaching when the room probably smelled like cum was probably startling for her, to say the least. “Please stay. We were just about to put our clothes back on.”

After a bit of a pause, she shook her head and said, “I don't know what y'all have been up to, but I will have a beer. It's been one of those kinda nights.” Monica looked like she may have been drinking too and likely had an unpleasant experience with her boyfriend that made her want to come home. We all put our clothes on as Monica went to her room and slipped into PJ pants and a tank top.

“I don't really want to talk about my night, but I do want to hear about yours,” Monica suggested as she sat on the couch. Of course, Anthony was the first to chime in; he talked about the party from earlier and the card game that followed. I was relieved that there was no mention of the sex we just had. The room surely still smelled like cum despite my cleanup efforts while Monica was getting changed. Anthony started going on about how great I looked naked and asked Monica if she got to see me naked often. Monica giggled, then pointed out that she got a good look at Mike's dick and was impressed at how big it looked. A few more jokes followed as we made light of the awkward situation Monica walked into but no talk of the sex. I felt relieved as you never know what is going to come out of Anthony's mouth, and I was somewhat embarrassed to discuss it with Monica at that moment.

Monica was drinking the beers rather quickly, presumably to either catch up to us or to forget about whatever went down with her boyfriend. At some point, Mike got up to pee.

“I have to pee too,” Monica declared shortly thereafter.

While they were gone, Anthony asked if I thought he had a shot with Monica. He clarified that he'd rather have a shot with me the way Jared and Mike did. I teased him a little bit while waiting for Mike and Monica to return. They did not. It was evident she took him to her room.

The sexual banter continued, and Anthony asked if my pussy had recovered from Mike yet. I retorted that it hadn't recovered from Jared yet and that I needed to see if he recovered from me. I sat next to Jared and started to feel his crotch. Then I looked him in the eye and told him I'd take good care of him as I unbuttoned his pants. I was hoping this would drive Anthony wild. It seemed to do the trick.

Before long, I was sucking Jared's dick while Anthony was groping me. I hadn't bothered to put any underwear back on, and he had pretty easy access to my fun parts. Jared pulled my shirt off and was fondling my tits as Anthony had his hand in my crotch.

“Is this pussy ready yet, Claire?”

I gave a thumbs-up as my mouth was rather full. Anthony pulled my pants down and started fucking me from behind. He seemed to slide right in and it felt great. I fantasized about Mike taking me from behind like that.

It didn't take Anthony very long to get to orgasm. He pulled out and shot it all over my butt. I had abandoned any thoughts of condoms at this point. It was just an extra measure anyway, as I was on birth control.

After Anthony finished, I straddled Jared on the couch and fucked him until he came in my pussy. I had a nice little orgasm too. I was exhausted at this point and feeling sluttier than ever. I sent the boys home and went to brush my teeth before bed. Lord knows I needed it after what had been in my mouth! Best to use some extra mouthwash too. As I was gargling, Monica came in to pee. She was completely naked and clearly drunk, judging by how chatty she got and how she was slurring her words a bit. She kinda blurted out that her hooha was a little sore. I was sure I'd feel sore, too, once the alcohol wore off.

Then it dawned on me... She definitely fucked Mike! Impressive. She confirmed this to be the case and told me she had just sent him home. I was eager to share some details with her and to hear about her experience with Mike. We both went to her bed to chat. However, we were both very drunk and very tired and fell asleep almost immediately. The details would have to wait until the morning...

Published 
Written by Claire_D
Loved the story?
Show your appreciation by tipping the author!

Get Free access to these great features

  • Create your own custom Profile
  • Share your erotic stories with the community
  • Curate your own reading list and follow authors
  • Enter exclusive competitions
  • Chat with like minded people
  • Tip your favourite authors

Comments