I'd agree with your assessment, Oli.
The other traits listed may play a hand in initial interest but won't hold me if love, care, and sincerity are lacking.
There are all kinds of beauty, and even physical beauty is such a subjective call, it's hard to pin down. Basically, I know it when I see it. I'm not impressed by wealth, fame, or status. Even reputation can be misleading. None of that factors in.
I judge physical beauty with my own personal biases. And I'm very picky. I know that much.
But there's beauty of the spirit... gentle souls who care about others, who care about justice and fairness, who help others in need. And who are full of life. Without that kind of beauty, physical beauty doesn't really matter much.
I found I can't categorize it down to one thing, so many aspects of a person attract me. From a distance the way someone moves is one of the first things I notice. I think it's because I am tall and thin and am kinda . . . gawky . . . is the best word. Up closer i have to look for a smile, a smile that reaches her eyes. I swear to god iits one of the first things I notice. I will happily look at her body, but that's not what captivates me.
Meddle Not In The Affairs of Dragons, for we are Crunchy and Good with Ketchup!
First and foremost - caring about something, someone other than themself. Self-centered, self-righteous, egotistical people are a huge TURNOFF for me. You can have the entire world and all its wealth, but if you have not love, you have nothing of real value.
The eyes will draw me in, a laugh or a smile will help hold my attention but it's a warm, caring heart that will capture mine. Inner beauty always trumps surface looks.
Tantalizing Teasing Temptress
Best way I can describe that would be my dearest and bestest friend Meagananne. Her warmth, friendliness, caring personality, wonderful sense of humor, inner beauty, intelligence and confidence had my attention long before I ever knew what she looked like on the outside. It was her beautiful soul that I was attracted to.
In RL I seem to notice the smile and eyes first . Having caught my attention then I listen for sincerity and warmth. On lush I like to observe over a period of time for consistency in character then get to know over time.
The beauty of a sunset that touches millions of lives. The beauty of an amazing song that touches the inner soul. The beauty of my daughter singing and practicing, giving her all as if millions are listening, yet she is only singing in the bathroom. True beauty people comes from the inside, comes from our heart and soul. To truly be beautiful inside and out, one has to showforth the actions regardless if they are ever recognized . Without inner beauty we are just dust that is here today and gone tomorrow. My other beautiful daughter with Down Syndrome is truly beautiful because she knows how to love deeper and care for others with more purity than any other human I have ever met. She often makes me question myself as to who actuality has the disability me or us so called typical people or her. Outter beauty can only exsist if inner beauty is ther first.
Another wonderful Forum thread Oli! Thank-you! I think as others have touched on here, it's a multi-faceted thing for me with really two steps, there does need to be some level of physical attraction, and as Bethany noted, that really varies from person to person. I usually need something physical to attract me, but then what really matters is how attractive that person is on the inside. I personally smile lots...and I can be drawn to another who has a bright smile, but if she isn't really smiling inside then she's not for me. True inner beauty must be there. A woman can be physically stunning but if I see she's mean (mean people really suck), selfish, arrogant, rude, hurtful, judgmental or vindictive she's really in the ugly category for me.
A person's eyes have always spoken to me, especially those whose eyes light up when they smile. That beauty has now become even more evident in the time of this pandemic as you must look into someone's soul solely through their eyes, now that their face is hidden and voice muffled. So now my infatuation with eyes has become a study in who someone is, but the way their eyes interact with me and the story that they tell, the window that they provide into who that person truly is.
So yes, a smile warms my heart, but the right look from someone's eyes, stirs my soul...
I believe that the beautiful person always sees the beauty of the others, It is a mixture of many.
The beautiful person never lets down or runs down others for any reason. An attractive, sincere, kind, caring, genuine, who is with a beautiful heart consider as a beautiful person as per my opinion.
The person who can make my world beautiful is the most beautiful person.
Her tenderness, her caring, her passion, and her love!
The way she expresses and shows her feelings and thoughts.
All expressed in her dazzling smile and those endlessly deep green eyes which trap you, hold you and pulls you into their depths. (I happily drown there every day)
Eyes which convey all that feeling and emotion and also express that wonderful inner Joie de vivre!! Always!
While fully endorsing the comment made by Nicole here agree with the comment made by Donna L as well.
For me an attractive person with a kind heart and a beautiful soul is a beautiful person.
Very hard to find but exist
I don't know if you can narrow it down too much. I think the most beautiful people are those who are open and kind but I do admit that if you have an amazing face and body, it will snag your attention right away. It will not keep it if you are mean or petty. I think most of use are beautiful in our own way (and sometimes, in our own time).
i need our personality's to click, before looks
there could be the most handsome guy in front of me, but if hasnt got a good personality it makes things quite dull lol
Sense of humor, charisma, intelligence and candor
one's inner soul one can try to hide it but their inner soul always comes out to play
My latest love poem has landed
Lover Moon
https://www.lushstories.com/stories/love-poems/lover-moon.
Kindness. Confidence. Intelligence. Humor. Honesty.
And yeah, physical beauty is important too, but only after the other checkboxes have been ticked.
) but only someone with a kind personality who has hobbies that match up with mine will keep my interest. Sex has to be good too. Mutual enjoyment is important to me. 
I'd love to taste that sweetness! 
h, and we must have things in common or else its just sex. Same lifestyle including latex.
)