Quote by Whiskey_violet
If someone we follow publishes a story in a category we have blocked, do we still get the notification about said story?
good question - i'm not sure, but i will look into it and give you an answer as soon as i have one
Quote by Whiskey_violet
If someone we follow publishes a story in a category we have blocked, do we still get the notification about said story?
You can’t truly call yourself peaceful unless you are capable of violence. If you’re not capable of violence, you’re not peaceful. You’re harmless.
Quote by sprite
good question - i'm not sure, but i will look into it and give you an answer as soon as i have one
You can’t truly call yourself peaceful unless you are capable of violence. If you’re not capable of violence, you’re not peaceful. You’re harmless.
Quote by sprite
we really get that this wasn't going to be a popular move - to be fair, i'd been pushing Nikki to do this for a while, not because i was a fan, but i wanted to see Lush stay solvent. her deciding to bring them back wasn't a decision she wanted to make.
the reality is that we were probably the only erotica website that didn't post the I stories - certainly the only site of this size, and it was hurting us a great deal. web traffic is what pays the bills. ours dropped by 50% after we stopped publishing those stories. 50% that hurt, especially when we went ahead and added servers anyways, just so this site could keep growing. i am deeply humbled to hear that people would have paid more for memberships, but really, it's still peanuts compared to the revenue we need to keep things running, let alone, growing as we'd like. "porn" sites don't generate the ad dollars that they used to, especially if their web traffic is decreasing rather than growing. it's as simple as that.
yes, it sucks. yes, i wish we didn't have to, but we do - the decision was not made lightly, but it was made.
Quote by sprite
this is a privately owned website with TOS which people agree to abid by when they sign up. one of the stipulations is that certain subjects are not tolerated. is one of them. the stories we publish are fantasies. pure and simple. we do not condone the practice in real life.
Quote by spriteu
'
there was, actually, an annoucement. and, as for as forum posts, it's still not acceptable - only in stories, which are easily blocked.
to address people's concerns. that same standard that applies to other stories applies here. we only accept well written stories. consent is still necessary, the age rule still applies.
bottom line, tho, is i know the stats. the decision really came down to this - either Lush restated this particular category or it eventually we closed the doors. we lost a lot of traffic, which means ads and revenue. that paid member system helped, but the percentage of paid members vs un-paid and non-members is a huge gap. the servers cost, the contests cost, etc etc. personally, i prefer taking on stories over losing what i consider to be the internets best erotica site.
Quote by Simplicity
As an victim, I find this appalling that you would allow this category. You say you dont justify it in real life... only as a fantasy .. well it was my father’s fantasy too, yet I had to suffer this all my life!!!! So since you are saying fantasies are okay.. does this mean fantasies and forced sex fantasies are acceptable because they are “Fantasies.” Why arent they allowed?
You can’t truly call yourself peaceful unless you are capable of violence. If you’re not capable of violence, you’re not peaceful. You’re harmless.
Quote by Simplicity
As an victim, I find this appalling that you would allow this category. You say you dont justify it in real life... only as a fantasy .. well it was my father’s fantasy too, yet I had to suffer this all my life!!!! So since you are saying fantasies are okay.. does this mean fantasies and forced sex fantasies are acceptable because they are “Fantasies.” Why arent they allowed?
Quote by JWren
u
All sane people understand when decisions are made for financial reasons. It's a pity this wasn't made abundantly clear rather than reintroduced behind the shield of 11 new categories. That's how it felt to me.
Also, it's good to read in a subsequent comment, that you don't condone in "real life." It sadly occurs in life, that's why it's illegal in vast swathes of our planet. Erotica is one thing, illegal perversion is quite different.
You can’t truly call yourself peaceful unless you are capable of violence. If you’re not capable of violence, you’re not peaceful. You’re harmless.
Quote by Milik_the_Red
You make a valid point here. The reasons for banning or allowing the return of the once banned genre would be the same for allowing or banning forced sex. It too is very popular on sites where it’s allowed. Personally, I dislike censorship and so I am not offended by either type as long as it IS only a FANTASY. So, why is offending the living hell out of one group okay, yet protecting the sensibilities of another unthinkable?
That’s the slippery slope we are on now and refusing to talk about it won’t make things better.
You can’t truly call yourself peaceful unless you are capable of violence. If you’re not capable of violence, you’re not peaceful. You’re harmless.
Quote by sprite
'
there was, actually, an annoucement. and, as for as forum posts, it's still not acceptable - only in stories, which are easily blocked.
to address people's concerns. that same standard that applies to other stories applies here. we only accept well written stories. consent is still necessary, the age rule still applies.
bottom line, tho, is i know the stats. the decision really came down to this - either Lush restated this particular category or it eventually we closed the doors. we lost a lot of traffic, which means ads and revenue. that paid member system helped, but the percentage of paid members vs un-paid and non-members is a huge gap. the servers cost, the contests cost, etc etc. personally, i prefer taking on stories over losing what i consider to be the internets best erotica site.
Quote by sprite
the stories on here are consensual.
Quote by Varrick
Whatever arbitrary rules you put in place are irrelevant. Even if you choose to ignore the moral arguments, the fact is that is illegal. I’m not surprised to see members leaving over this issue, and not only because of the subject itself, but because of the inept way it’s been reintroduced.
There was no consultation with members to see if those of us already here wanted such a category. Instead, you’ve chosen to pander to a crowd that mostly aren’t here anymore, and may never be again. We have been treated with disdain, and as I’ve said elsewhere, that is almost as annoying as the reintroduction itself.
You can’t truly call yourself peaceful unless you are capable of violence. If you’re not capable of violence, you’re not peaceful. You’re harmless.
Quote by Milik_the_Red
Oh, I’m well aware of that fact. I just find that to be a hypocritical attitude.
You can’t truly call yourself peaceful unless you are capable of violence. If you’re not capable of violence, you’re not peaceful. You’re harmless.
Quote by sprite
*shrugs* i'm more interested in keeping a site, which has some standards (most other erotica sites allow non-consent among other things), healthy. if that makes me a hypocrite... i've been called much worse, and i'm not planning on losing sleep over it.
Quote by Milik_the_Red
Nor am I. I do find the idea of it somehow being more morally acceptable to dip your toe in one cesspool rather than another to be laughably self-deluding. But that is the conundrum of any aspect of censorship, isn’t it?
You can’t truly call yourself peaceful unless you are capable of violence. If you’re not capable of violence, you’re not peaceful. You’re harmless.
Quote by sprite
yes, exactly. a crowd that is no longer here. that's the point to this. and i'm not sure how you've been treated with disdain. we're doing our best to answer questions and to be transparent. here. how would you prefer i handle it? i'm always happy to make adjustments, as long as they're sensible.
Quote by Varrick
You’re obviously ignoring the part where I said they may never be here again. In the meantime, you’ve managed to piss off some of your current members to the point that they are leaving. I’m not sure how that fosters a sense of community or drives traffic to the site.
Not sure how we’ve been treated with disdain? I guess I’ll just repeat the part where I said that current members weren’t consulted to see if those of us already here wanted the reintroduction of such a divisive category. It just happened. And here are Nicola’s words from the announcement thread:
“No discussions about this decision will be entertained. Please do not create forum posts or contact any moderators or I about it.”
Until this thread blew up, that post made it very clear to us plebs that there was no want to answer any questions on the subject.
I think disdain sums all that up rather well.
You can’t truly call yourself peaceful unless you are capable of violence. If you’re not capable of violence, you’re not peaceful. You’re harmless.
Quote by Simplicity
Seems I asked this to be done some time ago. So does this mean ALL categories that are blocked we will not get notified or just ?
You can’t truly call yourself peaceful unless you are capable of violence. If you’re not capable of violence, you’re not peaceful. You’re harmless.
Quote by sprite
we would all love to live in a black and white world where there was right and wrong and no degrees in between. i like to think that we have worked hard to create a site that is more than just erotica. it's become a community with very real friendships, and even relationships, forged. we've managed to pair dirty stories with threads that support women's issues and mental health and that actually takes a stance on things like non-consent and harassment. no, we don't have a perfect record, but we do try, and i like to think that makes us stand out a little. personally, i'd rather dip my toe in the cesspool a bit rather than start posting at a site that doesn't give a shit - and if lush stops existing, that, or not publishing stories at all, would be my only choice.
it is becoming uncomfortably close to sink or swim, and i prefer to swim, even if the water is a bit smellier than i'd prefer. trust me, i'm not deluding myself, i'm simply making the best choice i can from the options provided, as should everyone else. if people have an issue with it, then they need to decide if the negatives outweigh the positives and, if they do, they need to decide where to go from there. no one's making anyone stay here if they feel it no longer is comfortable. that said, this is exactly why people have the option of blocking story categories.
Quote by Varrick
Not sure how we’ve been treated with disdain? I guess I’ll just repeat the part where I said that current members weren’t consulted to see if those of us already here wanted the reintroduction of such a divisive category. It just happened. And here are Nicola’s words from the announcement thread:
“No discussions about this decision will be entertained. Please do not create forum posts or contact any moderators or I about it.”
Quote by Milik_the_Red
So I say now, even though I agree in adding the new genre, that trying to say we are protecting women’s issue while allowing is farcical.
Quote by sprite
and i like to think that anyone who knows me just a little would be aware that i would be happy to answer questions and/or concerns, as best i could, either in private or here, as i am attempting to do now.
Quote by Varrick
current members weren’t consulted to see if those of us already here wanted the reintroduction of such a divisive category.
Quote by Milik_the_Red
It still all comes down to choice, and remember, I am actually in support of the change. I understand your points of supporting woman’s issues. I was here, working behind the scenes with you for years in the fight. Also, I was the one who first purposed the LGBTQ forum, something I was grilled unmercifully for right here on Lush. I consider this to be my greatest contribution to the site. So yes, I totally understand that Lush is more than a simple erotic literature site.
As a mod, I put aside my inherent libertarian bent. I was part of a group that had to look out for the site and put it above my own views and I did. Okay, now I’m just a member and I won’t sell my views short anymore. So I say now, even though I agree in adding the new genre, that trying to say we are protecting women’s issue while allowing is farcical. Most victims of are female after all, we are fooling ourselves if we try to find any moral high ground. We are dancing with the devil here and choosing only one song to dance to is no less a sin.
You can’t truly call yourself peaceful unless you are capable of violence. If you’re not capable of violence, you’re not peaceful. You’re harmless.