Ok first off, BLUE BELL if possible. My favorite flavors in order are: coffee or jamoca, chocolate chip cookie dough, chocolate chip, mint chocolate chip, vanilla and cookies and cream. Mmmmmm... ok I think I need some alone time now.
1. Plain and simple peanut butter ice cream. Which, I've never seen sold in stores. I'm not talking about ice cream with peanut butter in it or chunks. I've only ever seen it sold in a little Dairy Shack by my house. Best ever!
2. Ben and Jerry's, to me, is far too expensive for the little things they come in. However, I LOVE the Strawberry Cheesecake one they have. No one else comes close to making it like they do. Trust me, I've looked!
3. Finally, Rocky Road ice cream. It has nuts, marshmallows and it is chocolate heaven. Though, I like the creamy marshmallow one, not the one with actual marshmallow bits.
Okay, I fib. There is a fourth, but I could go without it. If I had to. Sam's Choice makes this really freaking good Coffee and Donuts that is so on point.