Join the best erotica focused adult social network now
Login

What was it that made up your mind to try anal the first time?

last reply
21 replies
2.0k views
0 watchers
0 likes
Lurker
0 likes
I'm pretty sure that my wife knew at some point she was going to have to let me in it. But when we did it, it was a ightly build up for a few weeks before the first fuck. It easn't nearly as painful as she feared. How was it for you?
Rainbow Warrior
0 likes
Curiosity. The first guy that ever asked, I said sure, I'll try it.
Partner-in-Lust / Cummunist
0 likes
Horniness!!
Curiosity is one of those insatiable passions that grow by gratification.
Mana wahine
0 likes
I'm open to trying most things. Saw it in porn, asked my partner if he wanted to try it, he said yes, so we did.
Sensual Hobgoblin
0 likes
A combination of horniness, alcohol, some curiosity, and being convinced that the guy in question would do exactly what I wanted/said. The first time wasn't great but it wasn't awful either. It led to other times that hooked me.

I just published a new story, https://www.lushstories.com/stories/reluctance/naked-and-afraid A wife is home alone when two criminals break in to rob her. She's afraid and that's when it gets interesting A super story full of great sex, with a BDSM slant, that will hold your interest.

An oldie but goodie, https://www.lushstories.com/stories/monster-sex/the-emerald-lagoon An Editor's Pick from a comp a couple of years ago.

If you enjoy either, please comment. My ego needs a boost, ha! Thanks.

Active Ink Slinger
0 likes
Pretty sure alcohol was involved.
Lurker
0 likes
She was my 1st gf who was really into strapon's and she made a few comments about my ass. and told her it was all hers take it. so she did. Hurt some but in a good way and have loved it ever since
Lurker
0 likes
I trusted him. He loved me. I wanted to be used. He wanted me. He was a church boy and I gladly submitted
Active Ink Slinger
0 likes
I kept hearing from friends in high school how nice it was, how good it felt, and how safe it was to basically fuck and not worry. I'm sort of small, and my anus is small and tight, and I'm not a huge fan of pain, or of poop either. Every guy I "invited" to try back there was too big, or I just turned chicken. Until one guy, freshman year in college .... the first time I saw his cock (to give him a bj ) I saw that it was long and thin - probably the thinnest I've ever seen ... so very shortly after that, I invited him back there, and with lots of lube and patience, he got in.

Personally, I did not really enjoy it ..
Easily amused
0 likes
The VERY FIRST TIME I had sex, the girl stuck her finger in my ass while we were fucking and I loved it. So anal play has always been in the mix, and because it was my first time, anal has always had a real erotic charge to it.

Tintinnabulation - first place (Free Spirit)
Comet Q - second place (Quick and Risqué Sex)
Amnesia - third place (Le Noir Erotique)

Active Ink Slinger
0 likes
Quote by Guest
I'm pretty sure that my wife knew at some point she was going to have to let me in it. But when we did it, it was a ightly build up for a few weeks before the first fuck. It easn't nearly as painful as she feared. How was it for you?


It was done with me in my drunken state when we had sex after coming home from a wedding
I was dressed like Indian bride and was horny as hell
We had had wild oral sex and in the midst of my orgasm he took advantage and forced into my saliva lubed hole
I gave approval and it felt not bad
But i couldn’t empty my bowels next morning due to great pain
He didn’t try it for some time but i guess after a couple of months or so he again insisted and I never said no after that
(Need to mention that he is less than 5 inches when erect)
Active Ink Slinger
0 likes
My boyfriend at the time desired it. He had asked many times before I finally gave in. The first time was very painful. I tried to crawl out from under him to escape. It took considerable time to get him inside me too. I guess I was a tight ass.
Sexy Seductive Siren
0 likes
Wanted to relive my first vaginal experience (long story) and my boyfriend suggested anal which we ultimately did, four months after it was brought up the first time. My first story in Lush was about my anal experience, my second about my vaginal experience. Being my first story, not as good as it could be, but my first and to date, only, Famous Story.
Meagan
Voyeur @ f/64
0 likes
The $50,000 cashiers check didn't hurt and neither did her little Slimmy with plenty of lube.
Rookie Scribe
0 likes
I mean my policy is try anything thrice… Definitely glad i tried anal.
Lurker
0 likes
After my son was mature enough to move out on his own my husband and I got a book that focused on every imaginal sex position and related topics. We decided to try as many as we could. That opened up a lot of doors for us including my back door.JeT2jyicJKYsuIO1
0 likes

I jokingly said, “you first” to BF and he called my bluff! I fucked his ass with my vibe and got so turned on I honored the dare…not a regular thing but if I’m a bit buzzed and horny I like his cock in my ass!

Lurker
0 likes
That it was a cocky coworker who asked. Dirty as hell asking someone else's wife, I liked his cheek.
Active Ink Slinger
0 likes
I’ve been playing with my ass since middle school. However, one day a few years ago I just decided fuck it I wanted real cock in my ass so I visited an adult bookstore. When I walked in to a booth of 3 naked guys engaged in threesome. I asked if I could join. They said sure. I proceeded to strip naked and knelt down and began sucking the guy in the middles cock. The guy on right got up and began sucking me, eating and licking my asshole. He then asked me if he could fuck me and I said absolutely. He slid into my asshole easily and began pulling on my nipples. The rest is a blur. We had a decent audience for our freaky fuck fest. Multiple guys were jerking off watching us fuck. I took many guys in my mouth and ass. That was a hot sexy day. Don’t know how many men came on me came in my mouth and filled my ass w cum! It was so hot being a slut. Major fantasy fulfilled. Next time I may cross dress? You know heels stockings garter maybe a dress etc...
Advanced Wordsmith
0 likes

I actually did anal before vaginal because it carried a 0% chance of pregnancy. The guy I was with did not seem to mind.

Active Ink Slinger
0 likes

I'm very experimental and like to try new things. That's how we learn what we like and don't.